New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Posts

fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#1

fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

I acquired a Yankee 1545 eggbeater and everything seems to be working except that the crank handle is really tight. I'm not sure if the rivet that holds the handle on was overtightened? I had two ideas, neither of which seem fantastic. One would be to grind the rivet off and re-rivet the handle. The other would be to try to trim the handle back a bit so that it is looser. (But that seems like it would be hard to do.)

Anybody have any better advice on how I can loosen it?

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#2

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Kevin French

WD40 thru the straw into the handle, you might have a build up in there.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#3

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

I just finished restoring two millers falls hand drills. I took the crank handles off of each, filing off the rivets to do so. One of the handles was siezed-up beforehand -- the pin had rusted, swelling in diameter in the process. I suspect that is was caused it to sieze, although the handle was also very tight longitudinally, so that could have played a role too. I don't think I would have gotten it signifcantly loosened without completely disassembling it.

If you file off the peened part of the handle's pin, there may not be enough material to re-peen when you go to reassemble. One option would be to drill and tap the end of the pin for a screw instead, making future repairs easier. Alternatively, you could cut the shoulder of the pin back a bit, so that more pin material sticks through the metal bar. This shortens the useable length of the pin, further aggravating your problem of the longitudinally tight handle. However, a good workaround is to deepen the counterbore in the handle, so the pin head sits further down into it.

I chose the second option for my tight handle. The counterbore wasn't deep enough to begin with and was cut off center, so I was able to clean that up at teh same time. re-peening the handle pins was easy enough -- used the end grain of an old axe handle as an anvil to supported the head of the pin, while hitting the other end of the pin (lots and lots of times, but not too hard) with a regular 16oz hammer.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#4

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

When riveting anything, the first step is to get everything tight; you don't want to peen the rivet when the shoulder of the pin is not firmly against the handle. This is somewhat self-correcting for this particular application, but it would still be a good idea to tap around the rivet/pin to make sure it's seated well before you start riveting.

Lars mentions using an axe head as an anvil. If you counterbore the wooden handle so that the pin is below the wood, an alternate anvil is a short bolt of the correct diameter, just barely long enough to clear the wood, resting on something hard.

This kind of work often calls for three hands. If you've got a friend, lifemate, eager child who can hold the handle in position while you rivet, it will make things go faster with less frustration. If you're working solo, it's sometimes helpful to make a support for the handle to keep it in position; fancy's not necessary.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#5

Clint Searl

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Clint Searl

You hold the hammer, and I'll hold the rivet; when I nod my head, hit it.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#6

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

sorry to nit-pick, but actually i said axe handle, not head. in my case, i wanted a wooden anvil so as not to mar the head of the pins.

i managed with only two hands, though i sure could have used 3 or 4. the handle peening wasn't too awkward actually, but peening the little pins that hold the gears on was tricky.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#7

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

I tried solvents, but it didn't make things better. The handle seems to bind more in one spot as I turn it.

How do you file off the peened end without filing a groove into the crank arm?

This drill has a thin handle that is about 2.5" long and the pin head sits proud at the end. It seems like I'd have to do something like shave off the end of the handle to make it shorter. Trying to countersink it would be tricky, I think. On the other hand, the ferule around the handle is rusted, so maybe that rust could be causing the problem? Would it be possible and useful to try to remove rust before trying to disassemble?

One of the follow-ups said the assembly had to be tight when going to re-rivet. But I don't want it to be tight---that's the whole point. Am I missing something here? Would I want to introduce a removable spacer of some sort to give a bit of extra space in there?

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#8

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

i dont see why it would be necessary to file a groove in the crank arm. the simplest method is to just file the peen down flush with the crank arm. alternatively, you might be able to file around the peen, reducing its diameter but not its length. in either case, you are likely to scratch up the surface of the crank arm a bit when filing. since i was going to be doing some heavy sanding of the back of the crank arm anyway, i didn't worry about it.

shaving off the end of the handle to make it shorter sounds like a reasonable plan.

not sure what you mean about de-rusting the ferule. you could always try it.

"One of the follow-ups said the assembly had to be tight when going to re-rivet."

i think that was Bill H who wrote "...a good idea to tap around the rivet/pin to make sure it's seated well." he's refering to the fit between the pin and the crank arm. the fit between the wood and pin can be as sloppy as you'd like.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#9

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

What I meant was that in filing off the peen I'd scratch up the crank arm. I'm not planning a total refinishing like you did (they look really nice). I just want to get the tool working smoothly. So removing the metal plating from the crank arm is suboptimal. I was wondering if anybody makes files that are convex along their length so you could hit the pin without touching the crank, but I haven't seen any.

Regarding derusting, I normally do it by soaking in evaporust, but I'm not sure I want to soak the handle. I'm not sure I can think of a method that would get at rust that is on the inside. And in any case, rust tends to be weak and flake off, so I'm not sure that rust could make the handle stick. The fact that it sticks on one side makes me wonder if the problem is that the handle is slightly bent.

If the handle is slightly bent, it might be difficult to reuse the pin that holds the handle on. I'd have to be able to straighten it. Is it possible to buy a replacement for this part (e.g. from McMaster)? What is the correct name for this part?

I'm not sure I understand what you mean about the rivet seating well. I mean, if there's space around the wood then won't the rivet be able to move off the crank surface? The pin would be free to shift side to side in this case. It seems like it would be difficult to tap the metal of the pin out and keep a space underneath between the wood and the crank unless I used a spacer.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#10

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

the pin has a shoulder on it. in other words, for most of its length, its diameter is larger than the hole in the crank arm. it necks down to pass through the hole. take a close look at the picture below, and you'll see what i mean

possibly you could remove the pin without damaging the nickel coating on the crank handle by drilling straight into the peened part using the right size bit. you will probably ruin the pin though. a milling machine and end mill would give a better result.

i don't know the proper name for the pin, or if there even is one. mcmaster won't have an exact replacement. if you're clever, you could find a combination of parts there that would work. maybe a headed pin coupled with a tubular spacer. or a dowel pin threaded on each end, coupled with some machine screws.


img

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#11

Option B -- a woodworking approach

Lars Parrington

it seems like we might be getting beyond your metalworking comfort or skill level, so let me suggest a woodworking approach to the same problem.

using your favorite implement of destruction, break the wooden handle off. leave the pin attached to the crank arm and don't damage either of those. clean up any rusty crud stuck to the pin. then make a new wooden handle in two pieces (split lengthwise), and glue it together over the pin.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#12

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

Note that my metal working skills, as rudimentary as they are, are better developed than my turning skills, which are totally nonexistent. And I suspect that in this case the actual amount of true skill needed (as opposed to simple knowledge) is higher for turning than for the appropriate metalwork. (And a lathe would cost more than a 2nd drill.) So if I want to pursue a fix I think it'll have to be on the metalworking side. I'm asking lots of questions because I don't want to disassemble the handle and find myself unable to get it back together, basically having transformed a working tool with an annoyance into a non-working tool.

You forgot to attach the picture, but I think I understand what you mean. If the part that passes through the crank is narrower then that means that I really have to conserve material when filing if I want to be able to re-rivet the handle on, and the fix job will be weaker than the original. Is that right? Is it possible to hammer the rivet end from the side to conserve material so less needs to be filed off? It occurred to me that by using a file with a safe edge like my auger bit file I could limit damage to the crank arm.

What is the solution if the problem is that the pin is bent? I suppose leaving it bent and shortening the handle might work.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#13

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

the safe edge file sounds like a great idea to me. also, hammering from the side sounds like a reasonable thing to try. it sounds like you have a good understanding of the problem now, so i would say just keep trying out ideas like that until you get it apart.

you're correct that once apart, there may not be enough material left on the narrow section of the pin to get it satisfactorily put back together. that is what i was talking about in my first post about cutting back the shoulder to make that narrow section longer, or drilling and tapping the end of the pin instead. ideally, you would have a lathe for either operation, but i think a respectable job could be done by hand too (if done carefully enough).

there's certainly the risk that you'll ruin some part along the way. that is where you might turn to a mcmaster solution. i was thinking this morning that a shoulder bolt with nut might make a nice pin replacement.

p.s. i remembered to attach the picture to my last post about 1/2 hour after posting it, so it's there now, although it sounds like you no longer need it.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#14

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

How could I cut the shoulder back without a lathe? That seems like it would be hard to do. Could I use a grinder and grind it back? (Seems like it might be hard to hold the part against the grinder.)

Your other suggestion for what to do if the pin ends up too short was to drill it and tap it. I assume that is for inserting a screw that replaces the rivet? I did look at shoulder screws at McMaster and it appears that these don't come with rounded heads. In fact, the 3" ones all have knurled hex heads, which doesn't seem great. I suppose I might be able to grind or file the head into a nicer profile.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#15

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Adrian,

".... the crank handle is really tight. "

Does this mean that the knob is frozen and will not budge? Or will it turn a little if you twist hard enough?

Wiley

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#16

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Lars Parrington

i was thinking carefully file it. maybe you could chuck it into a drill to make the filing go quicker. maybe rest the safe edge of your file against the narrow diameter section of the pin push towards its head.

i didn't say the mcmaster solution would be perfect or pretty, but it will get you back to functional.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#17

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

The crank handle turns, but there is enough resistance that I find it annoying. The resistance is uneven. There is one "hump" you have to get over. It is conceivable that somebody less picky might consider the tool usable in its current state.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#18

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

OK. Does only the knob turn? Or can you make the rivets turn as well? When the knob turns through the 'hump', is the rivet turning with the knob, or do the rivets always stay fixed in place?

Wiley

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#19

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

Only the knob turns. The rivets stay fixed, even when going over the "hump".

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#20

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That pretty much narrows it down to the wood binding on the axle. There remains the conceptual possibility of the ferrule rubbing against the crank handle, but you could see that, or test it with a drop of oil.

What to do? I would focus on getting some lubrication down onto the axle--there has to be an annular space between the axle and the wooden knob. Get some lubrication into that annular space. With that in mind, is there any play, where you can pull the wooden knob outwards, enough to drip some light machine oil or WD-40 down onto the axle and work it down the axle?

If not, consider making your own oil hole. I have never done this but would think about it in this case--you could drill a 1/16" (or even a little smaller if you have number drills) hole through the ferrule down to the axle. That gives you an oil hole. File the entry smooth so it'd look factory. Add oil. If that doesn't work, you're down to 'how bad do I want to fix this thing'? Lars has already listed and detailed the remaining options.

Wiley

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#21

Or....

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

If there is a little play, maybe immerse the whole knob in olive oil overnight, and see if that will get down into the workings. If not, little has been lost and no damage done. I cited WD-40 in my last post--that may be a bad idea, I believe WD-40 may ruin whatever finish is on the wooden knob. Chemist Bill Tindall could be of help here!

Wiley

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#22

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

I tried working solvents in and I think it made a slight difference. I could try seeing if working a lubricant in makes a difference. It's hard to tell if the chemicals actually make it in to the axle. (Note: WD-40 is a solvent, not a lubricant, even though many people seem to be confused about this point. If you want an actual lubricant, use something else.) I wonder, given how hard it is to work solvents and chemicals in, how crud could have gotten in to create problems.

Are the pins iron? Could the pin be rusted inside?

I don't think I can tell visually whether the ferule is rubbing against the crank or not. But maybe I can test with feeler gauges.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#23

scott grandstaff

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

scott grandstaff

Take a very thin knife blade. Crappy steak knife or something.

Drive it in, under the handle, above the bar.

Now take another knife just like it, and drive it in under the other side.

Pressure from both sides is the point. You don't want to bent the rivet, you want pressure pushing the knob up.

Pull them back out and test.

Big difference huh?

If its still not free enough for you? Try thicker knife blades.

Rivets get loose over time, then people pound them.

They pound them too much, and it makes for a tight knob.

But its only a wooden knob and you can compress wood enough to make you a soft loose fit again.

No sweat

yours Scott

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#24

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

I picked up the drill to try some of the things discussed and discovered that it has improved while sitting on the bench. It seems that while I've been asking for advice, the solvent I applied has been quietly working invisibly on the inside (without even trying Wiley's oil hole scheme). So I sprayed a ton more solvent on it and turned the knob a lot to try to work it in, and am hoping for further improvement. One troubling observation is that it would turn freely and fairly easily for a while, but then the "hump" would reappear. And then go away. I wonder if that means that something broke inside and there's a chunk of handle floating loose.

Re: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

#25

Update: fix for tight handle on eggbeater drill?

Adrian

I sprayed it with solvent (Kroil) and rotated the handle some more and let it sit for a few days, and then repeated. At this point the handle spin freely and easily. It took several ways to go away completely---for a while it would go away but then reappear every few turns--but the "hump" has apparently cleared out.