New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A little advice please and Thank You

Posts

A little advice please and Thank You

#1

A little advice please and Thank You

Ron Harper

I am making a toy box for a niece. 30 in long by 20 in high, by 18 ib deep. Will be using borg pine because SWMBO is going to paint designs all over it.

The question is , since I will need to edge glue to get the necessary width, do I gain appreciable strength by using tongue and groove joints? Or, is is just a help in the glue-up?

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#2

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

Lars Parrington

no extra strength from tongue and groove, just alignment help and that will only be significant if you cut the joint tight enough.

i assume you are cutting the joint by hand? it might be hard to avoid tearout when cutting the tongues, which would be visible in the finished piece.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#3

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

david weaver

Edge joint only. I wouldn't T&G a hand joint that wasn't allowed to float, you can't be as precise as you would be with an edge joint, and the tongue probably won't be a laser tight fit, anyway.

Just my thoughts.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#4

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

TomD

No strength increase, and no help in aligning it. Mostly for situations where one is nailing and not glueing. Biscuits are useful for alignment, and do not adversely affect strength too much. I just butt most stuff, a really hard glue is key.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#5

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

Curt Putnam

T&G adds no strength and mostly loses some. Since the project will be painted consider the use of liquid hide glue - much better resistance to heat (without water) than the other TBs

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#6

I use old brown


Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#7

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

Patrick Gibbons

Tongue and groove was the way to go prior to about WWII. New glues made it fall from favor. To quote Bernard Jones' The Practical Woodworker, "Either tongued or matched joints are now generally insisted on in preference to the glued butt. ... For a perfect joint it is requisite that the tongue should fit just closely in the grooves without being tight, and be slightly less in width than the combined depth of the two grooves, so as not to bind when the joint is glued up. ... To make tongued joints easy to rub when gluing, the tongues should be planed slightly uneven in thickness, so that one edge fits tightly while the other will be loose enough to allow the board to be rubbed to and fro." Today we are told that modern glues are going to cure stronger than the wood itself and that the wood will fail before the glue in a stressed joint. A tongued joint provides more glue surface than a simple butt. If anything it seems to me that a tongued joint is even better with modern glues (as opposed to using hide glue). Maybe it doesn't help but it couldn't hurt.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#8

Just a thought

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron,

Like the others, I think the straight join is the way to go.

If you do want to get some reinforcement in there, I wouldn't go T&G. The problem I see with a T&G is that it would be a bear (for me, anyway) to get the tongued board to joinable shape. No problem on the groove, but the tongue would be a goat rodeo trying to get to a seamless join. Instead, I think you'd be better to (1) joint both boards, (2) groove both boards, say 1/4", and (3) insert a matching 1/4" spline. It'd be good to give the spline some expansion room within the housing, so it wouldn't distort the join line when it swelled with glue. Sure as little green apples, you'd plane down the swollen seam, then the spline would shrink back over time, leaving a depression at the seam line.

All in all, what the others said.

Wiley

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#9

another lumber choice

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I don't like building with pine. It is too soft. Poplar would be a better choice and it paints well. Give it a sealer coat of oil based KIlz, sand smooth with 180 and the result is a glass smooth surface ready to paint.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#10

Re: another lumber choice

Ron harper

Here the poplar would cost me double. I am using number 2 pine and cutting out the knots

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#11

Re: another lumber choice

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

You spent what for that saw and won't spend $40 for lumber for the wife's box! I hope she doesn't lurk here on WC and learn of this situation.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#12

Re: another lumber choice

Ron Harper

Spent 70 for number 2 pine. Poplar would have been 140. Box is a toy box for a two year old, which will be painted

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#13

Re: another lumber choice

TomD

One has to carefully manage expectations. I am legendary in having done so. I changed on diaper. That sort of thing. Of course, give credit where it is due, she never welched on a deal, and that is key.

Re: A little advice please and Thank You

#14

Re: another lumber choice

Patrick Gibbons

Here in Texas the Borg's pricing on poplar and oak are outrageous. I can buy poplar at the lumber store for cheap, cheap. They sell Western Yellow Pine (called white pine by most), radiata pine and some SYP other than two by material. Going to a lumber yard will get you better prices. Once you cull out the Borg pine that has warped while you wait for it to dry in your shop and the bad knots often it ends up being cheaper to have paid for better wood in the first place. That being said, pine, of all types, are some of my favorite woods. Just because something costs more or less doesn't make it better or worse. Time is also a factor. Panels made with wider boards are faster to put together. One thing about pine I've learned the hard way is that wider boards tend to have the center of the log. That center is unstable and best cut out.