New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

6 board chest -- moulding?

Posts

6 board chest -- moulding?

#1

6 board chest -- moulding?

Lars Parrington

i am in the process of making a 6 board chest. can't decide whether to put moulding around the base. any thoughts?

also thinking about the finish. leaning away from paint and towards amber shellac. perhaps i can teach myself to french polish.


Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#2

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

Ron in Sterling, CT

I completed this one last fall. The molding at the bottom also includes the feet.


Ron

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#3

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

Lars Parrington

very nice. i actually like the looks of that style much better, but opted to try this vernacular style anyway for a couple reasons.

1. i thought it would be fun to make nailed rebate joints, and i had recently purchased some rosehead cut nails.

2. i'm not sure if i like pine furniture, so didn't want to put in too much effort.

in the style i am building, i think it is traditional to put the moulding on a few inches above the floor. kind of looks like a little skirt to me.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#4

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

William Duffield

Unless you feel like you really, really need the practice, save your French polish for your next Newport Blockfront Desk reproduction in mahogany. (It's a lot easier to practice on a sheet of meranti (Philippine mahogany) or okume (African mahogany) 3 mil marine grade plywood.) No offense to your beautiful blanket chest, but French polish on white pine is like lipstick on a pig. :D I think my finish preferences would tend towards oiling it, padding or brushing on some garnet shellac and waxing it. If it's going to live in a room with small, rambunctious children, then I would consider Waterlox or even polyurinate if you've already blown your budget on the rosehead nails.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#5

bottom trim yes

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

It looks naked down there. What are you using for hinges?

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#6

A bit of history

Bob Hackett

Many of the older joiner`s chests I see up here are painted with whatever color paint was handy in the boatyard at the time which usually meant the same color as whatever hull was being painted when the chest was finished. The more fancy hands painted the chest the same color as the hull they were presently working on and the molding to match the "boot top" stripe that ran at the waterline of that hull. Many of the folks I know who make these as reproductions or scale them to blanket chest proportions still follow this tradition and will paint them to approximate the exterior color of the client`s home using milk paint followed by BLO as a sealer coat because it can easily be made to look "old and weathered".

One of my close friends once told me he felt this approach using toolboxes as a reference was especially appropriate for something like a toy box as children relate to their toys in much the same way as we do our tools, "They help them make their way through this world".

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#7

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think a moulding on this type of chest makes the feet look goofy and cheap, like there were bracket feet on it but they fell off. It does look good the way it is. If you do use a moulding, I think a moulding just across the front looks better than one that wraps around. A little late for this, but a front board with a bead moulding worked into the bottom edge looks good.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#8

a thought

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Cut something out that goes with the cut out on the bottom of the ends and fit it between the end boards on the bottom of the front board. It could easily be made to look like the front board extended to the floor with a cut-out. Alternatively, apply a piece to the front that is profiled on the top edge and cut-out (or not) on the bottom.


The pictures shows the bottom of a chest of drawers with just a molding around the bottom with the ends sticking down as legs. I love the rest of this piece but always thought the bottom looked weird.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#9

Re: lipstick on a pig

Lars Parrington

no worries on offending me. i harbor no delusions that this piece is a work of art. french polish in this case may indeed border on polishing a turd. rather than beauty, this build has been more about exploring some new techniques and getting a useful box out of the deal.

for the finish, really what i am thinking is shellac under wax, buffed out to a satin finish. i'm generally not a fan of high gloss, and agree it would be inappropriate on this piece. however, i'm thinking of experimenting with french polishing a bit along the way, as i see this as a low risk opportunity to convince myself that i can do it.

you'd recommend oil underneath to deepen the color? how long would you wait for the oil to cure before shellacing over it?

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#10

Re: lipstick on a pig

William Duffield

Yes, to deepen the color. How long to wait? It depends, on the type of oil you're using, and the temperature, and of course the porosity of the wood. I don't work much in pine, but I use oil based stains and oil based grain fillers on hardwoods. Especially with open grain woods (not pine, of course) the grain fillers and petroleum based carriers can take a few days to dry, and you can get fish eyes if you try to seal it with the shellac too soon.

I think you might be better off following Bob Hackett's advise than mine. I like his ideas for chests.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#11

Re: lipstick on a pig

TomD

Of course it is always possible there is a functional purpose to the molding, though I have no theories on what it might be. Even a cheap kitchen has a kick so that one's feet can get under the worksurface. It isn't a fancy shadow line. The molding could be protective, like if someone walks up to the piece and their buckle hits the lowest board and tears a hunk off (or it got under way as a repair for that, and then the next person who saw it figured that if his case had molding...). Or it stops cases sliding together and getting damaged, or insufficient air circulation without the set-back. I have no idea since I don't even begin to have an idea of what this was used for.

Part of the charm of old furniture is that it does not always work, but you get a chance to do something in poor taste because it already exists.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#12

basic brass plated butt hinges


Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#13

Another small addition

Bob Hackett

A bit of advice from someone who has had the screws holding multiple iron hinges ripped out of a soft wood (mahogany in my case) and the top edge fractured due to rough handling.Put some kind of stop on that top.

In my case it was young nephews playing around their great grandfather`s joiner`s box that did it in. The first go round at repairing it was just plain ugly. The second using new wood is less ugly and more structurally sound. It also allowed me to make the modifications needed to include a stop for the top. Most can`t see the difference between the old and the new wood (aged with dye, stain and glaze) I grafted on but I know it`s there. :(

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#14

Re: Another small addition

Lars Parrington

thanks bob, a stop is next on the list. i decided against the bottom moulding and so centered the top front to back (rather than having all the overhang in the front). the overhang in the back means the hinges will get ripped off if the top is opened any more than ~110 degrees.

also did some experiments with amber shellac and tung oil on a test board. interestingly, the tung oil adds almost no perceptable color change to this wood, though i suspect it would yellow over time. my wife would prefer something less yellow than the amber shellac, so i think i'll pick up some zinser "clear" shellac to try tomorrow.

i won't put too much time into the finish. we will live with it for a while, and perhaps someday paint it to match our house. we'll need to build a house first though.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#15

Re: lipstick on a pig

Patrick Gibbons

I use garnet shellac on pine for a warm, old-pine color. I've never used oil, it's not necessary to achieve the color.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#16

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

Bruce McCrory

I thought the effort would be ... umm, ... ah, rigorous. It is is quite pleasant to buff with a (muneca?) pad. But I was doing a Western Maple saw handle. I think something the size of your box would like Deft (lacquer) or, varnish.

However, I think one or two rubbings of linseed oil can warm things up; and meld the the stain/pitch lines.

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

#17

Re: 6 board chest -- moulding?

Lars Parrington

a coat of tung oil on the sample board made no perceptable change in color (which i've never seen happen on any other wood).

first two coats of shellac are already on. went with amber after all. took the sample board upstairs and it looked much better, more golden than yellow. must have been the shop lighting.

also fabricated stops to limit how far it opens are made. wooden linkages. i'm really pleased with how they came out. i'll post another photo when it's all finished.