Re: shooting boards - flat or ramped
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Eric
The short answer is that they all work, a ramp works better, but the effort of building one depends on whether you have the time and inclination.
I have an article on my website that compares the LN #51 (skewed blade at 45 degree cutting angle), LN #9 (straight blade at 45 degree cutting angle) and the LV LA Jack (straight blade at 37 degree cutting angle, with and without a hotdog handle) on both flat and ramped shooting boards.
If you want the salient comments, here they are ...
Cutting angles and the effect of Skew
First and foremost there is a significant effect from the way that the cutting angle and the way in which the blade enters the wood.
In order of ease of the way that the blade cut end grain, the LN #51 was way out in the front of the pack. This was perceived to be due to a combination of factors: the mass of the plane (9 lbs for the #51, 4 ½ lbs for #9, and 6 lbs for the LAJ) and its 20 degree skew angle.
Second in this category was the LAJ. Again the mass is a likely factor, but so is the lower cutting angle (37 degrees versus the 45 degrees of the #9). Note that the cutting angle of the #51 is also 45 degrees, and this suggests that the (20 degree) blade skew plays a larger part than the (8 degrees of) cutting angle.
A similar factor was apparent with the shooting boards. The ramped boards were 5 degrees. While there is a much debate whether the ramped board can be said to impart a true slicing cut, there was no mistaking that any plane on the ramped board cut with less effort and less apparent impact than when used on a flat board.
The ramped board does appear to cause the blade to hit the edge of the board at an angle, which leads to it enter the board at a progressive angle. By contrast, a flat board will cause a plane with a square blade to strike it across its full width.
There is also an additive factor here: a ramped board with a square blade has less apparent impact than a flat board with a square blade, while a ramped board with a skewed blade is best of all (e.g. the #51 on a ramped board). Wouldn’t a ramped version of the #52 be nice!
The full text (article) is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html
Regards from Perth
Derek