New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

You talked me into it

Posts

You talked me into it

#1

You talked me into it

Ron Harper

Toy chest. Trying to decide about corner joints. Wise heads convinced me that it would be great dovetail practice.

Slightly embarassing to show just how much that is needed. A few more ptactice joints before the real thing should be attempted.


img

Re: You talked me into it

#2

Hang in there!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

It'll get right with practice.

From the photo, looks like the main thing to fix is that pine won't hold its baseline, when the chisel backs up into it. A guide block clamped down on the work, and used to pare the baseline will cure that. Use PSA sandpaper on the bottom so it won't slide--as Krenov suggests in one of his books--or else let the block run up and down on bolts through a base, with wingnuts or whatever to clamp it down. Put a piece of scrap ply under the work to absorb the chisel cut. Set the block so you're starting your cut a few thousandths ahead of the scribe line, not in the scribe line. Work back to the scribe line in thin cuts--no hurry. Guide block material is all around--a 2x scrap jointed and straightened, or a 6/4 to 8/4 block of hardwood, again jointed and straight. One other thought: when sawing the pins, leave all of the mark--the mark is all live wood that belongs in the joint.

Next one's a winner.

Wiley

Re: You talked me into it

#3

Thanks Wiley

Ron Harper

You have a priceless gift. You are an encourager. Would you believe that I do have a 24 inch wide dovetail paring jig. I was in too big a hurry to dig it out for this joint. I shall certainly use it on subsequent attempts. I expect my fourth attempt to be useable, especially for a painted chest. I shall post a pic tomorrw.

Thanks for being so encouraging.

Re: You talked me into it

#4

Re: Thanks Wiley

Patrick Gibbons

Your dovetails look better than mine. I am not the most talented but I don't let that stop me. Pine is soft, obviously. After the glue sets you can take a cross pein hammer and lightly tap the end grain to push it into the gap. Put a little glue in the gap before you begin and tap lightly with the hammer. Plane and sand the hammered wood and the joint looks fine. Derek Cohen demonstrated this in a post last year I think. The main thing is don't worry about it much.

Re: You talked me into it

#5

Report back to Wiley

Ron Harper

Progress. The gap at the top is a boogered up edge that I did not clean up before layout

One more practice joint then the real thing.

Thanks again for the Pep Talk Wiley


img

Re: You talked me into it

#6

Hey, I didn't do anything,

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

You're doing it all! Congratulations, that baseline is really clean now, which tightens up the whole joint. That one is usable, as is.

If I might add one other thought, though it probably is not needed in Ron's case...Ian Kirby gives a useful pointer in his writings. He gives a lot of those IMO, little rifle shots that you don't forget.

What Mr. Kirby said had to do with sawing the tails, in a tails-first situation. Going tails first, sawing the tails is a freeby, you don't even have to mark them as far as functional strength goes. Except for one thing: the cuts across the top (end grain) of the tails board have to be parallel. Parallel saw cuts is the only hard requirement. So he suggested to make the first strokes of your saw cuts defining the tails, with the saw held vertical, not on the slant of the tail. First stroke vertical, so it's true to your mark and square to the face of the board; then having established squareness slant the saw and continue to the scribe line. That first cut is into the waste anyway, if held vertical, so it's not a white nuckler.

I just always found this advice useful, and so include it here, though it's probably old hat to Ron.

Wiley

Re: You talked me into it

#7

Re: Hey, I didn't do anything,

Ron Harper

Glad you reminded me where I learned that. I do tails first for all kinds of reasons. I start my tail cut with as little weight on the saw as possible making sure that I am perpendicular to the face, then move to the appropriate angle.

I remember a book that I have in my library that Kirby wrote on dovetails.

I have to remember to slow down. Caught myself sawing beautifully on the wrong side of the line for pins earlier today. Few things will make you feel dumber.

I just remembered that in the old days I cut two tail boards at a time. I found that it help stabilize the saw as well as save a little time.

Re: You talked me into it

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ian Kirby

Jack Guzman from Maine

His dovetail book got me to cut my first successful dovetails. I still remember what he said about stance and sawing techniques.---Jack