New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

Posts

Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

#1

Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

TomD

I do this every so often. Challenge, preferably LV, but anyone else who wants to, to bring out the FK saw that has the 90 degree mid blade kink to it. This is one of those things I could do I guess, but I would prefer to see a finer one than I can easily make. The fact there is a market for very expensive fret saws to remove waste indicates there could be a market for an all in one saw. I can appreciate there are difficulties such as the angle that would be required, and would one need to bring out many saw blades. Also bowsaw blades aren't money makers at the best of times. I think that if it is built people will come. If the bowsaw format is the problem it is possible it could be made in a backsaw version, though that would be a bit of a trick...

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/video/klausz

Re: Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

#2

Re: Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

The issue I have with the FK saw (blade) is that if one uses it to remove 90% of the waste and then chisels, there is no advantage over any other coping- or fretsaw, both which are probably easier to use. Or, if the FK saw (with an advantage in a having a broad blade for a straighter saw cut) is to be used for 100% of the waste - no chisel use afterwards - then I would want a better finish. FK gets away with it on skill alone. I cannot imagine many weekend warriors replicating his results (which were not great) without many years of constant practice. In the video, FK also did not quite manage to clear the waste from the tails in one hit. He returned on 2 of them to clear a corner.

Nice party trick.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

#3

Re: Is it time to bring up the FK saw again?

TomD

I was surprised in the video that he completely mised the ends with the conventional saw. So some of the roughness he could have avoided. That said his practical app was packing cases.

I think it has several uses:

1) People learning need practice, and contrary to popular belief (a dangerous and possibly non-commercial place to be), one thing they need is easy practice. You don't learn to ride a bike at the tour de France, you learn by, making in this case, stuff for the shop, packing cases, etc... Or knocking out a lot of practice pieces. I sorta agree with Bill that there is a hitch that people have about perfection on all this. Where I disagree is that some stuff shouldn't be perfect, but you don't start with perfect.

2) There is stuff that needs to be made, and could be made pretty quick and dirty. I needed a case to keep guitar parts dry in, and I made it of 1/2", high end ply quickly dovetailed. This saved money, and weight and there isn't an easy way to join 1/2" ply without junk like cleats, where it ends up tough and stiff. I repaired the back fence with dovetails. They should get used where they are appropriate to the use, not just where one dreams of impressing, possibly non-existant, peers.

3) I think FK deserves a lot of credit for showing the way on Video decades ago. Now we not only have a lot of people who are really good, but they can make their own video on youtube. I bet FK was dumbfounded to find his efforts essentially set back the craft 10 years when people just watched the video and then decided they could never do that. You can learn his method in a couple of evenings, yet mostly people just run off as if on fire.

Klausz was pretty explicit about his roots. a) He apprenticed. A system designed to ensure that almost anyone born into the opportunity would be converted into a person who could meet professional standards and b) he didn't achieve his professional speed right away, until he took on a job with hundreds of drawers. The tape was designed to dumb dovetails down. Ugly project, easy wood, carpentry type dovetails, etc... The take away was different...

4) fun and novelty are good. As much as I like the LV April fool's jokes, I like them best when they yield something semi-usable, like the tape. You of all people, Derek, I just know you would buy such a saw...