New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Posts

M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#1

M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Edward in Vancouver

Been going through the archives and related links finding out all I can about this little creature.

Why do I want one?

By daylight, I make chocolates and bars. Over the past year or so, I "figgered it out" that it I made a merchandising stand for my bars, the stores I supply would sell more. They do. I make the merchandisers out of Home Despot spruce 1 x 12's, but try and work in as many curves as possible. The merchandisers are 3 tiered affairs, each tier holding 8 boxes of 12 bars each. They are appreciated by store managers and are a welcome change from the regular cardboard or welded steel wire affairs. However I have to stick to cheap spruce since some of them get damaged, taken home by staff, or in one case, get stained red by the store manger (looks like he77, but if it sells my stuff, I'm not complaining).

What I've been dong in the past was to b.saw out the sides, spoke shave one side panel smooth, and then use a tailed router with a pattern bit to copy and clean up the other side panel. (In retrospect, maybe I should make a pattern...) I hate routers, and I hate the fact they burn the cheap spruce and chew up end grain. Then I figured if I clamped both sides together in the vice and used my #62 spokeshave I could clean up both edges at the same time just as fast---except for the tight radiuses. Sandpaper sucks, and I haven't bought a spindle sander yet, and don't really want to either

"Real" M.F. cigar shaves are hard to come by, last one I saw on the 'net was around $80, two weeks ago but no idea how badly the blade or mouth was chewed up. I'm a total eejit when it comes to bidding on da bay, and have no idea how to use snipe software.

While "researching" I came across only one modern reproduction, the "round shave" by woodjoy tools. Price is a fair $89

Has anyone else used a reproduction? How hard are they to set up, and how hard are they to figure out the bevel and mouth opening?

Regards,

Edward in Vancouver

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Jack Guzman from Maine

In my experience the cigar shave is a fussy little monster. I have an original and a reproduction. The reproduction works fine but either one is tricky to set up and to use effectively. I almost never use mine. I prefer cleaning tight radiuses with a fine auriou rasp following with scraper or sandpaper.---Jack

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#3

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Neal in San Jose

Have to agree with Jack. I also have an original and a reproduction; I can get 'em to work on perfectly straight grain going down hill but anything else I'm reaching for a rasp or a scraper. I like making cabriole legs and have no problem getting my L.V. round bottom shave to work, but once the curve is tighter than what it will handle, I go to a rasp or a cabinet scraper. Save your money unless you are a very patient person.

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#4

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Same experience as Neal and Jack. I have the Kansas City Toolworks version. Works OK in downhill grain and not-too-hard wood. Blade attachment too weak for heavy duty, like hardwood end grain. And it is definitely a finishing type tool; you won't remove much wood with it.

You can get in pretty tight with an LN round-bottomed 'small bronze shave', or a similar Preston if you find them cheaper. Truly though, a cabinetmaker's or half-round rasp will get you to your pencil line faster and cleaner. Follow up with PSA sandpaper wrapped around a pipe section or broom handle etc. Or scrape.

Wiley

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#5

Make your own shave

Ron Harper

John Gunterman has a free set of plans on the net. You can easily tweak his plan to make your shave cut a pretty tight radius. It is not hard. You can easily build the shave in an evening.

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#6

Re: Make your own shave

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for the replies.

A good rasp costs a little more than a cigar shave plus it can be used for a lot of other things, so that looks like a route that I'll probably take. Making my own shave is something I never thought of.

Thanks again

Edward

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#7

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have one of these useless tools that I have been meaning to sell. I never found anything it did acceptably. Maybe pine if I worked any.

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#8

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Doug Trembath

Edward, my experience with exotic shaped spokeshaves mirrors some of the other posters you have heard from. It's especially difficult to make them work on the softer species you are using on this project. They have to be incredibly sharp and oriented exceptionally well to the grain to be successful, and are just too finicky for me...

If it was me, (and yes, I know it isn't...) I'd stick with the original setup, except do as you indicated, and form up a template from 1/4" tempered hardboard, and use the router. Yes, this is the hand tools board, but the sales stands you are building don't need to last for centuries, right?

That being said, the spruce, pine and fir you find at the BORG will cut very nicely if you bandsaw close to the template line, and run the piece with the template bradded to the piece following the bearing and run it with light, quick passes. DAMHIKT, OK? The only time the SPF burns in my experience, is if the bit is dull, or sits in the same spot too long.

I think we all at one time or another have occasion to build something we don't intend to spend a whole lot of effort and time on, and the tailed tools do help out with those projects when in need.

Hope it goes well for ya...

Doug Trembath

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#9

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Edward in Vancouver

Just finished a "rush order" stand last night.

I've got no qualms using power tools like the T.S., B.S., and lunch-box planer, but I just plain hate the router, never have made friends with it. I probably do have dull bits, and probably was taking a big "bite" with it, but the (deleted) thing just eats and burns borg-bought spruce. The only thing I'm comfortable doing with that (deleted) router is rounding over hard edges

What I ended up doing was bandsawing as close as I could to the line, using a block plane and the round-bottom shave on two ganged-up side panels (goes just as fast as a router) and then for the tight radiuses, used my 70's era Craptsman tube bed lathe....

I needed a spindle sander and wasn't going to mess around with a broomstick and sandpaper, but in the end that's what I did. At a garage sale last year I bought 2 dzn 80 grit sanding belts and 2 dzn 120 grit sanding belts for the princely sum of $5.00. I cut a belt in half, ripped it into 3/4" strips, and spiral wrapped the strip around a broomstick that I had previously wrapped in double sided tape. A staple in either end, and I chucked the contraption on my lathes. Voilia! A spindle sander--albeit a horizontal spindle sander....

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

#10

Re: M.F. Cigar shave revisited

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Clever trick, the broom handle.