Re: Drawer Slip History
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
His name is Jack Plane on his blog, and Woodwould on the Aussie forum.
I have assembled some of the relevant comments he made on the Oz forum (from one of my build threads) in regard to slips and dovetails. Keep in mind that Woodwould (or Jack Plane) had little time for furniture built or designed after the 18th century.
"I despise drawer slips of all forms and do not condone their use!
The Georgian items that Fuzzie refers to are purely runners that bear the weight of the drawer and play no part in retaining the drawer bottom.
First and foremost, slips are downright ugly (as are muntins), they're synonymous with cheap work (as are muntins), they're unnecessary and they encroach on drawer space.
A better design functionally or aesthetically? Functionally, Basilg's wide runner is probably as good as it gets. However, I see nothing wrong with the seventeenth- and eighteenth-century designs – after all, many examples are still in un-restored daily use. Runners are easily replaced, so even restored seventeenth- and eighteenth-century chests of drawers will survive for many more centuries.
For full size drawers, I'm happy with 5/16" or even 1/4" thick bottoms. For small table drawers, 3/16" is fine and 1/8" was plenty for the small drawers in my recent shelves.
I dovetail the drawer sides on. The drawer bottoms are nailed into rebates in the drawer sides and then the runners are glued to the underside of the bottoms/sides.
Who said thin-sided-and-slipped drawers have a long and traditional reputation for elegance? Slips are a product of the machine age and elegance was the last thing on their inventor's mind.
With the homogenisation of furniture during the industrial revolution, drawer slips simply made it easier to construct drawers – the sides required no further work than dovetailing. The slips could be made by the yard from virtual waste and sapwood and drawer bottoms could be slipped into them with no handwork required.
(Nailing on bottoms) was the standard method in England too until about 1695 when the first runners appeared."
Regards from Perth
Derek