New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Saw diagnosis question

Posts

Saw diagnosis question

#1

Saw diagnosis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi All -

I have finished retoothing and sharpening the no-name saw I mentioned in a post several weeks ago. This has been a experiment and the saw tooth configuration is a bit non-conventional. This saw now has a 30 degree rake, a 25 degree fleam and a 25 degree pitch.

It cuts fine and leaves a very smooth cuts in red oak, but as I pull the saw back through the kerf it develops a pretty pronounced vibration with the blade swinging back and forth as I pull it back to start the next stroke. I thought that I had read that this was a symptom of an insufficient set. I have tried searching the archives, but I can't find anything.

I didn't want to experiment by adding more set until I had first tapped into the forum's collective experience. Can any one help? Is this a problem with the set, or perhaps some other problem?

Thank you for any advice or insights you might offer.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Saw diagnosis question

#2

Re: Saw diagnosis question

Patrick Gibbons

I have found that a few things may cause this. If the track of the kerf changes, and this can be a very slight change, it will cause vibration owing to the saw plate being pinched. I have the habit now of slightly raising the saw as I pull it back. This will alleviate the vibration greatly. Some woods are case hardened, and this will pinch the plate. Some woods saw better with more set to the saw. Wood with a cup, warp, etc will cause the saw to vibrate as you describe sometimes. Try another type of wood and see if you get the same result. A dry hardwood should saw well for you. If not you may need more set. Others may have a better handle on if your tooth geometry is a contributing factor.

Re: Saw diagnosis question

#3

Re: Saw diagnosis question

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I await the diagnosis too. I have a saw that I puchased new back in the 60s for my dad that I inherited. It does the same thing. Factory sharpened and set. Never molested. The grip is really blocky as Disston's later saws weren't very comfortable to use but it does have sentimental value.

Joe

Re: Saw diagnosis question

#4

Re: Saw diagnosis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Patrick. I have been swamped at work and haven't had a chance to make it back in to the shop to test your ideas. But I have just found what I think may have been the original description of this problem that I had seen somewhere online. Below is from the Norse Woodsmith website:

"Stopping the Wubawubawuba

What's the wubawubawuba? It's that annoying vibration the saw makes when you are pulling the saw back up through the cut. What's really happening is the saw is binding in its own cut. There may be several causes: either there isn't enough set on the saw, and it is binding, or the sawyer is pulling the back up at an angle not in line with the cut being made, causing the blade to bind that way. Also, make sure it isn't the wood closing up behind the initial cut, closing itself over the blade.

The fix is first to check your technique, then add a bit of set once you've satisfied yourself that your technique isn't at fault. Use a guide like the ones mentioned on the previous page to help you diagnose your technique."

So, when I get back in the shop I'll check on technique, but I haven't had this problem with my other crosscut saws. If that doesn't work I'll experiment with a bigger set.

Thank you for your post.

Dave

Re: Saw diagnosis question

#5

Re: Saw diagnosis question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Joe -

Thank you for your post. You may have seen in my reply to Patrick above that I think I may have found the where I thought I had seen someone offer some thoughts on this. It is from the Norse Woodsmith's website. If your Dad's saw was new and none of your other saws vibrate like that, I'm guessing it may need a bigger set. But you may want to double-check on your form before you increase the set. Best of luck.

Regards -

Dave