New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How Best To Finish Walnut

Posts

How Best To Finish Walnut

#1

How Best To Finish Walnut

Tom Colligan

I've had some pieces out of sunlight and want to use them for a bookcase. One side is what you'd expect walnut to look like but the side that's been exposed to room light has a faded, muddy, brown look to it though it does perk up when sanded.

Is there a way to keep the more attractive hue to walnut? It will be exposed to daylight though not direct sun light. Thanks in advance,

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#2

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

You have discovered why I always stain walnut with a mineral pigment stain. I use the following: Japan Color "burnt umber" and mix it 10% with General finishes "pre-stain wood conditioner" "natural". This is basically the formula used by General Finishes for their oil stains according to a reliable source. The mineral pigments don't fade. The result is shown in Picture 1.



The second picture shows the color of three walnut pieces of various ages, all located in sunny spots. The spice box on top is the oldest, the chest of drawers medium and the out of place drawer front on the left is freshly finished. You can see that with this finishing schedule the walnut stays about the same color.

If you are into minimalist finishing just oiling the piece with linseed oil and then varnishing or not will leave the walnut reasonably colored. This plaque was oiled and varnished in 1959. The oxidized oils are providing the color.


Lacquer over walnut provides the worst result. The walnut bleaches very light and the lacquer yellows resulting in a light yellow-brown effect.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If you are going to stain you need to learn to properly sand. For walnut I typically sand 120 followed by 180, or if necessary 100,120,180. The coarsest sanding needs to remove all machining marks and grain tears for these will show up and be enhanced by staining. I have never successfully pigment stained a planed surface.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#4

Re: Dark Seedlac or Stain

david weaver

Dark seedlac, like Bysakhi.

Though most of the professionally made walnuts I've seen (walnut is or at least was fairly popular for common furniture where I grew up) is stained.

My grandfather had milled a fence row walnut tree into boards several decades ago and left them in a chicken house. Maybe 15 years ago after he died, my parents commissioned a local furniture maker to take the boards and make four tables. They all have a very dark stain on them, and a lacquer topcoat and they all still look great.

If I was making for myself, I'd use dark seedlac as the top coat, and blo under if you want it to be even darker. If I was making it for someone else, I'd probably stain it so that it looked like the tables my parents had comissioned, because it looks more "consumer" and perfectly uniform.

I heard a line from a furniture salesman a couple of years ago when I asked him where their stuff was with solid wood. He pointed the few things out that they had and told me that far and away, people choose stuff with veneer on it because they say they want stuff made of solid wood, but when the rubber hits the road, they don't actually want that because veneered furniture looks more uniform.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#5

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Bill,

What finish/topcoat is on the various stained examples you posted?

Bob in NJ

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#6

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

spice box- shellac

other two- varnish

plaque- varnish

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#7

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut - Thanks


Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#8

More on pigment stains

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Now days "stain" can be a soluble dye made from some synthetic chemicals, a dispersion of finely ground insoluble pigment particles that can be mineral or synthetic chemicals or mixtures of these staining components. I suppose the MSDS could provide a clue as to what was in the can. (definition: dyes are soluble in the formulation, pigments are insoluble in the formulation)

The traditional mineral pigments are typically oxides of iron or manganese. They typically are red, orange, yellow, brown and black hues.

The mineral pigments offer a limited range of color but the colors are permanent. The synthetic dyes and pigments can be mixed to yield any color. They will fade more or less, ranging from insignificant to disaster.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#9

Re: More on pigment stains

Tom Colligan

And just how can one indentify a product that is using mineral pigments in their stains as opposed to synthetic pigments?

How 'bout the common Minwax Wood Finishes? Are these mineral pigments? Thanks,

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#10

Re: More on pigment stains

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I tried to find a MSDS on Minwax stains and did not find anything useful. So, I don't know what is used. A hint would be color range. If a company has oodilins of stain colors and some don't look like dirt it is a good sign that the pigment is some synthetic organic stuff.

If the can settles then the stain is at least partially pigment. If what doesn't settle will stain maple then probably it is a mixture of dye and pigment. But the bottom line is that I can't answer the question. If it works, don't worry about it.

I was told by a reliable source that the General oil pigment stains were mineral based.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#11

Re: More on pigment stains

Bruce McCrory

The same PWM issue which has made Mr. Tindall famous has an article on finishes. I have just this week reviewed the same from "Fine Woodworking's Techniques 3" (a mid-1970's publication).

To find your favorite tint, color, sheen, enhancement, etc., will undoubtedly run into thousands of dollars and a shed's worth of test wood ... Well, maybe, a Woodcraft, or Rockler store's entire supply.

For a home repair project, I grabbed a piece of my existing molding, the unfinished new wood, and took them down to Sherwin Williams to have them do a match. It's not perfect, but for $30 or $40 I have two quarts (stain and poly) to finish the moldings, casings, and trim. Don't waste your time trying to do the same at HD or Lowes (borg?).

And, before I wipe color, I am going to collect a couple oil colors from the art section of Joann's to tweak the finish further.

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

#12

Re: How Best To Finish Walnut

Paul M.

Thanks for this Bill. I'm just embarking upon a walnut project so this was very timely.

I went to my local lumberyard and was looking for the General Finishes stain and there was a General Finishes rep waiting in the aisle just to help people with questions. He confirmed that their oil based pre-conditioner is basically the clear base for all of their oil based stain products, and you could use either that or mineral oil for diluting their stain products. He also confirmed that all of their oil-based stain products are using natural pigments (he actually said dirt-based materials).

I'll be experimenting on offcuts first of course. :D