New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

How come my nails bend and screws strip?

Posts

How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#1

How come my nails bend and screws strip?

Bruce McCrory

Are connectors weaker, or is wood harder?

I have been repairing and remodeling my home for several weeks, after insurance cleanup crews tore up several rooms. I have not done heavy carpentry for several years and was astounded by all my nails bending in kiln-dried Hem-Fir.

I gave up on nails after going down to 8d from 16d. Coated nails are a b**** to remove. Now, most connections are 2.5" to 3" deck screws that have to be pre-bored. The other day I bought an impact driver drill to put in drywall screws. Even it is hit-and-miss.

I can blame myself for some of the messy results. I would think that juvenile wood studs are "softer" than old-growth, but I was salvaging and reusing 30-year-old framing, also.

And, now I know why driver bits are sold by the pound, too. [Sarcasm] They strip and shear as often as screws. (I have been nursing a long-shank Phillips driver from Boeing Surplus through several pounds of steel.)

So, am I alone? Do I need to retire from carpentry, too? Is everything from China garbage? And, is there a solution to this dilemma?

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#2

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

Patrick Gibbons

China puts out a lot of junk. Try McFeely's for better screws. So far, I've had good luck with their square drive screws.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#3

Hem-fir can be awfully hard...

John in NM

I remember getting a mix of white fir - basically hem-fir - and local pine when we did our floor. Nails drove trivially easy in the pine, the fir was an absolute pain. Somewhere I still have a pic of a fir 2x10 that had bowed so much in the kiln that it split along the rings.

For 2x4's I tended to look for Canfor wood, Home Depot was selling it at the time. It seemed to be spruce and was almost as nice as pine. Could have been balsam fir too I guess, not sure that they distinguish between them once they are cut.

I think it is the wood more than the screws/nails, just based on similar experiences.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

random musings

Jack Guzman from Maine

Framing lumber today is mostly stuff that would have been wood chips years ago. Everyone these days is using nail guns. I still don't own a framing nailer.They scare me.A finish nail gun however is a great invention.When I do framing I use star drive decking screws with an impact driver. If I get difficult wood I predrill. Hammers are funny,They still sell them everywhere but I never see carpenters using them for nailing. Hemlock has a property I learned of years ago. When it's green ,nails go through it easily but when it dries it becomes as hard as any hardwood. My floor joists are rough hemlock 2x8. I bought a pile of them,freshly milled from the local sawmill for $3 apiece(years ago).They were two shy of all I needed so I found two in a cull pile that weren't too twisted. These boards were black from weathering.I was merrily nailing away putting up my joists til I came to the first black one. The 16d nail sprung off into the air. I tried again,ping---gone.I finally managed to get a good hit on the nailhead and the end of the board split. So I got out a drill to predrill the rest and learned a lesson about hemlock.Good luck with your framing and if you persist with hand nailing watch out for your thumb.It takes weeks for the black thumbnail to fall off.DAMHIKT---Jack ;)

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#5

The wood is now drier

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"Fresh" framing lumber is not very dry (I think the spec is around 18% MC). After it dries out it gets harder to nail. Yellow pine is especially hard once dried for some years in the house.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#6

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

Kevin French

Put some Bee's Wax on the screws, I carry a bar in my driver box just for that.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#7

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

R Payne

You'll be better off with paraffin wax (used to be was available in the canning section). Bees wax is just acidic enough to rust screws and the like.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#8

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

just in case your not aware screws don't meet code requirements for framing.

Robin

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#9

Re: random musings

Bruce McCrory

Hah! Jack, I am learning the intricacies of a hammered thumbnail evolution as we speak! However, in this case, a 28oz hammer, or corded drill fell off a ladder and landed on my thumb. It has been a few months, I have forgotten, and pain is a common ailment in my life.

Bill, all, our local Big Boxes and other lumber stores source framing lumber locally. I am in the Pacific Northwest, so my woods are typically Doug-fir, Hem-fir/Doug-Fir, "white wood" (whatever that is) and Western Red Cedar. Even other firs are pretty rare, commercially. Ponderosa Pine is the the only pine we see. Boutique stores carry the rest. SYP, Bald cypress, and the various other firs, other than noted, are rare; really rare; or come from Canada as glued panel stuff.

We can even pick the density of the above exterior woods by sourcing west of the Cascades, wet ocean influence (3 to 10 rings per inch) and east of same, in dry forests (15 to 50 and more years per inch).

I thought the strength of the steels used in nails is less than previous years.

Re: How come my nails bend and screws strip?

#10

Re: Screws don't meet code ... Figures!