Re: Questions...
david weaver
I don't know why it makes the file less durable (talking about the phosphor etch, it's the only one that I have experience with).
I'd describe the file used as a half dull file, but I use that as a duration description because I don't know how else to describe it. Just a standard 10" USA made nicholson bastard file.
I soaked each end of the file in phosphor prep for a few hours, I don't remember exactly how many. It was definitely a little sharper, but the sharpness was short lived.
Lant may be a better option because it's much more mild and the etch wouldn't be as deep. I've seen it described not as the way I described phosphoric acid use, but as something that files are stored in.
I think a liquid honer (like boggs) is a lot more practical because it would expose fresh metal without applying a deep etch like phosphoric acid does.
George Wilson explained what the change was in the etched steel and confirmed that I'm not imagining things about the lack of durability.
At any rate, I think that means that the process is better used before a file gets half dull, and with a milder etch like ...well, stale pee.