Finish for an oar
Jack Guzman from Maine
A friend asked me to refinish an oar he has that is peeling. The other oar broke and is being replaced with a new one. What kind of finish would have been used on a store bought oar?---Jack
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Finish for an oar
Jack Guzman from Maine
A friend asked me to refinish an oar he has that is peeling. The other oar broke and is being replaced with a new one. What kind of finish would have been used on a store bought oar?---Jack
canoe paddle experience
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have made canoe paddles. I finish them with spar varnish except the handle, which I leave unfinished or oiled with linseed or tung. Every few years they will need to be refinished.
As far as what the factory used it is probably something that you can't buy in less than 55 gallon drums.
Re: Finish for an oar *LINK*
John in NM
Why not ask the vendor of the new one?
This place refers to "specially formulated marine varnish", sounds like spar varnish really.
We used to live near their shop. Got a lot of kindling out of the scrap pile 
http://www.shawandtenney.com/index.php
Re: Finish for an oar
Bruce McCrory
Marine varnish, which is spar varnish (flexible) containing higher percentages of UV inhibitors/blockers. Your best bet is to get it at a boat supply store. It is not cheap.
That said, I research things to death. Settled on Epiphanes (sp) and epoxy for two cedar chairs. Neither really worked to seal the wood, but I ran out of patience after three coats of varnish; and, epoxy is time limited, besides acting like butter in the first place. Water-based, two-part poly is not ready for general use, and definitely not ready for marine environments.
I think manufacturers dip the oars into finish. The target depth of varnish approaches 1/16 inch on boats which is about 12 coats. A good sanding and two toppers are required every working season to restore from UV damage; and a complete redo every 10 to 15 years.
This is why wood is relegated to rich hobbyists.
Interesting customer comments
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
for these products sold by Jamestown. Lots of specific detail:
Wiley
Yupper ! . . .
steve mackay
These have gotten spar varnish every four or five years for 40 years that I can vouch for. It's what Dad taught me and still work'n.
Re: Finish for an oar
Tom
So you first off have to look at the intended use. Being in maine, you have an actual real boat culture there. Paint is the obvious choice for that. But if you want a clear finish, then spar varnish is the way to go. If you go for spar varnish, you have a range of choices. There are modern super finishes, these are great but less good for an oar since it is likely a big baulk of wood so you can't control the fact it will expand and contract, so you are into a traditional varnish. If it was composite wood construction you could take the more modern finish path. So if you want to use trad vanishes, you can go local hardware store, or Marine store. The "best" varnish from a marine store, in trad form is arguably "Z" Spar Captains varnish. Not only does it last a heckl of a long time, but I still have the remnants of the first can I bought over 30 years ago, I keep it at the cottage, and it is still good to go. You want to follow the instructions but I would normally thin with a bit of the correct reducer, and apply a coat to clean wood, then topcoat. However there are usable products in the hardware store, just be sure you are getting a good quality finish with lots of solids. They won't perform up to a Z Spar, but they will do OK. If you really want UV protection you need paint. The varnish will not last and for yachts stored out of doors they will need constant work. So I only varnish stuff that I store indoors.
Interesting thing about a Maine type marine culture is that even in a state that was not always the richest, you see consumption patterns for the most expensive varnish products because people living close to the water know the value of it.
Another option is to coat with epoxy and then topcoat with varnish.
I actually got into woodworking in order to make technical canoe paddles, and then canoes. If I can find it I have a pic of my second paddle and my first canoe that I designed and built, back in the 70s. The only thing I would add to Bill's oil and varnish deal is that if you sand your varnish where the lower hand goes, it will be far less likely to blister you. One might expect the opposite, that a glossy finish would be the easiest on the hands, but it isn't. Cut back the shine with 360, used wet.

Thanks folks
Jack Guzman from Maine
I appreciate all the responses. I just happen to have a can of spar varnish on hand. Even though I'm in Maine I'm nowhere near the ocean. It's all woods around here.---Jack
Re: Thanks folks
Tom
Lakes and streams count too!
Re: Interesting customer comments *LINK*
William Duffield
It's curious that Wiley's link to Jamestown doesn't list Sikkens Cetol Marine on that page, because JD does carry it. It has always been my choice for spar varnish.
Sikkens Cetol
ordinary poly
Jerry Gibbs
If the paddles are to be stored out of the sunlight, I would use ordinary polyurethane. Those expensive marine "varnishes" are trying to deal with uv rays. I have a cedar strip built canoe covered in epoxy that needs uv protection. I used poly and keep the canoe covered when not in use. The short time the canoe and paddles are exposed to sunlight is not a problem. Jerry
Re: Thanks folks
Jack Guzman from Maine
I agree but my point was that being in the woods I don't get as much exposure to marine type woodworking as would a coastal Mainer. ---Landlubber Jack
Re: ordinary poly
Bruce McCrory
Isn't Poly considered a hard finish? Not flexible, like the marine varnishes? It's considered much more durable than varnishes, but in an interior application.
Re: ordinary poly
Tom
You are both right. The marine varnishes are supposed to be soft. But there are plenty of products that are used in the out of doors that get by without it. There are two ranges of reasons I would guess. One is boats that are built in the proper way using stuff like epoxy and fiberglass and lamination. So one rule is no elements thicker than .75". Anything thicker than that gets laminated. Or as in the gunnels of a canoe, it might be discrete enough to get marine poly or varnish. The other catagory is stuff like bows, or paddles, etc... that are really indoor items, that get taken out of doors for occasional use. Oars tend to be heavy and large, and are often stored with the boat out of doors. Paddles, though some get tossed under overturned canoes, I always store indoors.
There is stuff that is breaking all the rules but one gets away with it. Bows are an example. A catalysed varnish that is very popular for them is Fullerplast. Apparently the manufacturer has repeatedly warned people that it is completely inappropriate for bows because they bend, but it remains one of the industry standards. Presumably part of the reason that this works up to a point is that "wooden" bows of the backed with fiberglass type are pretty much 90% surface areas is 50 thou thick glass. the handles are often resin impregnated diamondwood, etc... So what kind of material is it really.