New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

old files

Posts

old files

#1

old files

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't recall if I've posted this before, but if so I apologize in advance.

I have a bunch of old files and rasps rescued from my grandfather's garage/shop when we sold it. These are likely 70/80 years old. I will be sending a batch of them to Boggs just because I don't want to deal with sharpening them myself and also because Slav highly recommended them.

If it turns out they can't be sharpened because they're simply too worn, what kind of steel are they likely made from? All of them are Nicholsons. If they can't be sharpened, they're going to become other tools, knives, etc., providing they are at least W-1 or better.

TIA

Re: old files

#2

Re: old files

david weaver

Something similar to W1. If they are very old, they might be a little higher carbon content than W1.

Re: old files

#3

Re: old files

TomD

Some of the guys on this thread are pretty serious guys:

http://www.knifenetwork.com/forum/showthread.php?t=28833

Re: old files

#4

Re: old files

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I could be so lucky as to have a batch of 1095. I've been warned to grind ALL the teeth off so as to avoid potential stress points. BTW, thanks for the knifeworks ref. I've not heard of that forum before. I generally go to bladeforum of knife dogs.

Re: old files

#5

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: old files

#6

Re: I'd long heard Nichoson used 1095

TomD

So long as the steel hardens file hard, which is presumably will in this case, or if one is cold working it, then it starts hard, it's all good. Knowing what it is is over-rated. And guys that really like a type of steel will often search out a large glob of it just to avoid the variations that exist even from batch to batch.

Re: old files

#7

Re: old files

TomD

You are welcome. The grind the teeth off thing applies particularly to stuff like grinding files into scrapers for turning. Sometimes these tool weren't even tempered. The caution could also apply to certain heavy use knives, though there, they often forge the file and leave a section of file or rasp visible, for texture. There are many woodworking tools where the file would never be heavily tweaked or pried.

Re: old files

#8

Re: George Wilson told me...

david weaver

..that the file steels in older files are sometimes (often?, always?) higher carbon than newer files, and the files are harder.

The old ones are definitely more crisp, I can see that just looking at them. The edges, the teeth, everything.

George sold me a set of needle files, they are swiss maybe, from the early 1900s. They are the most superb things I have ever seen, every edge on them is crisp and every tooth grips anything it comes in contact with.

Re: old files

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: old files

#10

Re: That's what I'm saying - confirmed...

John Aniano in Central NJ

David and Bruce,

I found two older English files, one stamped "Barley Sheaf" (late 19th century?), in a pile of rusty tools in a barn about 8 years ago. I sent them to Boggs for sharpening thinking that if anyone could resurrect them, Boggs could. I was amazed at how well and easily they cut after sharpening. And absolutely, they appear to be of a harder steel than currently available. I use one specifically on mother-of-pearl because of this and the results are excellent. It never seems to wear out!

John

Re: old files

#11

Re: That's what I'm saying - confirmed...

TomD

Some new files are not made of tool steel they are case hardened, or some such. But that is relatively recent, as far as I know, I have converted "new" Nicholson into plane blades, and they were purchased some time in my career.

Re: old files

#12

My problem with files

Patrick Gibbons

Rust is a never ending battle. I've oiled some patches of rust on files but I'm not sure if this is good practice. The majority of files I own are late American-made Nicholsons. Some have dulled much quicker than expected. I guess my replacement choices are limited. Other than eBay, what are some other sources of NOS? I know about Slav but don't know how to access him.

Re: old files

#13

Re: My problem with files

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Slav posts on the WoodNet handtools forum. He lives in the Chicago area and makes it to some regional MWTCA meetings. I bought a couple rasps from him a month ago at the MWTCA tool meet in MN. He's a great guy with a bigger selection of rasps and files than any hardware/tool store you've ever seen.

Re: old files

#14

Re: My problem with files

TomD

Obviously Nicholson is a good brand that one can get from big box stores etc... But I also get the oddball sizes from industrial, machinist suppliers. Those guys use files for real, and even the cheapo brands work pretty well. I get mine from KBC, but Enco seems the more popular place in the US. Or MSC. KBC is US also, but they opened up in Toronto, which is nice for us.

http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INSRAR?PMSECT=0002001213

http://www.kbctools.com/can/Navigation/NavPDF.cfm?PDFPage=553

Re: old files

#15

Re: My problem with files

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Tom,

have you ever used any Bahco files or rasps?

Re: old files

#16

Re: Slav's Contact Info

William Duffield

Here is the contact info I have for Slav. I have no idea how much of it is still valid.

Slobodan Jelesijevich

Phone - 312-455-0430

2023 West Carroll Ave.

Chicago IL 60612

I also have two e-mail addresses for him, but again I have no idea if they are current:

slavstoolshop@aol.com

lunytools@aol.com

Re: old files

#17

Thanks everyone


Re: old files

#18

Re: My problem with files

TomD

I don't think so. Rasps I would be more cautious about since machinists are not all high end woodworkers, and asian rasps I have bought from machine shops have not been wonderful. But conversely, I have had good luck with files bought in such places since many machinists are experienced in file work, and would not put up with junk.