New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Stringing is underway

Posts

Stringing is underway

#1

Stringing is underway

Bill Tindall, E.TN.




Practice is over and these are the real drawers.

The layout is critical. To get the intersections of this 0.030" inch stringing near perfect requires that the layout of the compass point be right on to something like 0.005" or thereabouts. The whole layout is done with dividers, with very sharp points. Every compass point is on an orthogonal grid lined at 1/4 the pattern height. It is slow work. I can only begin to imagine how much extra a decorated Chester Co piece would have been to the customer buying it from the local cabinet maker.

I hope to be done by the end of next week. Or go crazy getting there.

Re: Stringing is underway

#2

Great job Bill!   


Re: Stringing is underway

#3

Re: Stringing is underway

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The stringing looks good, Bill. A nice thickness, which is really important. One thing you have to remember is that the guys who were doing this in Chester County likely did a good number of pieces with this same type of decoration. In my carving work I often do fifty or a hundred of the same thing. Over the course of the job, my speed will double or triple and the quality goes up as the effort and worry go down. I am sure that you will be a lot more confident on the last drawer than the first. And if you have a chance to do a half dozen chests you will wonder that you ever fretted about it.

Re: Stringing is underway

#4

the risk

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I did a sobering calculation. There is 20 feet! of stringing per drawer.

I usually think I have gotten good at something about one step before I have and suffer a major screw up. I'm trying for more discipline on this job.

Re: Stringing is underway

#5

Re: Stringing is underway

Patrick Gibbons

I'm impressed. Thank you for showing us your journey on acquiring the skill and applying it. Can't wait to see the finished product. The design looks good and your execution is very good.

Re: Stringing is underway

#6

Re: the risk

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We do see flaws in 18th century work, like junctures that don't meet perfectly or small chips missing, minor carelessness. What we don't often see is work where technical skill is ahead of artistic skill. Usually by the time a guy was doing fine technical work, style and proportion were already in place.

In today's reproductions we often see the opposite. A guy will make very careful scrollwork where the curves just aren't that stylish. Or flawless mouldings which don't have character, don't really sing. Today we are obsessed with flawless execution, in the 18th century they were obsessed with style.

Re: Stringing is underway

#7

Re: the risk

CStanford

Your fantastic post should be a sticky at the top of every woodworking forum on the internet.

Re: Stringing is underway

#8

You ARE a baaaaad man !


Re: Stringing is underway

#9

Re: Stringing is underway

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Really good, Bill. The one thing I have learned about ornament (I have no talent for it) is that there have to be points of tension in it. Usually where the design forms cusps. Your execution has real good tension at the apices of the 'concave diamond' figure.

Thanks very much for showing us the whole process of learning, what works and what doesn't, and then the execution in progress. Great teaching!

Wiley

Re: Stringing is underway

#10

plenty of tension

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I feel it in my shoulders after a couple of hours and gut when I swing that first arc and hope it lands in the right place!! I have already exhausted my CD collection of calm music.

If there is one trick I have learned it is that the string should not be tight in the trough when dry fitting......and to take the time to dry fit. Changes in grain make the troughs ever so slightly different in width as they proceed around the arc. One needs to scrape the string to get a favorable fit around the arc.

Re: Stringing is underway

#11

My usual progression is

Chuck Nickerson

1. Start something and make a mistake.

2. Decide I'll be careful, start again, and make a mistake.

3. Decide I'll really be careful, start again, and make a mistake.

4. Do the thinking I should have originally, start again, and complete.

I get enough shop time. This year's NYR is more (and better) completed projects.

Re: Stringing is underway

#12

Re: Trick Question for You, Warren

William Duffield

Would you care to comment on the artistic merits of these 18th Century curves? :D


I took this really bad photo of a silver tray four years ago, in the George Wythe House, intending to reproduce it someday. Now, I'm glad I didn't.

Re: Stringing is underway

#13

But

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

you liked it at the time, didn't you? Must've been something about it.....

Wiley

Re: Stringing is underway

#14

Re: But

William Duffield

Yes, and I still like it.

There is a rather involved back story, which only Warren, myself, and one other guy would appreciate without an involved explanation.

At last month's Williamsburg Woodworking in the 18th Century conference, one of the Historical Trades shops (maybe the Hay Cabinet Shop, but more probably the Joyner's Shop) reproduced this tray. During the presentation, I was sitting next to Warren, while he was explaining to (CRS syndrome kicks in here, and I can't recall his name, nor where I filed all the information from the conference, including the list of attendees and the drawings* of the silver tray) some important aesthetic issues with the subtleties of the curves cut into the edges of the tray. In retrospect, every defect he pointed out made sense to me, but without his analysis, I'm not sure I would have recognized what needed to be changed, and I'm sure I would not have appreciated why it needed to be improved.

I'll let Warren provide the detailed analysis of the problems with the curves, if he is so inclined.

*Colonial Williamsburg is protective of their intellectual property, as well they should be. I could not scan and post the drawing here, even if it was for an example of "don't do it quite like this," instead of "this is the way you should do it," because I am only allowed use of what they distributed to us at the conference for my personal, non-commercial use, and am not allowed to reproduce and publish a copy of the drawing. If I were to build a silver tray similar to this one, I would be well advised to not say it is a reproduction of a specific artifact owned by them. Eventually, I'll find the drawings, but I don't think I will apply them directly to patterns to cut out wood. When I make my patterns, I'll use the drawings, the fuzzy photos I took four years ago, the photos I took last month, Warren's analysis, some insights I've learned from George Walker and others, and my own design sensibilities.

Re: Stringing is underway

#15

Re: Trick Question for You, Warren

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I rather like trick questions, William. I think what I was trying to say earlier was that you don't usually see fine technical work in the 18th century without fine curves as well.

What I criticized at the conference was a drawing someone made of the tray for a handout. (I did not get a look at the original tray). I dug out the handout this evening. Even though your picture of the old one is not real clear, I can see that at least some of the problems are with the drawing, not the original. And that the curves in the original have more life and charm to them. Thankfully, I was on the right track. I have been working on this stuff for many years, but still hardly have the vocabulary to talk about it.

I have not been in the Wythe House for 15 years, but now that you mention it I remember seeing the tray there.

Re: Stringing is underway

#16

Re: But

William Duffield

FWIW, within 2 hours, his name, Ian, has come back to my feeble excuse for a brain. But this revelation only leads to more questions. In my address book for his entry is the apocryphal note, from the 2009 CW conference, "coping saw".

Re: Stringing is underway

#17

Re: Trick Question for You, Warren

William Duffield

Here are a couple more photos I took last month of the silver tray (or whatever it's official name is). They're no better than the first one, so there's no way to use them to determine how far the illustrator strayed from the original patterns. It is obvious that either the original maker got a little lazy with the scroll work on the far end, or over the years, a lot of wear has occurred and a couple of the fragile short grain corners got knocked off. That's not surprising for something that wasin every day use for carrying sharp eating utensils between the dining room and kitchen.



Joiner Ted Boscana is discussing his reproduction of the tray.