New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

Posts

A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

#1

A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

Patrick Gibbons

I know these can be made of wood, but this appears to be a convenient little gizmo. My saw sharpening skills are still developing. I would always council someone to get off the training wheels for sharpening blades. Should I be ashamed of really wanting this and hoping it improves my saw sharpening?

Re: A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

#2

Sure looks interesting

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Although I seemed to do OK on the only saw I've ever sharpened (short 16 tpi backsaw), I could see the usefulness of the tool...

Then again, when sharpening a saw, one does usually just follows the existing geometry, unless there's much fixing to do. From my point of view, preserving the fleam angle seems the most important benefit of the tool. I'm definitely no expert, so take everything I say with a handful of salt :)

I'll probably buy it down the road, since I now have a couple more saws to sharpen...

DC

Re: A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

#3

Re: Sure looks interesting

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I brought one back from Canada on my recent trip and have so far used it to sharpen a dovetail saw.

There is nothing there that you could not do with a piece of wood wacked onto the end of a file, however the Veritas Saw File Holder does make it much easier.

Rather than several blocks of wood, you have just one file holder. Rather than approximating the fleam or rake angles, you can get them spot on each time, and reproduce these settings every time.

It does not reduce the amount of hand memory needed when sharpening, and it (unfortunately :) ) does not sharpen for you. It does, however, make it a little easier to develop these skills.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?cat=1,43072,43086&p=70465

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

#4

Re: A new Lee Valley offering- Dear Abby...

TomD

Looks nicely made. I don't think I can afford it, but I would like one. Unlike a lot of sharpening tools, it looks like it really doesn't get in the way much. Most sharpening jigs do not fit all blades, require time being fitted to a blade, often restrict the range of motion, restrict the surfaces of the stone, and can add to the wear on the stone. This device attaches to the file in a way that does not seem to have any similar problems. Only advantage to wood might be on weight.