New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

Posts

stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#1

stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

Lars Parrington

after making my roubo workbench, i procrastinated implementing the pinless part of the leg vise for a long time. in the meantime i just used the vise and made some kludgy modifications here and there to make it work better. i had a bit of a eureka moment with the last modification, and ended up with a perfectly functional pinless leg vise that is super simple. i'm sharing it here in hopes that it will be useful to other workbench builders, and save them the cost and complexity of intalling a st. peter's cross, a chain mechanism, or a linear bearing.

the mechanism is basically just a hardwood ramp that pushes down on a bearing located at the end of the parallel guide. this forces the vise jaw to the correct angle. another bearing located in front of the leg reduces friction and makes the vise slide in and out easily.

i'm not sure the picture does a great job of conveying how this works, so i made a youtube video also (my first one, how'd i do?)




youtube video here

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#2

A clever fix

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Lars,

I don't at all find it a simple piece of engineering, with the two bearing points and the ramp to keep the jaw at the right vertical angle. It is very efficient.

As time goes on, it may collect shavings and what-not, but if it does you'll figure out how to deal with that!

Fine youtube explanation!

Wiley

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#3

Re: A clever fix

Lars Parrington

thx! i've actually been using it like this for a month or two now. shavings do collect around the front skateboard bearing, but it doesn't seem to interfere with the operation at all.

i do think that over time the front bearing may make divots/bumps in the bottom of the parallel guide. in which case, i'd need to graft on a steel wear plate there.

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#4

some real (5 star) ingenuity there 


Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#5

Clever


Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#6

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise

Larry Wyatt

VERY nice indeed!

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#7

Question

Larry Barrett

Lars, have you tried clamping a much wider board in the vise? When the vise face is further out, and the bearing on the parallel guide is near the front bench leg, the effect of the ramp will be much less. Does the vise still close correctly? Admittedly this is a less common situation, and what you have done clearly works very well for the most common situations.

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#8

Another similar solution

Patrick Gibbons

Years ago I came across a patent that was a simple solution for the leg vise. It is #200,848, Bench-Vise, by A. P. Thompson, patented March 5, 1878. Thompson devised a runner that runs in a groove on the lower rail and through the front leg to the bottom of the chop. This is connected to an upright that is connected to an adjustable bar at the top that runs through the front leg and connects to the chop below the screw. It's simple to make, adjustable and can be added on to an existing bench. One can get a copy of the patent online from the patent office. It's simpler than my explanation. In principle, you have duplicated the mechanism. One of these days I'll build a new bench with a leg vise. This is how I'll do it.

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#9

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise

Patrick Gibbons

Lars, in my rush to tell you about the patent I forgot to commend you on your ingenuity. You came up with a simple solution to what is the Achilles heel of the leg vise. (Pun intended).

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#10

Re: patent #200,848 *LINK*

Lars Parrington

patrick, thanks for sharing this. very cool. i don't really think it's any more similar to my design than it is to a chain vise or a st. peters cross. however, it is delightfully simple. i probably would have built it had i known about it.




http://www.google.com/patents/US200848?dq=200848

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#11

Re: wide board problem

Lars Parrington

hi larry. wilbur had the same question in last night's chat room. i just went down and took some measurements. it turns out that you two are correct, the vise does not work perfectly with wide boards.

for a 3/4" board and for a 3-1/2" board, the gap at the bottom of the vise is ~1/16" greater than at the top when clamped down firmly.

for a 5-1/2" board, the gap at bottom is ~1/16 less than at top when clamped firmly.

for a 12" board, the gap at bottom is ~5/32" less than at top when clamped firmly.

i'm not sure i can think of a case where this problem actually matters, but i can speculate on why it happens.

there is some flexure in the mechanism that allows it to go from not parallel to parallel (or beyond) when clamping force is exerted. i suspect most of this is from compression of the wood under the bearings. indeed, i can feel some slight bumpiness in the bottom of the parallel guide where the front bearing has deformed it.

in theory, the angle of the vise should be maintained regardless of how far it is opened. as it is opened farther, the ramp gets thinner, but the bearings get closer together. in practice, the angle does appear to be maintained when no load is applied to the vise. however, when clamping force is applied with the vise opened wide, the load on the bearings is greater (because the distance between them is less). thus, the mechanism flexes more than when the vise is only open a small amount.

so, i think one solution would be to line the bottoms of the parallel guide and ramp with steel.

another solution would be to replace the bearings with blocks of slippery plastic or even hard waxed wood. this would make the construction of the system even simpler, although it may not glide in and out quite so smoothly.

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#12

Re: wide board problem

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Lars,

When you clamp the 12" wide board, is that board horizontal in the vise, and placed up at the top? Or is it being clamped vertically?

Whichever it is, I suggest trying it the other way, to see whether and how much of a difference that makes. Just another step in the analysis of what's happening.

Wiley

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#13

Re: wide board problem

Lars Parrington

hi wiley,

i had it clamped this way before:


per your request, i went back and clamped it this way:


it actually measured the same as before, 5/32" smaller gap at bottom. although, this time that has a lot to do with the geometry of the board, since it extends down past the screw, it will keep the vise from getting too far beyond parallel. when i clamped the vise down hard, it was pinching the board at the screw, and also at the top (because of the leather). however, if i eased up just a bit, i could get a feeler gage in at the screw and the board was still held securely by the top of the vise.

note that the edge of my workbench top is not perfectly square to the top, nor is it perfectly in the same plane as the leg. it was closer when i built it, but that was 10% moisture content ago. as a result, in the second picture, you can see a gap where the top of the board meets the top/front of the workbench.

Re: stupidly simple pinless leg vise *LINK*

#14

Re: wide board problem

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

Assuming the 12" wide board is parallel all the way down, then I'd say you're good right now, since the vise has a good grip on the top of the board, both in the first photo and the second one. The narrower gap at bottom might be just the angle created by the leather up top--you could check this using basic trig.

The main thing is that the vise should grip tightly at the top in all situations. It's doing that.

Wiley