New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

wood planing competition

Posts

wood planing competition

#1

wood planing competition

adrien

http://kottke.org/13/02/competitive-wood-planing

I'm a turner, not a cabinet maker, but thought this Japanese planing competition of interest to this group.

Re: wood planing competition

#2

Re: wood planing competition

TomD

3.6 tens is a pretty solid shaving. The first or second Japanese plane I made back in the early 80s did 4 tens. But it was a narrower blade, and I was just interested in the shavings I was getting, I did not have anyone grading it for length of completeness. It was an american white oak dai.

Re: wood planing competition

#3

Re: wood planing competition

eliot d

I worked really hard making my first kanna,and it works well. But not like this! I wonder just what they do to get these kind of results. You apparently do know. Can you enlighten us?

Re: wood planing competition

#4

Re: wood planing competition

CStanford

...was thinking the same thing.....

Re: wood planing competition

#5

Re: wood planing competition

TomD

Well what results?

- For one thing a plane that takes 4 tens normally makes a shaving that looks like gauze in a very nice and plastic piece of pine. So I have no idea what wood it is that planes sub 4 tens and looks like a opaque ribbon.

- My planning style is more oriented towards speed, to increase cutting power. So in a competition I tend to get few great passes. The people who beat me are planing slower, pressing down, and really maintaining contact.

- I don't know about those guys, but a short plane will follow the surface better, since the idea is full width and even cuts of minimum thickness, a short plane is maybe an advantage, and that goes for finishing.

- My results way back in the day were from an 8000 king stone. Part of the reason why a lot of sharpening tech discussions, while they interest me, do not really shake me. While I do almost all my sharpening free hand. This can be a situation where sharpening with a jig is a good idea. I heard these guys use jigs, and the ones I heard about were pretty expensive. Sadly the LV has not really reached out to this world since there are plane blades up to 80 mm. And 70 is common. The Mark II will get that.

- The dai needs to be really flat, and while various people can do this with a scraper plane I have saved a few people's bacon who went on to star in local contests, by rubbing the wave pattern out on sandpaper...

- Blade fit and mouth are not as important as one might think. The first plane I made that performed at that level can be adjusted by hand and was loose on one side. This kind of test is not about wild grain.

- One does have to do whatever it takes to get the blade projection right, which can take a little fiddling. If the blade does not take a shaving for a while, and then suddenly takes a fat one, and the blade was sharp, then the geometry is bad.

- The wood has to be nice stuff, and it has to be dead flat when you step up for a pass.

- I have been told these guys go well beyond 8000 Kings, and rub all the fine stuff out with jigs for very long times, then check the edges with optics, but I don't know that to be true, and it was not necessary for 4 tens. 4 tens was relatively casual.

-

Re: wood planing competition

#6

Re: wood planing competition

eliot d

The only thing I don't get about your reply is about the perfectly flat sole. Why get rid of the traditional scalloped sole that the Japanese favor?

Re: wood planing competition

#7

Re: wood planing competition

TomD

Good point. That scallop is, as you know an aid to perfect flatness, so I was speaking more generally so long as the front of the mouth is there and the contact points are level, one is good to go. I use the wave pattern, myself, and the rear of the plane pretty much needs relief for this kind of work on a japanese plane. The only exception I have made to that is that in the early days I couldn't work the scraper (the first plane I made that worked to 4 tens was made with the scraper blade). I actually freehanded the pane on a router table, and had about a 8 thou of clearance in there.

Speaking of the blade, this plane was also the one that taught me that one could make a great plane with just 5 degrees of clearance angle.

Re: wood planing competition

#8

Re: wood planing competition

eliot d

I guess I don't know what clearance angle is.