Ouch...
Rob Lee
...price of shellac has just gone up 50% AGAIN!
We'll be changing our prices shortly.... best stock up now if you use it....
Cheers -
Rob
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Ouch...
Rob Lee
...price of shellac has just gone up 50% AGAIN!
We'll be changing our prices shortly.... best stock up now if you use it....
Cheers -
Rob
Worldwide demand or loss of bug habitat?
Why?
Jack Guzman from Maine
What is causing this? Thanks for the heads up.---Jack
Re: Why?
Rob Lee
No idea why ....perhaps it's demand from the cosmetics industry (nails)... which probably accounts for more demand than furniture....
Just be wary of price differences - ours will go up May 15th, people with older stock will likely have lower pricing for awhile...
For those that don't remember, there was an almost 100% increase last fall....
Rob
Re: Why?
Patrick Gibbons
Checked on shellac.net and they say because of crop shortages over multiple seasons.
Darn! That's my favorite finish!!
Shellac flake life..?
david weaver
..I know I've seen it mentioned in blog posts, etc, before that shellac flake doesn't dissolve as easily once it gets past a certain age, but I don't remember what the ultimate conclusion was...
... I ask because I have a couple of bottles of 4 year-old garnet flakes that never got used, and I am curious about whether or not I should do something with them.
Like most of us, I have used shellac that was already mixed after confusing when it was mixed, only to find out it was too old and wouldn't harden quickly. But I only made that mistake once.
Presume (as a big big fan of shellac) that it wouldn't be a great idea to go buy a couple of pounds that might not get used for several years?
My understanding
Ellis Walentine
...such as it is, is that the esterification process doesn't begin until the shellac is mixed with the alcohol. Perhaps the chemists among us can illuminate.
Ellis
Re: My understanding *LINK*
Paul M.
My usual supplier has the following text on his webpage (link below):
What is the shelf life of shellac?
Shellac flakes have a finite shelf life unknown to most users. Even if Shellac flakes are stored in a cool, dark and dry place, but older than 2 years, it will not dissolve completely in alcohol overnight when compared to fresh stock. When applied, it will be sticky and slow drying. If used for French polishing, more than the usual amount of oil will be required for lubrication. If shellac is used after this date, make sure that it dissolves completely in the alcohol. If you see a thick gooey gelatinous mass at the bottom of the jar, its past its shelf life and should not be used. It is always a good idea to buy shellac flakes as and when required.
Once dissolved in alcohol, shellac does not last more than 6 months at the most. Store mixture in a cool dark and dry area of your workshop. The ideal temperature is between 65-70 degrees F.
Always dissolve shellac as and when needed.
http://www.shellacfinishes.com/Contact_and_FAQ.html
Re: My understanding
david weaver
Like I said, I used the gooey once when I lost track of how old the shellac was. In my case, it went on fine, but it never dried hard, even after a week.
I wonder if shelf life could be improved by keeping it in the freeze, as in, is it oxidation, or is it moisture?
So much for that. If one actually uses the shellac they have, even at $35 a pound, it's not the worst thing in the world for how versatile it is. Certainly better than buying 4 pounds for five bucks less and throwing out three of them.
Seedlac has indefinite shelf life.
Re: Seedlac has indefinite shelf life.
david weaver
Thanks stephen...someone else I know advocates using seedlac only when the purpose is final finish.
something doesn't make sense - shelf life
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
The reaction of shellac, which is an organic acid, with alcohol to make an ester that is a crappy finish is well established. It would seem that the easy solution to this problem would be to formulate with a nonreactive solvent and I suppose that is what Zinsser does. However, something doesn't make sense about the shelf life of flakes. If there is some reaction with air or moisture that renders the flakes an unsuitable finish, then why wouldn't this same reaction occur for the applied film on a piece of furniture and render it compromised? How can the applied film last forever and the flake it came from not?
George (last name forgotten) at the Smithsonian is a shellac expert and in a seminar on the topic he told of buying a huge amount of shellac at some bargain price. He talked like he expected to be using it for years to come. While touring the furniture of PA this spring I stumbled into the shop that does the repair and conservation work for the large auction houses. They bought shellac flake by the 25 pound container and I was led to believe it lasted them a while.
I suspect...
John in NM
That the reduced shelf life of flake shellac has to do with perception more than actual data. Old flake behaves a little differently in dissolution, so the assumption is that it is bad.
I have some old flake in a tin, and the flakes took to sticking together. When one chisels out a chunk, it takes a long time to dissolve - stuck together, the ratio of surface area to mass is much less. It did eventually dissolve and worked fine. The description of the slow to dissolve mass at the bottom describes it perfectly - but once it dissolved it was ok.
Re: something doesn't make sense - shelf life
wilbur
Kari Hultman once wrote about a batch of shellac flakes that she couldn't get to dissolve, and figured that they went bad. I asked her if she could send the bad flakes to me for me to play with. I used Everclear as a solvent, made a slightly less than 1 pound cut, and wound up with a batch of shellac that had some of that gelatinous stuff at the bottom. I let it sit, and most of the gelatinous stuff went away over the course of a few days.
In use, this seemed to work fine as a finish, except that if I wasn't careful, some tiny gelatinous bits got onto my workpiece. But that was easily taken care of by rubbing out the finish.
After that, I kept the leftover shellac with the gelatinous bits on the shelf. Eventually, all the gelatinous bits dissolved, and it still seemed to work well as a finish.
I'm not sure why I didn't find this to be an issue. The only thing I can think of is that Everclear is 95% ethanol, 5% water, with no denaturing agents. Your typical denatured alcohol that you get in the big can at the borg is 50% ethanol, 50% methanol. Maybe it's something about my choice of solvent that made this shellac behave better.
Of course, going through all this to get rid of the gelatinous bits isn't as fast as making shellac from fresh flakes that go into solution more quickly, but I don't think that it's necessarily a deal breaker.
More pictures and details here: http://giantcypress.net/post/17205738940/the-shellac-redemption
Not a difficult thing to test, right?
david weaver
If flakes are questionable, dissolve them and apply them one day before you will want to use them.
If the finish is hard and can be sanded within a reasonable period of time, then all is well. If it balls or rolls when sanded, then you can let it go a little longer and see if it gets better.
Re: free makes it OK and an alt to everclear
david weaver
When you get something for free, it's no big deal to deal with a little trouble.
The green klean strip is likely at least 95% or more alcohol, almost completely ethanol and is about $7 a quart locally.
But to be honest, I have never had any trouble dissolving shellac in the half methanol stuff, and I don't know that I've met anyone who has. I'm sure someone has, but the implications of huffing in the methanol is a lot bigger deal to me than the possible water content.
question-typo?
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
There are many ways to denature alcohol with the addition of methanol being one of them. However, the amount of methanol added is not nearly as great as 50% when used as a denaturant.
Re: question-typo?
david weaver
Check klean strip's msds for the non-green DNA. It's about 50% ethyl and 50% methyl.
Same for sunnyside now, which used to be a better mix (more ethyl as I recall).
The only widely available inexpensive DNA that is mostly ethyl is the klean strip DNA that comes in a green container.
Re: something doesn't make sense - shelf life
Larry Barrett
The 'George - shellac expert, recently retired from Smithsonian' that you refer to is, I think, Don Williams. He is conducting a finishing class this weekend. William Duffield is attending, so if he reads this perhaps he can discuss with Don and shed some light on shelf-life.
Re: question-typo?
Paul M.
All of the denaturants seem to be stuff that cause sensitization issues with me. I cannot stand that stuff. I've tried just about every one I can find and all give me extreme headaches and other health issues.
I also live in the nanny state of CA which has decreed that 190 proof Everclear is evil and is banned from stores.
So I go south to Tiajuana and smuggle up Mexican Moonshine for use with French Polish. Stuff works great without any adverse health issues. I refuse to be poisoned by denaturants just because the state I live maintains a random stupid law against Everclear.
you are correct
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
where did I get "George" from!
Re: question-typo?
david weaver
oh, but it's not random. It's not safety-producing.
It is purely an element of tax revenue protection, one that has killed less well informed people in the past.
It irritates me, too, that I get a negative health effect or pay huge amounts for alcohol because the government wants to protect their pocketbook.
Re: something doesn't make sense - shelf life
William Duffield
I had several issues/questions to discuss with Don, but something came up (actually, came down) and I am not at the finishing retreat. 
Someone, it may have been Don, but might have been Stephen, but I can't remember, has suggested taking the old shellac flakes and putting them in a coffee grinder. Thereafter you shouldn't have any problem dissolving them. Of course, you have to turn the grinder on. 
Re: question-typo?
wilbur
Check the MSDS for Klean Strip Denatured Alcohol, the most commonly available brand, and the one that both Home Depot and Lowes carries: http://www.wmbarr.com/ProductFiles/1625%206%20Denatured%20Alcohol%20MSDS%204%2015%202013.pdf
It lists the methanol content as 50-55%.
Klean Strip Green denatured alcohol contains methanol at <10%, and MIBK at <10%, which I read to be "up to 10%".
http://www.wmbarr.com/ProductFiles/KSG%20Denatured%20Alcohol.pdf
The main point is that Everclear is a much cleaner solvent than any of the denatured alcohols. A side point is that methanol in any concentration is highly toxic, and I'm very glad to not have it in my shop.