New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

Posts

Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#1

Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Am circling around the glue-up of a desktop, trying to think how to proceed with the top veneers, which are sawn satinwood approx. 1/8" thick (they'll finish about 3/32"). Here is a photo of the loose pieces I'm working with: The center field is quartered satinwood; the crossbanding is ribbonstripe satinwood, 2" wide:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8493267960/in/set-72157632172323442

The crossband will be mitered at the corners. There will be a string (white, black, or black/white--not sure which yet) separating the center field from the cross banding, and another string outboard of the cross banding--this latter string will be rabbeted into the satinwood lip that will be the edge of the top. I expect the finish will be oil followed by X coats of blond shellac; cut back the shellac to satin, and wax.

How to proceed? Am sure there is a standard way, but I don't know what it is. Here are the options I see:

Option 1, Center first: Glue the center field first, making all decisions about string and string widths up front; leave enough margin so that the top can be trimmed back to the cross banding after it is applied (so the crossbanding itself doesn't have to be trimmed back to take up fitting error); then plane off glue, apply lip, level everything, and apply finish as final step.

Option 2, Crossband first: Glue the crossbanding first, leaving stringing decisions open. Then fit the center field into the open middle, getting it to within 1/32" of a fit all around; plane off glue, level, and add a first coat of finish; now make stringing decisions, having seen the color and grain of the wood in full-size; cut in the interior stringing and plane it level; add lip to outside; add finish as final step. (The outside string will be rabbeted into the lip.)

Both options have advantages and disadvantages. In principle, I like Option 2 because I can see the final top before making the stringing decision. However, cutting the stringing into the finished top will not be real easy because the channel has to be cut 2" into the interior of the top (which is kind of a long throw for me) and slip-ups can be fatal at that point. Option 1 is easiest and most straightforward, but requires all decisions to be made up front--though I suppose if I guess wrong on the stringing, I could always dig it out and be no worse off than if I had gone Option 2 in the first place.

Any and all thoughts welcome!

Wiley

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#2

Re: Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This seems to be a pattern others have used. Find a picture and make the stringing decisions off the picture. And/or. lay some stringing options on the layout in the picture and see how it looks.

Given where I am at in the learning curve I would lay up the center and cross banding and use a Dremel or similar to cut the stringing grooves.

I am making something similar and Steve Latta told me a simpler way. Lay up center on plywood and trim to size. Glue thin strips of the "string colors" to edge of the framing "lumber" (in your case a veneered piece of what ever goes around the outside edge.) Miter the ends of the framing piece and glue it onto the center.

In my case the center will be curly rift ash, then a black "string" and then plain rift cut mitered framing surrounding it all.

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#3

Re: Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

William Duffield

This is how I would do it:

1. Cut the field a bit oversized and glue it down.

2. Using a cutting gauge, cut it to width all around to the width of the stringing + the cross banding. Remove the excess with your weapon of choice (probably a routah with a fence, but a router or chisel and shoulder plane would work, too.)

3. glue in the stringing, trimming it to length with a chisel at the corners. I would use blue painter's tape and clamped cauls.

4. Remove the painter's tape, and clean up glue squeeze out with a shoulder plane or chisel.

5. Fit the miters of the satinwood crossbanding. Glue the ends (shorter lengths) of cross banding first, using cauls and handscrews.

6. Fit the miters of the sides (longer lengths). Apply glue to two overlapping lengths of cross banding. Cut them to fit near the center of the long sides, using a square and knife (one cut through both pieces). Caul and clamp.

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#4

Re: Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

James Watriss

Yeah, no pressure. :-)

My instinct re: your question is center field first. It's easier to miter the cross banding after that, to fit. If a miter is slightly off-square, if the banding doesn't go down straight, whatever, you'll be chasing that field all day trying to get it to inset. And that's if everything goes right.

A note on sizing, as in, glue, water, and glycerine... This is important to do. Dry wood that gets wet on one side will warp. Veneer will curl, and do funny things.

My opinion on how to go forward: Size your veneer. Then cut your pieces to fit, and edge glue all pieces so the visible joints are done already. Doing one part and then the other, you'll have glue beads to clean up, edge bruising from clamping, and all kinds of other issues to contend with and clean up befpre you lay in the next part... And the more opportunities you'll have to make new problems. So glue the field up first.

Leave the stringing until the field has been successfully glued down. You can make or buy any number of tools to help you to cleanly slice the stringing in. But bottom line, you don't inlay a surface before you're done building that surface.

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#5

Re: Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

I have not done this myself, but am familiar with the process. This being to start at the centre and work outwards.

I recall a wonderful demonstration on The Woodwrights Shop, well worth watching ..

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2800/2810.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#6

Re: Sawn veneer;  order of assembly?

wilbur

I'm working on my first veneer project, and my understanding is that traditional practice is to start with the middle and work outward.

If the issue is making decisions upfront, I'd get a big piece of paper and draw out your final design full size, and tweak it on paper so you know what your final dimensions are before committing to veneering. Everyone who has ever talked to our woodworking club on designing takes this approach.

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#7

Response and Thanks!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks to all! Many useful suggestions--I will lay out below what I've gleaned, and would welcome any more thoughts and suggestions (or arguments) that you may have.

Comments to those replying:

As everyone has said, I will start from the center, and build outward. Both Bill T and James suggest laying up the center field and the cross banding, then cutting in the interior stringing. That may well be the best way to do this job, and was part of my option 2, but on reflection I'm scared to do it that way, for fear of fatally munging up the top after it is essentially complete. Instead, will do what I had not thought of--Sir Wm's strategy of laying up the center field oversized, then cutting it back to final dimension after the glue is scraped off. This approach avoids the problem that James brought out--which is dinging up a final edge getting the glue off. Will use Old Brown Glue on three surfaces--the substrate and both sides of the field to avoid the cupping that James cautioned about.

After cutting back the center field to final, i will apply the interior string by dragging it through hot hide glue, bring it out dripping and press it into place with fingers, then butting it up with a metal straight edge for a couple minutes til the glue seizes. Miter the string corners in place with a chisel, except for the fourth side, which will have to be an exact fit as glued.

On the cross-banding, will use Sir Wm's suggestion to lay up the end pieces, then do the long sides in two pieces, fitting the miters and making the final cut to fit in the middle. Because these veneer pieces are thick sawn sticks, I won't be able to knife cut them to fit, but will be able to use that basic approach, which solves the huge problem of how to get those long miters perfect--they're the most visible part of the whole top, and the light wood will emphasize even a tiny lack of fit.

Will use Bill T's suggestion about applying the outer string to the edging. It will be rabbeted into the inside edge of the outer framing strip. This avoids the problem of having to plane back into that outer string when preparing to glue on the border.

Derek, the video was most enjoyable and brought back some happy (and some not so happy) memories of when I was a starving student back at UNC about the time that Roy started his Woodwright Shop there. Thank you. And Wilbur, you're right, my main issue was wanting to defer the stringing decisions. Sir Wm's approach will serve the same purpose as the full-scale drawing, except the drawing will be right on the substrate of the top.

Big thanks to all! It's tremendously helpful to get other people's take on things. You have brought out a couple of key issues I would not have thought of otherwise.

Additional thoughts, musings, clarifications, heated arguments--all welcome, of course!

Wiley

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#8

Re: Response and Thanks!

William Duffield

Note that the last time I remember doing something similar, it was not the same as yours, and the differences constrained the order in which I did things. First, the field was the solid mahogany of the table top. Only the stringing and Ceylon satinwood cross banding were veneer. In addition to cutting the field to width for the stringing, I needed to lower the surface of the top to the thickness of the banding. For this, I used a router. The table top had rounded corners, so the stringing had to follow a radius, instead of being mitered on the corners, and the cross banding had to be coopered, so its grain ran perpendicular to the edge all the way around the corners. The coopering was done one piece at a time with a block plane, and the inside radius was shaped with PSA sandpaper on a dowel. I used veneer tape to assemble the individual pieces of satinwood. The stringing and banding were modern, sliced, and so were a lot thinner than your sawn veneer, and thus I could get away with a single knife cut to fit two pieces tightly.


Corner radii were 8". The white and black banding were 1/8" wide. The strips of Ceylon satinwood started about 1" wide and 2-1/4" long.

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#10

Couple more things

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Sir Wm, that table top is gorgeous! Your black/white string convinces me that is the way I should go with the string dividing the centerfield from the cross banding. Konrad Sauer suggests making the ebony string very thin and the white a little heavier--will do that. I will use your method for fitting the longside crossbanding pieces: To make it work, will use two pieces, fit the miters at each end, mark their crossover, then slide them apart by a dozuki saw kerf, and saw through both pieces at once (that's conceptual, I left out the details ;) ).

Derek gave us a link to Roy Underhill and two other guys working with sawn veneer. That video showed them making great use of toothing planes, including toothing the ground. Little while after watching that, I called Kristen down at the Old Brown Glue works (where world class marquetry is done and taught also), and whilst ordering another bottle, asked her about the toothing. She instantly said yes, they tooth the ground every time, then called in to Patrick to make sure--I heard his affirmation too. Our own Stephen Shepherd has been adamant in favor of this point of view also. I'd be interested in Warren's view of toothing the substrate, as well. Anyway, I'm going to do it.

Bill, I will certainly provide pictures as I go, which will be necessarily slow as molasses, but will do it. Here is a better picture of the cross banding. I'm calling it ribbonstripe satinwood, because I don't know what else to call this figure. It has very strong chatoyance--if anyone has a more accurate term for this figure, I'd love to know about it. Konrad found this board up at A&M in his back yard, and was kind enough to resaw it on his Yates 'snowflake' band saw and ship it to me. What you see is three pieces of it edge-joined, and I am in the process of sawing 2-1/8" cross bands across the grain.

I took this photo because it was one of those moments when everything in one's world sort of melts together. At the top of the photo, there is an Old Street (late Clark & Williams) strike block plane, which is my go-to shooting plane. That plane has its whole side showing unbroken ray-fleck from top to bottom and stem to stern. I think current partner Don McConnell made the plane, though it could have been Larry. Anyway, in the morning air, Konrad's satinwood, Don's beech ray-fleck, Heiji's saw, and Dave Anderson's plane hammer all just sorta flowed together into one thing:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8489565365/in/set-72157632172323442

I send more stuff along as I make progress!

Thanks again to all,

Wiley

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#11

Re: Couple more things

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

awesome wood.

Anybody have a theory as to why "toothing" is desirable or necessary for this application while in every other kind of joinery we strive for as smooth a mating surface as possible?

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#12

For reference....

Tony - Memphis

I just completed a veneered round table top. The field is figured makore in pie wedges. I used a black inlay between the wedges and around the field with a cross banding of satinwood. I too was in a dilemma trying to figure out the best approach. Daryl Kleil (vacupress) and the veneer guru in CA (can't recall the name but he is very well known?) both suggested taping the whole thing together before applying. Saw the same thing in a book. After some thought, that made the best sense. So, I cut and taped everything together and glued it on the substrate as one piece. That felt much more comfortable than trying to create a groove after the fact. One difference to consider is that I was using thin commercial veneer. Good luck with your project.

One last thought, I used a piece of rubber pond liner to make up for the difference in thicknesses between the veneers and the inlay. I scraped the inlay down somewhat before pressing because it was a good bit thicker than the the veneers.

Tony

Here is a pic during the taping....the blue tape held the inlay until I could apply the veneer tape. This process worked really well. I saw it in a veneer/marquetry book I have.


Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#13

Re: Couple more things *LINK*

wilbur

Patrick Edwards says that toothing a surface that has been planed is a check to see if the surface is really flat. The toothing will identify low spots that might have been missed.

The other reason he states for toothing is if you are using sawn veneers. The toothing removes the saw marks. He also notes that with modern veneers, this is not an issue.

The toothing discussion comes in at 3:30 in this video. It's well worth watching.


Patrick Edwards on veneering techniques

Re: Sawn veneer; order of assembly?

#15

Re: Couple more things

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I don't do a lot of veneering, but I am inclined to believe the toothing helps adhesion. Ed Wright, Williamsburg harpsichord maker, claims this is the reason. He saws his own veneers. In the 18th century veneers were sawn by hand and then planed. Hand sawn veneers would need to planed; they are just too irregular otherwise. On the other hand the substrate would be flat. A guy who is used to hand planing stock doesn't need toothing to tell him it is flat. And if he were worried, he could use a smoothing plane the same way as the toothing plane and feel that it was cutting everywhere.

Hand planed surfaces are awfully slick. This really shows up in finishing so perhaps in gluing also.

Veneer technology has changed a number of times over the past 200 plus years