Good info on sensitive topic
Ron Harper
See Shannon's blog about exotics
http://www.renaissancewoodworker.com/stop-apologizing-for-using-wood/
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Good info on sensitive topic
Ron Harper
See Shannon's blog about exotics
http://www.renaissancewoodworker.com/stop-apologizing-for-using-wood/
Re: Good info on sensitive topic
William Duffield
It is curious that Shannon's well thought out post has not attracted vicious responses from irrational tree huggers. Anywhere else on the Net where comments are accepted on similar topics, even at Lost Art Press, the rabidity of a small percentage of vocal readers is readily apparent.
Thanks for posting the link. I would also encourage those who blog or comment on other woodworking fora to provide links to Shannon's article.
It would probably not be a good idea to mention that the company he works for imports virtually all of the teak that comes into the U.S. If you need some teak to build a campaign chest, for example, their retail outlet is Teak To Go.
Re: Good info on sensitive topic
TomD
I don't really buy most of that. Teak is one of a few woods that are manageable at some level of quality. Many woods are simply gone. And even where commercial exploitation is sustainable that does not mean that the forest environment is being preserved. Trees, in monoculture do not equal a biosphere.
I use various woods through a moral system known as "I don't care". The reality is that Brazilian rosewood either makes it into concert classical guitars, or it gets cut up into veneer and laminated around disposable lighters. The majority of really nice redwood and cedar I have seen was destined for decks, were it will be junked the moment some homeowner's whim changes, or after it rots out in ten + years. Far better it makes it into a boat or a soundboard, at least as far as I am concerned.
And part of it is just what concerns you. Woodwork is part of culture and has it's place. I don't have a huge problem that people may argue against wood use, I just don't feel required to join them. We know full well that environmentalist who feel passionately enough jet all over the place to have conferences on the causes of global warming. I am not playing the hypocracy card, I am just saying that if you feel passionately about something you tend to carve out an exception, and I am doing that for wood.
Right now, under the Lacy act, using certain woods is pretty risky for reasons of potential prosecution. I am giving a lot of thought to that, and not so much to the people that think that using quality hardwoods for heating is carbon neutral.