New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Building a Strike Block Plane

Posts

Building a Strike Block Plane

#1

Building a Strike Block Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Over the past few weekends I have been busily building planes for the forthcoming Perth LN Tool Event. In past years I have demonstrated joint-making with handtools (OK, in the land of the blind ...). This year I shall be demonstrating plane building.

I thought it pertinent that I take along some new planes (some for demonstration and a few to sell). To this end I have so far completed 11 planes (it sounds grander than it really is - there are 5 router planes, 2 Krenov smoothers, and 3 Krenov block planes). I am just waiting on a few parts, plus have one more to complete (a solid body coffin smoother), and then I shall post pictures.

This is a solid body strike block plane. Why did I choose this particular plane to build? It is not as though I am low on planes for shooting. However I wanted one to dedicate to my ramped shooting board. Plus I enjoy using woodies, and my eventual plan is to fill a tool cabinet with planes I have made.

The strike block is a bevel down plane with a low cutting angle designed for shooting end grain. It is an alternative to a mitre plane, which achieves the same cutting angle from a bevel up orientation.

Were we discussing metal planes, there would be no question that the bevel up plane has the advantage of achieving a low cutting angle. Take for example both the Lee Valley and the Lie-Nielsen BU Jack. Built in strong and durable ductile iron, there is no difficulty in building in a 12-degree bed. Add a 25 degree bevel, and the result is a 37 degree cutting angle. This is great for planing end grain.

Wood is not a strong enough medium for low bevel planes. A 12-degree wooden bed is vulnerable. Building a 20 degree bed, while stronger, does not offer any advantage over a common angle (45 degree) bevel down plane. The strike block plane provides the low cutting angle by having a bed between 35 – 40 degrees.

Larry Williams (Old Street Tools) suggests that strike block planes fell out of favour in the 18th Century owing to the casual sharpening techniques of the day. His view is that it is imperative to maintain a clearance angle of a minimum of 10 degrees. Consequently, unless the bevel is maintained at about 25 degrees, a strike block plane may run out of clearance angle and stop cutting.

The plane build here is based on a bed of 38 degrees. This should provide the same performance as a low angle bevel up plane with a 12 degree bed. The overall dimensions are a 14” length (that comes from the Old Street version), with a 2 ½” wide x 2 1/8” high body. The blade is 2 1/8” wide, tapered and laminated high carbon steel.

I have used Jarrah for the strike block plane, mainly as it is a dense and heavy wood, and I have a good supply of dry, salvaged roofing trusses. The wedge is White Oak.



There is a steel strike button (more durable than wood) ...


The underside shows the brass mouth ...


A close up (because someone will ask anyway :) ) ...


This is where it will work (although it will also be useful for cross flattening panels) ...


And .. yes .. it works very nicely. Easy shavings in 1/2" Jarrah endgrain ...


There is a step-by-step record of the build on my website: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/BuildingaStrikeBlockPlane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

#2

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

TomD

Beautiful! Though the metal inlay reminds me of that line in Once Upon a Time in the West:

"How can you trust a man who wears both a belt and suspenders? The man can't even trust his own pants."

After 35 years making my own wooden planes and using them, I don't think there is enough time left to justify worrying about wear on mouths or strikers. Of course that doesn't mean one shouldn't use metal ones: "Oh reason not the need"

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

#3

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

Thanks.

The brass wear strip/mouth was not planned. If you read the build pictorial you will discover that I had problems with blades. The final blade is the third I tried. The upshot is that the mouth ended larger than intended (as it fit the first blade perfectly). The brass mouth was the fix. Of course, I'll tell everyone it was intended all along! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

#4

Question about strike block planes

Patrick Gibbons

I seem to remember strike block planes having an angle greater than 45 degrees. With what am I confusing them?

Re: Building a Strike Block Plane

#5

Re: Question about strike block planes

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I seem to remember strike block planes having an angle greater than 45 degrees. With what am I confusing them?

Possibly just about everything else!

No idea. A strike block plane follows a path in a completely different direction.

Regards from Perth

Derek