New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

A problem with setting hinges

Posts

A problem with setting hinges

#1

A problem with setting hinges

Joe Grittani

I recently built a reproduction of a Shaker lap desk from the measured drawings in John Kassay's book.

All went reasonably until I got to the - dontcha know - very end, installing the hinges. The top is quarter sawn White Pine. 9" x 13" and 5/16" thick. I found 1/4" #2 slotted brass screws at Lee Valley that fit the hinges from Rockler well. (The screws supplied with the hinges were Phillips head 1/2", so wouldn't work.)

Even though the screws are 1/16" shorter than the top thickness, I created bumps on the top of the lid installing them. I pre-drilled the lid with a brad but the screws will not hold. They seem to pull down snug, but once I open and close the lid a couple of times the hinges are wobbling. I've plugged the holes with toothpicks and started over a few times. No luck. I've patched in pieces across the bottom of the mortice and re-cut and adjusted the mortise depth. No luck. I'm somewhat convinced that the screws are too small to support a lid this size but can't go to a longer screw without going through the top.

I'd apreciate any suggestions you might have. The piece turned out great except for this mess with the hinges, tiny dovetails and all.

Joe Grittani

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#2

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Might try adding a drop of epoxy to the screw hole and even behind the hinge.

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#3

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Jerry Roberts

Joe, Im not sure this is your problem but is it the screws are not centered? I dont install hinges unless I use a vix bit. Come in many sizes. Cheers, Jerry

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#4

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

I like Bill Tindall's proposal.

Another thought is triggered by googling 'Shaker lap desk'. When I did that, I looked at images and found a pine model by Chris Becksvoort. His top was affixed like what I imagine you're trying to do. It couldn't hurt to email Mr. Becksvoort and see if he might offer a hint as to the hinge fixing on the lid side.

If you have a small plug cutter, like 1/4", you might try gluing hardwood plugs where each screw will go (hardwood dowels would be much easier, but then you're screwing into end grain). It would be critical to pilot the screw holes into hardwood with matching steel screws--the brass screws would break for sure. Only thing I hate about this idea is that you'd have to drill 1/4" holes close enough to breakthrough to make it real nerve-wracking.

I have another really crazy idea about dovetailing the hinge leaf, to give the screws some mechanical help, but I'll spare everyone that for right now. Maybe Mr. Becksvoort would help.

Wiley

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#5

Re: A problem with setting hinges

John Pappas

Joe, any way to beef up the edge of the top and the box so that you could use longer screws? I just don't think quarter inch screws will do the job over time. Otherwise, Bill's idea to use epoxy may be the solution.

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#6

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

The lapdesk I built has lids only 1/4" thick. There is not much left after morticing for the hinges. I carefully went as deeply as possibly with an awl, and then very carefully drilled to depth with a stop. The screws were ground shorter to fit the depth. I had tested the drill bit width beforehand, and this paid off since the screws (now with ends cut off and then carefully bevelled) performed like a tap, and seated strongly. They are holding well (bearing in mind that they have come off and gone back on a few times) but I plan to add a tad of epoxy to the holes and under the hinges before I call it a day. One difference with yours is that the wood I am using is very hard.

I think epoxy is the way to go.

One more thought: did you clear the rim of the screw hole - you now how it creates a raised edge? I clear this with a touch on a countersink. That ensures that the hinge sits flush. Your rocking may be due to the surface not being flat.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#7

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Patrick Gibbons

Lee Valley sells a kit of taps and two drills per size (one for tap hole and one for clearance hole). They suggest for very small screws such as you're using that a machine screw will hold better than a wood screw. I have found this to be true in my experience and have had much better luck doing this. Also, you can install a brass machine screw and hammer the opposite end like a rivet to increase the screw's holding power. I would drill holes, glue in a plug, install machine screws and peen over the end as a rivet.

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#8

Re: A problem with setting hinges

William Duffield

Buy 5/8" narrow hinges, and set them into the edges. With QS pine, setting them into the faces, your screw holes are either in soft wood, where they won't hold at all (without epoxy) or in hard wood, where the screws will want to wander off into the soft wood. If set into the edges, they go through alternating hard and soft wood, and hold fine in the hardwood layers, and where you can use longer screws.

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#9

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Joe Grittani

Thank you all. I've had already tried a number of suggestions. The screws into the top of the box edge are fine - there I was able to use 1/2" #2s. The lid's the problem. The suggestion I haven't tried is epoxy, so I guess that's what I'll do next. I assume that if that doesn't work I'll be making a new lid with breadboard ends, a real pain, but "so it goes".

Are you referring to liquid epoxy or the two part solid stuff? Would I run the screws into it before it hardens or wait and re-drill?

Again thanks for all of your time and advice. This is a great place.

Joe

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#10

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

the best two part you can buy. Juice up the hole, add some to the back of the hinge after through cleaning it and the mortise of pitch and oils and screw it on, being careful to not over tighten the screws. Then swear to never build from pine again.

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#11

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I would take a Dremel wheel to the inside faces of the hinges, scoring them here-and-there to create keys for the epoxy to grip. You could do the same in the hinge mortice using a drill bit.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#12

Re: A problem with setting hinges

Joe Grittani

Bill and Derek -

Thank you again. I religiously read all of both your posts and really appreciate what you do.

Joe

Re: A problem with setting hinges

#13

Re: CA glue for setting hinges

Bruce McCrory

Using thin CA glue, you can harden a larger volume of wood fibers. Tap, then drop glue into the hole and let it harden before setting the screws.

You will need a void (over-size tap) below the screw point to prevent pimples on the opposite surface.

Epoxy will give you time to align the pieces; and use a bigger attachment surface.

Wiley's hardwood filler is useful, also.

However, a quarter inch of any wood is asking a lot of any fastener within that depth to restrain a panel of that size.