New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

A little plow plane help needed

Posts

A little plow plane help needed

#1

A little plow plane help needed

Ron Harper

This is an Atkin and Son plow plane. The screws that hold the depth adjustment are stripped. The depth adjustment will not work properly because the screws will not hold. Two remedies come to mind.

1) use a size longer screw.

2) remove screws. Bore clean hole. Insert and glue cross grain plug. Re use original screws.

Better ideas?

Thanks for help

Ron


img

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#2

Re: A little plow plane help needed

wilbur

I vote for #2. Overall, it will be a cleaner repair.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#3

Re: A little plow plane help needed

TomD

We used to just put steel wool in the screws on cross country skis, which take a heck of a lot more load. Advantage of doing that is the the plane remains in original condition, and it only takes a second. Toothpicks in the endgrain of the hole, also work.

If that won't work then I would put epoxy in the holes, drill them out and insert screws, less visible harm. I just did that repair to a ski, yesterday.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#4

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A little plow plane help needed

Stephen Shepherd

Don't use epoxy on that nice old plane, it will reduce its future value and integrity. Lightly oil the screws and wipe off any excess. Then wrap some linen twine around the threads, insert hide glue in hole and turn the screws in, clocking them. Allow the glue to dry. You may also want to put a light coat of oil on the underside of the brass depth stop to act as a glue release.

Stephen

Nice plough.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#5

Re: A little plow plane help needed

TomD

I like it. Of course Hide glue is just an earlier version of epoxy. It does everything, glues to itself, etc... Does not release too well though. Now that I know the traditional fix I will file that away for future use.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A little plow plane help needed *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

Tom,

Here is a link to a period e-pos-ee that works great. It dates from before 1824.

Stephen


img

Cutler's cement

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#7

Re: A little plow plane help needed

Terry McClean

Stephen, can you explain what you mean by "clocking" the screws as you turn them in?

Thanks

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#8

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A little plow plane help needed

Stephen Shepherd

Sure, it is something gunsmiths and watchmakers do when they put in screws, they make sure the slots all line up on the same 'time' of a clock, usually 6 and 12 or 3 and 9. It just looks better and shows those in the future just how anal we are.

Stephen

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#9

Thanks Tom and Stephen and old dog thought

Ron Harper

I suppose one would have to say that Stephen offered the best technical repair. However, before I saw his, I had already done as Tom suggested. Which, of course, solved my problem, at least or now. I am filing Stephen's post away in the event that further remediation is required. But for now, the depth stop on my plow plane is performing just fine.

As I have shared, forks in the road caused me to have a ten year hiatus in my woodworking. Ten years is a long time, and memory is not what it used to be. I did indeed know about Tom's remedy and had used it before. Sometimes it us not necessary to teach an old dog new tricks. You just remind him of ones he forgot :D

This place is such a fantastic resource for those of us who are serious about learning more about the craft.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#10

Threaded Inserts

ebushee

I had this problem with a moving fillister, and I drilled larger holes and put in threaded inserts. Probably devalued the plane, but it fixed the problem.

-Eric

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#11

Re: Thanks Tom and Stephen and old dog thought

TomD

Glad it is done and back in service. I would guess the best technical repair is the epoxy, but best repair in this case is presumably Stephens. Since I make a lot of my tools, and don't have a ton of the older ones, I do not often take into consideration value and authenticity. I am not oblivious to it as my wife was a conservator for a while, but my brain runs down a track that is more oriented towards practical engineering solutions rather than conservation ones. And that can be an oversight.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#12

Tell us a little about the plow

Patrick Gibbons

Ron, how sweet does she run? How many irons do you have?

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#13

Me too

Ron Harper

I have never been one of those who gets the fantods because a guy drills a hang hole in a number 5. I think so very few of us will ever have in our hands a piece of the nation's historical treasure, that much of the discussion in this area is idle.

Stephen has a background and owns tools that make his comments very appropriate and valuable. I will say again how much that I value your input as well.

I reflect back on the information that was readily available when I started to learn the craft, compared to the ease of getting massive quantities of information at our finger tips today. Forty years ago I could not have imagined a video of Paul Sellers or Curtis Buchanan that I could view on a tablet computer, take it to my workbench and try to duplicate what they had just tried to teach me. Incredible.

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#14

What little I know

Ron Harper

It is very clearly marked Atkin and Son, which means it was made in Birmingham UK between 1839 and 1845. I have had several plow planes and none of them compares with how sweetly this little guy performs. I have 5 irons that fit. Two of them fit after I ground the sides down.

I really had been planning to get a new Veritas small plow. Yesterday afternoon I realized that that would be silly. This thing is a whole lo better tool than I am a user. I know that not every one shares my view, but I much prefer to use old tools whenever I can. I have been very blessed over the years to have some century old tools that required very little tweaking to perform very well. These are my favorites. My only exception to that love affair is combination planes. I just got rid of my last one. I figure that I am not gonna live long enough to mess with them. :D

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#15

Stephen, a couple questions on the twine.

Chuck Nickerson

1. Is the linen twine in the threads to keep the glue from getting too good of a grip?

2. What keeps the twine in the threads while the screw is turned in?

Or does this work best when the wood threads are completely gone?

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#16

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Stephen, a couple questions on the twine.

Stephen Shepherd

1. Is the linen twine in the threads to keep the glue from getting too good of a grip?

No, the linen thread [I use linen because it is strong and has triangular shaped fibers] is to add filler and it is in the same shape as the threads.

2. What keeps the twine in the threads while the screw is turned in?

I put hide glue on the twine and wrap it around the screw threads in the groove, then hold the loose end on the end that goes in the hole then twist in the screw.

Or does this work best when the wood threads are completely gone?

Works on any size stripped out hole. For bigger holes I use bigger linen twine.

Don't use waxed linen thread or twine.

Stephen

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#17

Re: A little plow plane help needed

TomD

Thanks for that thoughtful addition!

Is there something one can add to hide glue to make it more water resistant? I gather walnut oil added to shelac makes it more water resistant, but is there anything for hide glue?

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#18

Re: Me too

TomD

Yeah, it really is. The key to the information age is the devaluing of information as it become ubiquitous. Or more democratic. I'm sure everyone has the odd pang based on how hard it may have been to gain the info in the first place, but none the less, sharing is the only real option for most of us. It is a great time to pick up a craft or two. Now if I could just master TIG welding...

Re: A little plow plane help needed

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A little plow plane help needed *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

I talk about this in my book, there are a couple of things to make hide glue water resistant, you can mix it up with non fat skim milk instead of water, you can mix up dry powdered non fat dry milk with water and add to liquid hide glue.

As for waterproof, you can use formaldahyde or alum to make it waterproof. Care must be taken so as not to allow it to dry in the glue pot, no way to remove after it is dry except to burn it out.

Stephen


Hide Glue Book