New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Sharpening files with urine

Posts

Sharpening files with urine

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Sharpening files with urine

Stephen Shepherd

I have heard that the Traditional Method of sharpening old worn files [& rasps] was to soak them in a bucket of urine. Yet I can find no references in literature about this method.

Any idea where the notion came from or how old it is?

Stephen

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#2

Re: Sharpening files with urine

wilbur

Urine is usually slightly acidic, which can lead to sharpening up a rasp the same way a dunk in vinegar can.

As far as historic references in the literature go, my first move would be to ask Stephen Shepherd. Oh, wait... :D

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#3

Could we say

Ron Harper

That tbe dullness gets. Pi--ed off?

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#4

....aged urine..

david weaver

... aged urine and not fresh. I'd imagine that the aged urine is a lot less aromatic, but I've never kept any of it around long enough to know if that's true.

There would be the same issue with any acidic etching, though, that the file would be made more brittle.

I've not been too excited about what phosphoric has done for my files. They do get sharper from the etch, but it is short lived.

Given the cost of files 100+ years ago in relation to a daily wage, though, I'd imagine that you'd stretch them as far as you could even if it wasn't a perfect method.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#5

Re: Sharpening files with urine

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

The only chemical effect that I can imagine would be from chloride. And the problem with exposing a ferrous material to chloride is that some sticks and promotes further corrosion after treatment.

As far as acidity whatever tiny amount would be initially present would be promptly neutralized by the decomposition products of urea.

Citric acid will dissolve iron and the reaction products will be soluble rather than sticking to the iron as "rust". How, or if, this procedure sharpens the file is unclear.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#6

I suppose you'd want a gouty friend for this test

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

since more acidic urine is a common symptom of gout.

Doggone it. Every pun I think of in response to your question is not family-friendly.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#7

No literature reference, but

Chuck Nickerson

I'd suspect access to horses would help in getting enough urine to dunk.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#8

Questions...

John in NM

I've been staying out of this thread, as I figured if I were to etch some files I would simply buy some acid :D I don't have even a shred of Stephen's dedication to period correct methods, and I sure wouldn't want to explain that particular jar of fluid to any visitors :D

I'm curious though, why the etch would make the file more brittle? It is effectively a surface treatment.

How long did you etch for? How dull was the file to start with?

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#9

Re: Questions...

david weaver

I don't know why it makes the file less durable (talking about the phosphor etch, it's the only one that I have experience with).

I'd describe the file used as a half dull file, but I use that as a duration description because I don't know how else to describe it. Just a standard 10" USA made nicholson bastard file.

I soaked each end of the file in phosphor prep for a few hours, I don't remember exactly how many. It was definitely a little sharper, but the sharpness was short lived.

Lant may be a better option because it's much more mild and the etch wouldn't be as deep. I've seen it described not as the way I described phosphoric acid use, but as something that files are stored in.

I think a liquid honer (like boggs) is a lot more practical because it would expose fresh metal without applying a deep etch like phosphoric acid does.

George Wilson explained what the change was in the etched steel and confirmed that I'm not imagining things about the lack of durability.

At any rate, I think that means that the process is better used before a file gets half dull, and with a milder etch like ...well, stale pee.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#10

Re: hydrogen embrittlement..

david weaver

..i finally located what George told me. Files can be weakened by hydrogen embrittlement if they are etched too hard.

I have no clue what that is. I'm sure someone could google it. All it means to me is that refreshed files have sort of stayed semi dull when I've done it due to the etched surfaces not being that durable.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#11

Hmmmm...

John in NM

I would guess that a stronger acid is the ticket, not a weaker one. I've read that the professional method is to use a fairly strong nitric acid for a quick etch, but I have no reference for that on hand. If we assume that penetration depth is a factor in embrittlement, fast would be better.

I was wondering how exactly that brittleness is manifested? Teeth break off? Files are pretty brittle in any case, I've had chainsaw files break from nothing more than being dropped on a concrete floor.

Best I can come up with, just speculating, is that etching does not make the steel brittle - it is already brittle. Most likely it is making the steel porous, like a sponge made of glass compared to a solid block of glass the same size. Seems plausible, but I'm no metallurgist.

I don't know George Wilson.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#13

Re: Hmmmm...

david weaver

George is an old school craftsman. Well, old school and new school. He can make just about anything, from tools to instruments to dueling pistols, either entirely by hand or with extreme precision using machine tools.

I mentioned him only because I usually ping something off of him if I think I'm seeing it. It's likely he can tell you what's correct in practice from about 4 decades of exposure to all of the other craftsmen at williamsburg where he worked.

He's the shop master in this video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K48FezBoPWg

While the video doesn't help explain why he'd know anything about files, it's from 40 years ago. His last rotation at williamsburg was as the toolmaker there.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#14

Hydrogen embrittlement is a big deal, too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The bridge that runs from Oakland, CA to San Francisco, across the bay (thus its name: Bay Bridge) demonstrated in the Loma Prieta quake that it wasn't sufficiently earthquake-proof, so there's been a new bridge a-building for a long time now. A whole bunch of anchor bolts snapped when tensioned, with the leading theory being that the process of hardening and then galvanizing them led to hydrogen embrittlement. Why the engineers did not test some of the bolts to design torque...well, that's an ongoing conversation.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#15

Another wrinkle *LINK*

John in NM

The article in the link is concerned with using HCl to descale high strength fasteners after heat treating. One part of it, that I will also cut and paste, seems to suggest that the embrittlement is temporary when steel is left un-galvanized. Apparently the H diffuses back out at room temperature if allowed to do so (the zinc coating of a galvanized fastener prevents this, leading to the problems Bill describes).

"Initial data points generated brought to light an interesting embrittlement phenomenon, that is room temperature bake or relief is observed on acid cleaned - bare steel samples. An appreciable room temperature diffusion of hydrogen out of the test samples is occurring during the transfer from acid exposure/rinse to actual testing. Since this test program involves no subsequent metallic or sealing coating applied after exposure, a free-surface diffusion gradient is present for hydrogen escape. The diffusion thermodynamics at 75 deg. F room temperature are sufficient for hydrogen migration either out of the samples, or into the samples to concentrations below which embrittling interactions do not occur (embrittlement threshold). It was not desired to add another test variable to this program, i.e. a metallic or other impermeable coating to prevent this hydrogen migration, as metallic coatings would generate additional hydrogen and add another variable difficult to quantify. From the initial stages of the test program, it was found that transfer dwell times of 2 hours or more allowed room temperature relief from embrittlement to occur. It must be emphasized that real world plating shop practices would apply an impermeable coating (at room temperature) quickly after acid clean. Entrapment of hydrogen from the acid cleaning would occur, along with any hydrogen generated during the actual plating process. Baking was not part of this test program, as it is well known that quick elevated temperature baking of bare steel samples would result in rapid alleviation of hydrogen effects."


http://www.omegaresearchinc.com/Publications/getpub.cfm?pub_id=5

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#16

Re: Another wrinkle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Interesting. There's a lot of concern expressed on some fora about hydrogen embrittlement from acid de-rusting - WoodNet, which has developed something of a special focus on saws, contains many a conversation warning against vinegar de-rusting of saws because of hydrogen embrittlement. Sounds like it's not such a big issue. It also sounds like cooking the saws for a bit would be even better.

Makes sense; hydrogen, being the ultimately simple atom, should diffuse pretty easily from anything it doesn't bond to.

I guess this means we shouldn't galvanize our files/rasps/saws/plane irons after de-rusting them in acid washes.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

and an aside...

Jack Guzman from Maine

I seem to recall talk about hydrogen embrittlement after derusting by electrolysis. I'd like to know more about the condition since I still use this process.---Jack

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#18

From what I have been reading...

John in NM

A two hour bake at 200F after treatment will remove the stray H ions.

In most articles, a much longer rest at room temp is also mentioned, up to 30 days. I suspect this option is less well tested, because most research is focused in the fastener industry, and they have no desire to let parts sit around an extra month when they could just bake at a temp low enough to not effect the heat treatment.

I believe this is a non-issue with mild steel, but again that could be a result of the focus of the research more than reality.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#19

Correction...

John in NM

From the articles I've been reading, weaker is definitely better on the acid. A low temp bake is also reported to be effective at eliminating the embrittlement.

Re: Sharpening files with urine

#20

Waste not, want not...