New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Wipe-on poly and cost

Posts

Wipe-on poly and cost

#1

Wipe-on poly and cost

Clementine

I like the benefits of wipe-on poly. A little reading pretty much says that wipe-on is a 50/50 mixture of polyurethane and mineral spirits. That doesn't really square with a cost of $24.00 a quart. The wife wants the protection of poly on her new library/dining table, so a quart is required. I'm just curious why the addition of mineral spirits runs up the cost. Have I missed something? Would you recommend I make my own?

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#2

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

David Weaver

You can give it a try. I've had to use it on some trim in the house, but don't generally use it anywhere that shellac or lacquer would be appropriate.

It's sold do the DIY market, and is ripe for being the kind of thing where the price is double what the components are and a large % of the product ends up in a rag.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#3

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

CStanford

I don't know what brand you're buying but it's about $10 higher per quart than the prices I've seen for most wipe on poly products. Check out Amazon.

Poly gets knocked, and rightfully so in many cases, but it has its uses. Sam Maloof like it and it didn't keep his customers from laying out five figures for a rocking chair.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#4

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

CStanford

$24 a quart?

Look:

http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=search-alias%3Daps&field-keywords=wipe+on+polyurethane+varnish

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#5

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

Lars Parrington

make your own. i do it all the time. it's as easy as you say.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#6

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Those prices are all over the map, aren't they? One listing has a quart of Minwax for nearly the same price as the listing just above it for a pint. And if you calculate the quart price of one General Finishes product, it's $36 a quart!

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#7

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

CStanford

Little bit, but it would be a pretty easy decision for me.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#8

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

CStanford

I've got to run to HD in a bit to buy some SYP. I'll take a look there for the hell of it.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#9

Don't forget shipping...

John in NM

I ship stuff all the time, and it is getting to be quite painful. You can get free shipping from Amazon of course, but only if you spend $25 or more :D

Ya can't win, one way or another :D

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#10

Agree...

John in NM

I don't use it, but I would try making it if I had both poly and mineral spirits on hand and wanted some wiping varnish.

I do use Danish oil some, and as far as I understand, it's basically the same thing as wiping varnish. Mine is left over from an antique gallon - I suppose I will soon have to figure out if I buy more or make something similar too :D

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#11

What I use

Ron Harper

A third varnish, a third turpentine, a third boiled linseed oil. Very similar to Maloof's finish. After about 4 coats, i substitute beeswax for the varnish.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#12

craigd

Re: What I use

craigd

+1 - I keep a quart jar of 50/50 BLO/MS that I use for a base coat. If I want a hard surface, then I take cheap hardware store poly ($12/quart), put some in a jar and add the BLO/MS mix (up to 50%), depending on how "wipe-able" I want it.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#13

danish oil != wiping varnish

Lars Parrington

danish oil is an oil/varnish mix whereas wiping varnish contains only varnish. both contain lots of thinner. iirc, danish oil contains less than 10% varnish.

because of the oil in the mix, the danish oil is a much softer finish. it is generally wipe-on, wipe off. i love the way this finish looks and feels. i like watco's danish oil. i also make my own danish-oil-type finish by mixing 50/50 polymerized tung oil and d-limonene, and then adding a few drops of heavy metal driers. it is not an oil/varnish mix, but behaves like one because the polymerzied tung dries hard and fast.

wiping varnish on the other hand, will cure just as hard as regular varnish. it does not need to be wiped off after application. the thinner it is, the more it will flow out and hide your brush/rag strokes, but also the thinner and therefore less durable each coat will be. by making your own, you can thin it only as much as you need to, which lets you get the same amount of build with less coats. i like to start with a thicker blend and finish with a thinner one.

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#14

Try not wiping off the excess...

John in NM

Then Watco behaves a lot like a thinned down varnish as opposed to a drying oil like tung or linseed.

I do this intentionally and buff it with steel wool after a couple coats, specifically to make a film finish - that's why I figure I could substitute thinned poly. Bear in mind, these are small parts I'm finishing, I doubt I would do the same on a table top :D

Re: Wipe-on poly and cost

#15

I chose Watco wipe-on

Clementine

I got the Watco wipe-on quart at Amazon for $15.59; Prime shipping was free. Since the table is for the better half, I didn't want to mix my own brew just in case the thing goes south (I take pride in accepting personal responsibility as long as it rests on someone else). I like some of the mixtures suggested and will keep them in mind. Thanks for all of the replies.