New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Fodder for the Ash Critics

Posts

Fodder for the Ash Critics

#1

Fodder for the Ash Critics

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


I got the top of what will become a desk laid up. The wood is some curly ash I had sawed when we were sawing lumber for the house some 20 years ago. A few logs had an outstanding curl, equivalent to good maple. These logs were rift cut and this lumber was saved for future furniture.

The only "clamping" pressure for the veneer joints is supplied by the stretchiness of the tape so the joint must be perfectly prepared. I had a time with it. ( the masking tape used to pull the joints together was removed before taking this picture. The veneer tape added to strengthen the joinery is yet to be tediously removed) The top will be framed with not-curly rift cut solid stock with a black string inlay at the joint.

It seems that the thing that is normally done is to glue on the mitered frame, then make the trough and add the inlay at the joint. I would have thought it easier to add the inlay to the frame material, trim and then glue on the mitered frame. It would be a simple matter to rabbit out and 1/8 x 1/8" edge of the mitered frame, add the contrasting wood, trim flush and glue the assembly on. But there must be some not obvious shortcoming of this approach.


The reverse side is some unknown veneer. I have a few hundred sq.ft. of it if someone needs any. I thought to appease the ash haters that I could make the top reversible by attaching it with strong magnets.

On the topic of ash, if you are a young woodworker buy up a large quantity of ash, spray it with persistent insecticide (borers love it) and set it aside. When the Emerald Beetle kills all the American ash it will become valuable.

When we fist got into the lumber business ash and cherry were the same price, and had been for decades. Then for reasons that escape me ash fell out of favor and has remained so ever since. A few years ago I was on a yard that had 200,000 feet of ash logs wasting away. The market was too poor to cover the cost of sawing the logs. Maple, which always had been a utilitarian wood, gained favor as the light wood of choice and its price exceeded ash. For utilitarian industrial purposes we switched our customers from maple to ash.

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#2

Once again...

Bob Hackett

We are talking in terms of what something looks like rather than what something excels at doing.

Ash is not used more simply because A- the grain is very pronounced and B- sooner or later it turns yellow with age despite most people`s best efforts to the contrary.

Most people completely miss it`s redeeming properties because of A and B. among those properties are;

Ash is lighter than hard maple. It`s more flexible than most hardwoods so it bends more easily, especially when steamed. It has more impact and rot resistance than many other woods to name just a few of it`s excellent qualities.

Once we look more deeply into the redeeming qualities of an individual species and perhaps even single trees and consider factors other than appearance alone there are many reasons that Ash makes an excellent choice for many projects.

BTW Bill, I really like the application of the rift sawn Ash in both your recent projects and pics. If I wanted monotone and bland I`d work in either metal or fiberglass and use paint as a finish. I like a wood project to look like wood. I personally feel a wood project should be able to be identified as being made from wood even from some distance. Add this to the list of things that Ash shines at.

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#3

Re: Once again...

Sgian Dubh

" ... sooner or later it turns yellow with age despite most people`s best efforts to the contrary."

Bob, there is of course a solution to that: dye it or stain it, and perhaps even use some grain filler, then polish. That doesn't suit those that want a light coloured or pale wood in a job, but it is one solution, and the chosen colour to change it to doesn't have to be something in the brown area-- black, for one is good, and so is a bronze look, and making it grey with ferrous sulphate are just three options, of which there are several more.

Personally, I'm also fond of polishing ash with no more than a clear finish, even if it does yellow with age. Slainte.

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#4

In my experience it's the finish that yellows

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


The wood itself becomes brownish with time. This floor was finished 21 years ago with a water based acrylic nonyellowing finish that has stayed relatively "water white". Put nitrocellulose lacquer or varnish on ash and the result is distinctly yellow, the color of snowshoes for those familiar.

Never-the-less up until the 1980's ash carried an essentially identical price as cherry. It was regraded as a premium wood. But fashions change. Painted with milk paint and then coated with a clear finish the effect can be striking (at least to some tastes).

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#5

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Looks really good!

You made a query of sorts: "I would have thought it easier to add the inlay to the frame material, trim and then glue on the mitered frame. It would be a simple matter to rabbit out and 1/8 x 1/8" edge of the mitered frame, add the contrasting wood, trim flush and glue the assembly on. But there must be some not obvious shortcoming of this approach. "

I'd also love to hear from someone on this point, who knows the answer. The decision may come down to the most practical way to control the string thickness--"trimming flush" as you put it. If you let the mitered frame carry the string in a rebate, Option A might be to glue the string in the rebate to exact size, and try to plane exactly to it; Option B might be to put the string material in oversize, and plane it (and the frame material) back until the string thickness looks right. Either way presents some tedious planing strokes and maybe measuring thickness along the string.

One other thought occurs. By making two separate operations, if anything goes wrong preparing or installing either the frame pieces or the strings, you just pick up another piece of string or another length of framing stock and you haven't lost much. But if the string is combined with the frame, if anything goes wrong with the frame (stick trimmed too short at the miter, say) then you have more work in that piece that is now ruined, and double work to do to replace it.

Someone will come along who knows the answer!

Wiley

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#6

Re: Ash bugs

Bruce McCrory

Regarding insecticide control in storage, do you need to use a pesticide regimen with an ash floor, too? Besides termite control?

That floor looks great.

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#7

Re: Ash bugs

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I never got the powder post beetles in furniture or the floor. But we have had several hundred bdft of ash lumber destroyed over the years until we learned to control it. By spraying with Lindane as soon as the lumber arrives we have successfully stored the treated lumber for up to decades thereafter. DDT would work too but you would have to make it.

Except for the living room the floors in our house are ash. It was supposed to be milled into 3" strip floor but that is not what happened. The living room floor is flat sawed 4" plank white oak, hand scraped just for grins.

The ash was finished with some acrylic premium crosslinked floor finish. Hated its milky bluish luster, but that was the price of using acrylic water based finish at that time.

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#8

Also....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

if there is any little dinging anywhere along the edge of the main field, which may have occurred in trimming back the main field, or just some random event after it's trimmed, but before you've got the protective frame in place--the stringing gives you a final chance to go back in and restore a crisp edge to the field. Maybe that's how stringing got invented--to fix issues with edges!

Wiley

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#9

Re: Also....

Bob Lang

I also can't see how putting a groove in after the veneered panel and edge frame are together is easier/better/less risky/makes for a nicer finished product. Planing the band down to the back face of the frame would only take a fraction of the time it would to make a perfect groove, size the banding for a perfect fit in the perfect groove (including the length at the corners) then bring the banding back down to the surface. Of course you would get to use more tools, and you'd get to fuss and fret a lot more.

Bob Lang

Re: Fodder for the Ash Critics

#10

Reviewing the situation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bob,

I hear ya. However, Bill said his information was that the standard method in these cases was to retrofit the string (rather than rabbet it into the top inside of the frame). I was trying to account for why that would be so, since it seems almost like a no-brainer to rabbet it into the frame.

Perhaps we could back up a step: Is it a fact that the standard method for stringing these outside borders is to retrofit? (All this discussion pertains to sawn veneer, not 1/42" veneer.)

A similar question arises in the case where there is a cross-band around the margin of the top: Isn't it simplest to apply the inside string to the inside of the cross-band, so as to miter the string and crossband together, install them together, and avoid the retrofit problem of digging a channel into veneer that's already laid down?

Wiley