New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Stanley 42 saw set question

Posts

Stanley 42 saw set question

#1

Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi All -

It has been a while since my last foray, but I am diving once again in the waters of saw sharpening. I just finished a George Bishop 5 1/2 PPI rip saw and I am very pleased with the outcome. All my previous efforts were with much smaller PPI saws and while the sharpening did improve the saw's performance, I was not totally thrilled with the outcome.

But now I am taking another step. I am taking a no-name 8 PPI saw that was filed rip and repointing it as cross cut. I am using a standard peg tooth configuration simply because none of my other saws have that configuration and its is really easy to keep the top of the file flat (or perpendicular) relative to the blade.

But I digress....my question is: I have a Stanley 42 sawset and I am trying to figure out how to use it. I have a couple of other saws (a Stanley handyman sawset, and a couple of Morrill style sawsets). All of my other sawsets have the number of PPI stamped into the sawset so you know how much to set it. But I can't find any such numbers on my Stanley 42. I do see four groves (?) in the side of the anvil, and clearly one adjusts the depth of the set by moving the anvil up and down. But how do you know when you have it in the right place for a 8 PPI saw such as the saw on which I am working right now?

I used the Stanley handyman on the rip saw, but wanted to use the 42 on this saw because the handle is so much easier to clamp shut and make the set...and my hand was getting tired after using the handiman (and the Morrill styles seem so much less comfortable to use).

I'm not complaining because I am blessed to have sawsets, but any help or advice would be much appreciated. Thank you.

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#2

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

My Stanley 42 has marks on the "dial" at the "barrel" end of the sawset, ranging from 4 to 16 TPI. Loosen the screw, rotate the dial to the proper setting, and tighten the screw. That's it.

Do you have a picture of your sawset? Just curious...

DC

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#3

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question *LINK*

Chuck Bjorgen

I have the Stanley 42x saw set with a scale similar to yours. It's sort of a trial and error method to determine the correct setting. Here's a link to the Vintage Saws web site that describes using a micrometer to measure the thickness of the saw plate compared to the thickness at the teeth caused by setting. This system makes a lot of sense to me.


Saw setting

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#4

Re: trial and error..

david weaver

...you might want something different than the preset amounts, regardless of what the set says. Start small and set a quick pass with the set, try it and adjust as needed.

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#5

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Marv

Hi Dave,

The amount of set you will want on your 5PPI rip saw or your 8PPI crosscut will be determined by whether you will be sawing dry wood or wet green wood. Generally speaking, setting the teeth for wet green wood will be the exception. The location of the anvil on your 42X should start down at the bottom line. First set a few teeth back at the heel of the saw so you can see how much you are bending the teeth. In any case, you want a minimum amount of set, just enough so the blade does not bind or drag in the kerf. The amount of bend in the teeth will be very little. So go ahead and set all the teeth so you see only about .005 per side. That will not be too much for either saw. For backsaws, the amount of set is even less.

As for saw sets that have numbers on the anvil, those numbers should not be used to determine set for any particular tooth count, like your 8PPI saw for example. Those numbers always put too much set in the teeth. Use the numbers only for reference.

Marv

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#6

Note that there are several No. 42 saw sets

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...very different from each other. It might help if you knew which one you have; the alphabetical suffix (X, W, etc.) is what distinguishes the model numbers.

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#7

Re: Note that there are several No. 42 saw sets

Marv

Bill,

Dave described the 42X :|

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#8

You're right

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I realized I was responding to some of the replies that were referring to other models of 42.

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#9

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

With this type of saw set the angle of set is constant; it is the face angle of the two parts of the set, the plunger and the anvil. The way we regulate the amount of set is by bending more or less of the tooth.

Put the saw in the slot of the saw set. If the bottom of the anvil coincides with the bottom of the tooth, then that is the maximum the tooth can be set. If we turn the screw and raise the anvil to the point that the bottom of the anvil is at the middle of the tooth's height, then only the top half of the tooth will be bent, resulting in more moderate set.

When sharpening saws for our own use we generally do not set the saw every time. So the set decreases gradually with several sharpenings until it has to be renewed. For this reason if you should find that you set it more than you need or like, it will improve the next time you sharpen it. Also different woods have slightly different needs for amount of set.

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#10

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Denis -

First, thank you for your post. Second, I am going to try to post a picture of the sawset. I don't think I have this pic thing down. I have tried to resize it so I think it will work, but I don't think the files are small enough to post all three pics so I will spread them out among everyone's replies as each pic seems most appropriate.

You will note that my sawset has no dial.


I appreciate your taking the time to post.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#11

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you for the link, Chuck. From many of the replies I see that this is mostly trial and error, and I am fine with that. Still I like the micrometer idea and will probably use it as I go through the trial and error.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#12

Re: trial and error..

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, David. I will give it a try. This is a learning process for me so I am happy to experiment until I find what works.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#13

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Marv -

I appreciate your thoughtful suggestions and I will give them a go. I am not sure my sawset is a 42X. I think it may be a plain vanilla 42, but I will post a close up of the handle in one of the posts below.

Thank you and regards -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#14

Re: Note that there are several No. 42 saw sets

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Bill -

Here's pic of the handle:


Are you able to read it? It looks to me like all it says is "Stanley No. 42." Is there some other way to determine the "letter" that might go along with this particular version?

Thank you for your post -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#15

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Hi Warren -

Thank you for your post. As I mentioned I have changed the tooth configuration from rip to a peg in preparation for experimenting with this as a crosscut saw I am working on right now. So I have done ALOT of filing and there's very little set still left in the teeth.

Here is a close up of the anvil and the markings I mentioned.


This pic doesn't provide a very good angle to see the hammer, but it sounds like the main thing is the see where the two connect in relation to the tooth.

Thank you for taking the time to post.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#16

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Marv

Dave,

That looks to be just a 42 with no letter after the number. The 42X is much smaller and has a plunger that presses against the blade just before the hammer moves in and bends the tooth. Your 42 is a little trickier to use and is meant for the larger teeth such as 5PPI for example.

Marv

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#17

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Patrick Gibbons

Your saw set looks different from mine. The picture below shows the underside where it says 42X. The box and directions do not have the x anywhere.


img

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#18

Another picture 


img

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#19

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons

Yours is a 42 (no x, w or any other letter). Here is a website I found with pictures.


http://members.acmenet.net/~con12a/saw%20set%20website/plier1.htm

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#20

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Marv

Thank you Patrick, that really explains a lot when it comes to the Stanley saw sets. I bookmarked that page. I'll use that in the future. Questions like Dave's comes up quite often in various woodworking forums. Wish I had, had this kind of information back when I was trying to find the best saw set to use. I now have a small pile of dust collectors that never get used. The 42X is the one I use the most. I have a second one that I modified the hammer on so it will easily set the smaller backsaw teeth.

Marv

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#21

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Dave, as you may have figured out, your set as pictured is adjusted for setting a saw with large teeth. You will probably want to move the anvil up maybe two lines on the scale for your 8 point saw.

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#22

Thank you.

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you, Patrick. I appreciate the pic. I'll help me know where to look if I ever see one at a flea market...and it confirms what I suspected that I have only a plain, vanilla No. 42.

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#23

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

Thank you for the link, too. The 42 and 42X look pretty similar in the photos, but if you look very closely you can see a few differences.

Dave

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#24

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Dave, I have a 42X that I just got this spring at the PATINA sale. As I changed jobs and am now in Alexandria ( on Little River Tpk) I would be willing to bring it in and you could try it out to see if you need to look for the upgrade. I also have a MF 214 ( I think ) you could play with.

I'm about a mile from 395 toward Annandale.

Regards,

Joe

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

#25

Re: Stanley 42 saw set question

William Duffield

Wow! That improves your commute by an order of magnitude.