New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Panels with knots

Posts

Panels with knots

#1

Panels with knots

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 1977 I had a friend who lived in the Caleb Pusey house as a caretaker. Pusey was sent here by Penn to manage the grist mill and saw mill at Chester, Pennsylvania, and built the house in 1683. It is the only remaining building in Pennsylvania that Penn is known to have visited.

In the house was a walnut corner cupboard with huge knots in the panels. My friend thought the panels were great, but it was a bit much for me. The piece is otherwise quite handsome. I thought of this cupboard, which I had not seen since, when we were discussing the applewood chest. I managed to find a picture; the knots are about 3 inches by 8 inches and there is crotch wood above them.


img

Re: Panels with knots

#4

distantly related question

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

In my limited encounters with PA furniture I have not seen any in cherry. I don't recall a single eastern PA cherry piece either at Winterthur, Chester Co museum or in Schiffer's book. I was wondering if knots were used to decorate cherry pieces but then realized I had no data for cherry. Given the popularity of cherry at other times and places it is curious that cherry seems missing from this PA. period.

Re: Panels with knots

#5

Cherry

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We see quite a lot of cherry case furniture in the late 18th century here in Pennsylvania. In mid 18th century, not so much. Cherry does not carve as well as walnut or mahogany so that is a factor. I once carved cherry rosettes for an 18th century clock that was missing pieces; it would have been easier in mahogany. The museums tend to collect the finest examples which might bias toward walnut or mahogany.

Re: Panels with knots

#6

Re: Cherry

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Cherry is not fond of a mild climate and eastern PA may be considered mild by cherry standards. Could it be that the cherry quality was not high in eastern PA and hence it did not appear widely in furniture until timber from the western part of the state became available? Walnut, on the other hand, would have thrived in the valleys and river and creek bottoms.

Until you get up to around 3000' elevation the cherry here in TN and NC is not of high quality. The color is different (some would say poor by northern standards though it has a local following) and it has lots of gum pockets. However, the trees may be large. I once sawed a monster with 1300 bdft.

Re: Panels with knots

#7

Re: Cherry

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think that the big factor is preference, not availability. I don't think cherry lends itself to Queen Anne or Chippendale like walnut or mahogany. Once you get into the Federal period, we see plenty of cherry pieces made with fine material. My father has a SE Pennsylvania desk with spectacular quarter sawn cherry drawer fronts. In the township where I grew up there was a Prunus serotina with a circumference over 21 feet.

Re: Panels with knots

#8

more data

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I took a few minutes to poke into the book Connecticut Valley Furniture. Of the 200 pieces represented, most are from the 1750-1800 period, with a few earlier. Much of this furniture is cherry with the usual sorts of carving we see on mahogany furniture of this time (shells and the like). There was not a knot to be found.

Re: Panels with knots

#9

Re: more data

david weaver

It's easy to find clear wide cherry boards here. Like this, and twice as wide isn't out of the question if you will pay:


This stuff was less than $3 a bd ft. here. It is very very pink, something the flash in this picture does no justice to show.

It's probably never been easy to find long clear apple boards for common furniture.

Most of the older furniture I've seen in homes in SC PA has been walnut, mahogany, and if newer, cherry. Not talking about the nicer stuff like warren is dealing in, but the common stuff. When it's cherry, I have generally not seen knots, either, unless sapwood is also acceptable, suggesting the piece was anything goes (and those pieces tend to be 20th century local makers from my area that were making very very "common man" furniture for rank and file america).

Re: Panels with knots

#10

Re: more data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If I were making Chippendale furniture I would pick walnut over cherry; if I were making Federal furniture I would pick cherry over walnut. Here in Southeastern Pennsylvania cherry became very popular in the period 1800- 1830. There is no lack of trees.

Some people are quite fond of Connecticut furniture and much cherry furniture was made there in the 18th century. However you have to consider that black walnut is rare in much of Connecticut. It has no reported natural occurrence in four of the eight counties. Some distribution maps show it only in the extreme Northwest corner of the state. So if black walnut is rare or absent in Connecticut, is it a wonder that they used cherry instead?

Re: Panels with knots

#11

Re: more data

William Duffield

It's plentiful in the Garden State, too. These are from Hunterdon County. I paid $140 last week for the four 4/4 cherry boards on the right. 8' x 15", clear, except for the bottom foot or so, and figured. I don't know yet how pronounced the figure is, as the surfaces are off the bandsaw, but I suspect it exceeds "blotchy".


Bench Dog Seal of Approval!

Re: Panels with knots

#12

Wow Bill, $3.50/bd ft


Re: Panels with knots

#13

Re: more data

david weaver

Who did you get that from in hunterdon, was it a store, or was it from a farm?

Re: Panels with knots

#14

Re: more data

William Duffield

Come to think of it, I never asked him where he got that particular log. It may have been local, or he may have found it many miles from his place. He's retired, and saws logs using a WoodMizer, as a hobby. E-mail me and I'll send you particulars, if you want them.

Re: Panels with knots

#15

Re: more data

david weaver

Just curious because there is a youtube stream that I subscribe to from a farmer in Frenchtown. He also bought a woodmizer and has been going through his woods after the storm last year and bringing out a lot of lumber.

No need for contact info, transportation would kill the deal from there to here (pittsburgh). We have a local guy who comes to the WW club in pittsburgh and pretty much brings whatever you ask for. If you want 15" wide QSRO, you can get it from him, and he's cheap, about the price range you quoted for various things.

I have otherwise been getting lumber from Mike Digity, but each time he tells me he's retiring, and I think he might have told the truth last time. Those kind of folks are a godsend for us. My only other reasonable choice is a 40 minute drive to a supplier who charges 5$ a bd foot for 4/4 cherry that is really underwhelming. Rockler often has cherry, too, but the only good cherry they have is 8/4 and they want some princely sum for that. The stuff that comes in on skids is usually pretty barfy, and pre-thicknessed to 13/16, complete with complimentary twist and cup.

Re: Panels with knots

#16

Re: more data

William Duffield

This sawyer is in Ringoes. He has the largest silver maple in NJ on his property, but he's not planning to saw that one up.