Data
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
I just spent two full days making straight, curved, long grain, cross grain, etc. troughs in walnut and several days of practice before that. Additionally, I watched Steve Latta do Federal legs and help me on line and berry. Here are my conclusions for drawers and legs based on this experience and watching what Steve preferred for each task. (I have no opinions on guitars)
1. If I had one I would be stringing a drawer or leg edge with a properly set up Dremel. It is fast, easy to control and the cuts are crisp. Anybody that thinks there is a faster way just hasn't used one, or at least one optimally set up. That said, it can be done just fine with hand tools. For cross grain, the "saw" arrangement promoted by Steve is substantially superior to scratching in both speed and quality of the trough.
2. For line and berry the compass cutter sold by Lie Nielsen is the best tool for the task . These patterns are all arcs of a circle, a task ideally suited for a compass cutter. It takes but seconds to do a small one. Home made compass cutters are just as effective at cutting the trough but one will be making a lot of them to do a set of drawers, 12 in my case. In skilled hands the Dremel could be slightly faster for the larger arcs. However, because one would first have to lay out the pattern with a compass I doubt it would in fact be faster. I will never do enough line and berry that I will ever gain the confidence to use a Dremel for the line and berry arcs. While it cuts a bit faster it also can cut where it shouldn't very fast!
The slow part of line and berry is making the terminations and intersections crisp. Neither compass cutter nor Dremel avoids this tedious hand tool task. Hence, seconds saved on the trough making is irrelevant. The tool choice is made by cost, and reliability, or what is at hand.