Diamond paste carry-over
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
When we first started using diamond paste we thought that we had evidence that coarser grit particles stuck in the tool being sharpened where they could be transferred to the next plate in a sharpening sequence. Supporting evidence came from an old machinist handbook that discussed abrading with diamond paste.
During my recent trip I had the opportunity to test this presumption. A piece of high speed tool steel (I thought it was M2 but analysis was more consistent with M1), and a Stanley plane blade were abraded with a normal(scant) charge of 15 micron diamond on cast iron. The dull scratched surface where abrasion occurred was apparent and the surface abraded quickly(normally). The tool was then cleaned with solvent and wiped with paper towels and wrapped with a towel for transport. The abraded surface was examined with a state of the art Zeiss microscope to see if diamond particles could be seen in the scratches.
The results were unclear. A control of diamond paste smeared on the metal surface readily revealed a dense loading of approximately spherical diamond particles closer to 20 micron than 15. Because I was unable to re-clean the surface before examination there was "junk" to be seen when it was examined. By in large the junk was greater than 20 microns and not shaped like the diamond particles. The tool steel sample was "cleaner" and we detected few, if any, particles that could have been diamond particles. There was more stuff on the Stanley blade. There could have been some diamond particles on this blade but the result is uncertain.
We conclude that under the conditions of this experiment that there is little, or perhaps insignificant, transfer of particles to the steel being abraded.
As an aside, I was surprised how narrow the scratches were relative to the approximately 20 micron particles. Apparently even diamond does not penetrate the tool very much during abrasion.



