New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Drawer Slip History

Posts

Drawer Slip History

#1

Drawer Slip History

Don Stephan

Drawer slips have been an area of interest for me since Richard Jones first shared them here years ago. At different times I've made inquiries of some woodworkers and museums for information on drawer slips - where, when and why they were used- with no success. A FWW article on drawer types years ago obliquely hinted they may have originated in France, but I've always simply assumed they originated in England. I've also assumed they were developed to slow the rate of drawer sag, as slips more than double the width of the wearing surface. Can anyone provide historic details on these fascinating drawer enhancements? Thanks.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#2

Re: Drawer Slip History

William Duffield

A recent in-depth analysis of the evolution of English drawer construction can be found on Jack Plane's blog, Pegs and 'Tails. While primarily about drawer dovetails, some information on slips is also included.

Drawer Front Dovetail Evolution

While the article may not provide the answers we are looking for, it may at least enlighten the discussion.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#3

Re: Drawer Slip History

Patrick Gibbons

A good article William. He clearly shows why London dovetails were used to offset seasonal movement. In his illustrations we see drawers that are grooved on the outside to engage runners on the carcase. That's a mute argument against using slips because of the sides being too thin to accept grooves for the bottom. It also appears that other examples with thin sides did not utilize slips. I don't believe he showed a single piece that had slips. I may not be observing correctly so please inform me if I'm wrong. Pine was used to make drawers as well as hardwood and the blogger references an earlier entry on deal that was enlightening. The evolution of drawer construction as presented in this article begs the question when drawers themselves became common. Construction of these changed much from the 16th to 18th centuries. They must not have been common before this or these details would have been worked out sooner. While chests were common before this time, the chest of drawers was not.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#4

Skinny dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Alan Batty, who worked in an English factory making drawers, provided the most convincing reason for skinny dovetails. With an oak side and mahogany front one could make the drawer faster by removing a lot of wood from the soft mahogany front and three saw cuts and a single chisel pare made the pin socket in the oak side. The joint was cut with a slight taper and the skinny pins drove like nails into the oak sides. The quota was 6 drawers per day.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#5

Re: Drawer Slip History

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

His name is Jack Plane on his blog, and Woodwould on the Aussie forum.

I have assembled some of the relevant comments he made on the Oz forum (from one of my build threads) in regard to slips and dovetails. Keep in mind that Woodwould (or Jack Plane) had little time for furniture built or designed after the 18th century.

"I despise drawer slips of all forms and do not condone their use!

The Georgian items that Fuzzie refers to are purely runners that bear the weight of the drawer and play no part in retaining the drawer bottom.

First and foremost, slips are downright ugly (as are muntins), they're synonymous with cheap work (as are muntins), they're unnecessary and they encroach on drawer space.

A better design functionally or aesthetically? Functionally, Basilg's wide runner is probably as good as it gets. However, I see nothing wrong with the seventeenth- and eighteenth-century designs – after all, many examples are still in un-restored daily use. Runners are easily replaced, so even restored seventeenth- and eighteenth-century chests of drawers will survive for many more centuries.

For full size drawers, I'm happy with 5/16" or even 1/4" thick bottoms. For small table drawers, 3/16" is fine and 1/8" was plenty for the small drawers in my recent shelves.

I dovetail the drawer sides on. The drawer bottoms are nailed into rebates in the drawer sides and then the runners are glued to the underside of the bottoms/sides.

Who said thin-sided-and-slipped drawers have a long and traditional reputation for elegance? Slips are a product of the machine age and elegance was the last thing on their inventor's mind.

With the homogenisation of furniture during the industrial revolution, drawer slips simply made it easier to construct drawers – the sides required no further work than dovetailing. The slips could be made by the yard from virtual waste and sapwood and drawer bottoms could be slipped into them with no handwork required.

(Nailing on bottoms) was the standard method in England too until about 1695 when the first runners appeared."

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Drawer Slip History

#6

comments

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

"I dovetail the drawer sides on. The drawer bottoms are nailed into rebates in the drawer sides and then the runners are glued to the underside of the bottoms/sides." I see this method used on some of the furniture in the Shelbyville shop. Maybe this method is why some drawer bottoms are installed with long grain running parallel to the drawer side. It made nailing the bottom in easier.....and invariably led to a split bottom.

"With the homogenisation of furniture during the industrial revolution, drawer slips simply made it easier to construct drawers – the sides required no further work than dovetailing. The slips could be made by the yard from virtual waste and sapwood and drawer bottoms could be slipped into them with no handwork required." While the author presents this argument as a reason to eschew this style of slips I find it a reason to use them. But then my furniture building methods are not stalled in 1720.

There is something to be said for a drawer bottom that handily slips out. It makes adjusting the drawer a simple exercise should it be needed.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#7

Re: Drawer Slip History

Tony Zaffuto

If I might add an opinion about the use of drawer slips? From my perspective, I've been using slips on all drawer projects for the past few years, mainly because I find it a very simple and quick method! I don't have to deal with planning on where grooves occur in relation with dovetails, a place where no matter how much I plan, I inevitably mess up!

Re: Drawer Slip History

#8

Re: Drawer Slip History

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Sounds like a good reason to use them. I have the same problem getting all the grooves to wind up in one plane and this problem is, as you point out, lessened.

Re: Drawer Slip History

#9

Drawer Slip History

Tom Colligan

"The English love very fine drawer sides. I do, too. I've made pieces with drawer sides as thin as 3/16 in. Generally speaking, these sides are too thin for a groove that can house the bottom. The solution is to glue small grooved slips of wood to the bottom edges of the sides. The slips support the bottom, and the added thickness at the bottom edge of the sides doubles their wearing surface and longevity. I make up the slips separately, and glue them into place once the drawer box is assembled." Garrett Hack, FWW #213: A Solid Drawer Bottom I Worth The Effort

Re: Drawer Slip History

#10

Re: Drawer Slip History

Bruce McCrory

Cool idea! Didn't the Swedes/Danes/Finns(?) develop a special drawer design based on modified slips? 8)

I can see slips serving the function of a tertiary wood of better durability than secondary wood sides, doubling duty as slides and runners. In fact, I have been working on just that thought using milling resources I currently possess. ;)