New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

Posts

Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

#1

Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

Jay St. Peter

OK, I don't mean the part that's supposed to be sharp. But, the edges along the length of the chisel. I was using one fairly aggressively the other day and actually cut myself a little. I'm thinking I should take some 400 grit or so and run it along the long edges to dull them down a bit. I can't think of a reason why I shouldn't do that. Is there a reason they are so crisp?

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

#2

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

TomD

When I started out in the Japanese tool market, I read something suggesting I should sharpen those edges, so they would shear better. I got some gushers, but the upside was that I eventually learned to use the handles...

If you dub the edges, all things being equal you will transfer that dullness to the corners, which are one of my favourite parts. There are workarounds for everything... one of which would be chasing the corners as you go, which will probably affect the width at the edge. I don't do it but I doubt anything really bad will happen.

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

#3

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Jay

The minimal lands do help especially with dovetails. However I have cut myself on chisels (and also plane blades) when freehand sharpening.

Now I soften the edges on a worn 600 diamond stone, working to about 1" behind the bevel - just enough to soften and not enough to alter the edge shape.

I posted this info when reviewing the Veritas chisels ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

#4

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

David Charlesworth

That's pretty much exactly what I do to all chisel edges that cut me.

I would say just leave the first 3/8" sharp, for good cutting , right up to the edge, and hone as little as possible from the rest.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

#5

Re: Any reason I shouldn't dull my LN chisels

Jay St. Peter

That was my plan, so I'll do it. Thanks guys!