New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Question I shouldn't have to ask

Posts

Question I shouldn't have to ask

#1

Question I shouldn't have to ask

Ron Harper

Toy chest ...Borg pine... To be painted and "girlied up"

30 in long 20 in high. 18 in deep.

How much strength do I add by doing hand cut box joints with ten per side glued screwed and plugged, as compared to rabbet joints?

Seems to me like I would gain some?

Thanks

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#2

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

Paul Dzioba

Ron,

If you are doing box joints there is no need for screws.

If you are cutting box joints by hand you might as well do dovetails. Box joints are not easier.

Have you considered rabbets, glue, and rosehead cut nails? A lot of chests have been done that way and have lasted a long time.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#3

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

Ron Harper

If it is going to be painted, why not reg cut nails, set and putty the holes?

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#4

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron,

You'd pick up lots of long-grain/long-grain glue surface with the box joints. The rebate joint, if we're talking about the same thing,

http://dtatist.wikispaces.com/rebate+joint

has only long-grain/end-grain glued surfaces. Using hide glue, if you glue-size those end grain surfaces, it's my (limited) experience that you can still get a strong join. Plus you could reinforce the inside corners with glue blocks, which would be all long-grain/long-grain. But at the joint itself, there is no question there's lots more glue surface with the box joints, much of it long-grain/long-grain.

I agree with Paul that if you're hand cutting the box joints, may as well do dovetails (which I find easier to saw for some reason). If you want to paint the plugs a contrasting color as an appearance feature, then that's a different matter of course.

Sounds like a wonderful project!

Wiley

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#5

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

wilbur

I like to put it this way:

Box joints. For when you want all the difficulty of a dovetail without the mechanical advantage.

:D

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#6

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

wilbur

Cut nails would be a very quick and strong way to put this box together.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#7

alternative

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If you are not proficient in cutting dovetails it is occasions like this that provide a stress-free opportunity to gain experience. When I was crawling up the learning curve I dovetailed anything I could- drawers for daughters kitchen cabinets, a stand off for a meat grinder, some shop furniture, etc. After 100 or so joints I began to get comfortable with the task (I am a slow learner). Had I only used this technique on "fine furniture" I never would used the technique on fine furniture because I never would have been confident enough to try it. Other's results may vary..............

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#8

Thought about it

Ron Harper

Essentially for the reason you suggested. I am no better than mediocre at the joint, having been out of the shop for ten years. It just seems like a lot of work for a box that is going to be painted with stars and girly stuff and glitter. Know what I am sayin?. I can take my moving filitster and cut the joints for a rabbet joint in the time it would take to lay out the tails. May do it anyway. Still wrestling with the portable tool box design. Have to dovetail that. So this may be good prep. If they are wretched, can apply molding to the corners.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#9

Re: Thought about it

William Duffield

My mentor put it this way: "That's why God made putty." If you are not showing off the dovetails, and not applying a clear finish, the only thing you really care about is structural integrity. For this, dovetails are unsurpassed. They're also cheap, in both time and materials, especially with the hand tools and techniques you've already invested in.

Just mark the waste, and don't cut any taildoves.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#10

Thanks for the nudge

Ron Harper

Only the tiniest bit of reflection would indicate that Bill , William, and Wilbur, and Paul are right. Dovetails it shall be.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#11

Re: Thought about it

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"It just seems like a lot of work for a box that is going to be painted with stars and girly stuff and glitter."

I submit that this is exactly the kind of project to practice on.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#12

Re: alternative

TomD

+1

Dovetails normally have a lot fewer interfaces. With a storage box you can put a pin every 4-6 inches, really forgiving. I do it in plywood when I need to get something at 90 degrees.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

one more pro dovetails

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ron,

I love old chests and boxes. I look for them everywhere besides having a shop full of them. Almost all old chests I've seen are dovetailed,and not decoratively.Most are obviously hand cut and uneven.I am sure that If you do a pretty little girl paint job on that chest noone(except for a fellow woodworker)will ever notice your dovetails. Good or bad.---Jack

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#14

Dovetail fear

Patrick Gibbons

Dovetails are the correct joint. Chris Schwartz had an article once where he wrote that when one asks a question such as yours, it's because the answer is known but not what the woodworker wants to do. I still fear doing dovetails because they take me a lot of time to do and sometimes have errors. That's a good reason for me to do them. As Bill said, it's a good project to improve your dovetailing. Years from now a woman will look at the chest and remember fondly that someone who loved her made that for her with his own hands. The dovetails will help the chest to make it to that point.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#15

We have done it to ourselves

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Dovetails are not slow and tedious if we stop fretting that they may turn out less then flauntable. It is hard, if not impossible, to dovetail together a box and not have it be robust. However, the modern fixation on flauntable dovetails has made this useful joint off limits to all but the highly skilled and experienced, and/or bold. If more simply adequate dovetails showed up on WoodCentral and the magazines and books maybe there would be less fear among the masses to use them. A more reasonable standard would be to poke into old furniture and strive to make them as well as what you see.


Example from 1853.

Likely we are the first people to critique this joint in its history which should illustrate the point of striving for adequate, not flauntable, dovetails. These have held the drawer together well.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#16

One more thought on dovetails...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

They're easy to troubleshoot, to find out what's going wrong. In my little bit of experience, the problems are usually traceable to one of these:

1. Sawcuts on tailboard not parallel to each other.

2. On the pins board, letting the saw cross the mark (the entire mark is part of the live wood)

3. With the chisel, overcutting the baseline (maybe the most common error)

4. Letting the work move when transferring marks from tails board to pins board (or vice versa).

These issues can all be seen detected right away, just by looking at the joint, and the fix in each case is straightforward.

Depending on the issue, a simple thing like making the initial cuts on the tails board straight across to establish parallelism, or using a paring block to keep the chisel from backing across the scribe line, or fixing the two boards rigidly when transferring marks--can make a difference like night and day.

Wiley....just saying

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#17

Yeah I know but

Ron Harper

I understand all of that. I used to be at least slightly above average at it. But, that has been a while.

Yeah, I know..... Get back at it.

I will be on it on Friday.

Ron

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#18

Good Decision

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have made 3 blanket chests with hand cut dovetails over the last 3 years, and 4 more to go. As I only do 1 per year, I do a practice corner before I start the actual chest each time. I find that it reminds me of most of the things that can go wrong, and that by the time I start on the actual pieces I am pretty well warmed up and in the groove. Good Luck.

Ron

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#19

Very small progress report

Ron Harper

Snuck down to the shop for a very few minutes after dinner and practiced. Made a few practice cuts and then laid out a tail board . I stunned myself by making square cut right up against the line al the way across. Feeling a little better

As a small experiment cut one tail with a ryoba. Obviously the kerf was smaller and cleaner, but that is sort of irrelevant if you keep the kerf where it is supposed to be. The thing that shocked me was how much faster my independence tool saw cuts. I did use the crosscut side of the ryoba which counts for some of that.

Will do a whole practice joint of Friday then get after it. Feeling encouraged cause my chisel work is adequate. Thanks again for shoving me a little.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#20

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

jack curtis

Box cuts aren't as strong as dovetails, but they have a certain look that I find attractive, a bit more so than dovetails. For structural reasons I'd go with the dovetails.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#21

Re: Not really

TomD

The DTs in the picture are basically clean. The baseline of the middle one might be bad, but that is a simple thing to de-skill.. So skill wise this guy had it, but he overshot the saw cuts. Modern cabinetmakers have a lot of tricks for de-skilling dovetails or speeding them up. Tag Frid would have made flawless looking joints in that case, put money in his wife's pocket, and taken hardly any time over it, and the technique involved is skill free.

Sure more pins would mean more time, but let's be serious, you are the guy using the workmanship of certainty to tattoo an otherwise elegant piece of casework, when deep down you know that stencil painting would have allowed you to "get er done" faster, and been more where your heart truly is. You are taking days so are a few additional moments on the DTs really such a big deal?

Every activity is going to have it's Mount Everest, you know, the thing everyone not in the know thinks is the summit of achievement. So why not let cabinetmaking have it's own dream of perfection and ultimate experience, who does it really hurt.

Re: Question I shouldn't have to ask

#22

Re: Alternative solution

john sayles

In several instances, when making simple chests, I have eschewed dovetail joints in favor of rebates, but with the following important distinction. Chest sides (with grain running horizontally) are joined to end panels (with grain running vertically) thereby avoiding the "end grain problem."