New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

Posts

A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#1

A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

david weaver

This past week, I got one of the big norton multistones. I sort of have a thing for stones if nobody has noticed before.

I've gotten a fair number of norton stones, and while their fine stones are a little less fine than dan's, they still break in to fine with use (to clarify, the dan's stones are lapped, they start out much finer, but when the smoke clears and you've used both for a while, the dans trans is still quite a bit finer, so is the black, to the point that it's an excellent razor finisher).

Anyway, the set I bought included a 11 1/2 inch long Hard Translucent arkansas (by listing). At one point, Norton was selling stones marked in blue letters and they were either marked "soft arkansas" or "hard translucent arkansas". However, the set arrived and the same part number was on the stone as is on the older Hard Translucent stones pictured online, but the print on the side had been changed to black ink, and it only says "HARD ARKANSAS" on it.

A look at norton's catalog shows that their chart of stones doesn't include hard translucent, all of the hards have been lumped together.

The crux of the issue is this stone is coarse for a stone with translucence - very coarse - and it will just barely barely pass the tiniest amount of light from a 200 lumen compact flashlight. I guess by definition, it could be called translucent, but at least on this large stone, something is different. Other trans stones I've had would pass light easily and a large part of the stone would illuminate just from something simple like a lightbulb.

Any of the vendors (Joel or anyone else? .....fyi, joel wasn't the vendor) have any idea what's going on? I sort of expected the same quality as the blue labeled stones marked "Hard Translucent" given the price is hard translucent price, but what I got was something less - creating an alarming very large wire edge you'd expect from a coarser stone.

I don't want to hassle the retailer because if norton is still using the same part # as they did, there's likely nothing the retailer can do about it and I have, of course, already slicked up the stones to give them a whirl.

And, yes, I sent norton a question about them, but they haven't gotten back to me. They don't give you a number to call, and I"d bet they get very little feedback about stones because stones seem to be a very small part of their business, as evidenced by the fact that the website has been screwed up for years where clicking on information about a given stone sends you to a default page - and nobody has fixed it.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#2

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors hel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You have probably seen the chart at Dan's whetstone showing specific gravity of the various stones. The "true hard" stones like translucent and black are above 2.50. Perhaps you could get an accurate weight and calculate.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#3

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors hel

david weaver

I'll have to double check thickness, but if the dimensions are right, it's 2.7 or so - 640 grams dry. If it's a bit thinner than 1/2, then it'll be just less than that. It's definitely in the "true hard" category and on the border of translucent and not translucent. Maybe as it absorbs oil, it will gain translucence.

The density is good, the lack of material translucence coupled with a little bit of porousness (and the huge wire edge it raised) are really what concerns me, along with the change in the label to remove the word translucent.

And the only real concern is that it was implicitly $160 buried in the cost of the tri hone, i was sort of sitting on this being a replacement for other loose finish stones I have sitting around.

As you know, a true hard white arkansas stone is not a valuable stone, a translucent is.

I'd imagine norton will get back to me, but I suspect the "translucent" may have been removed because some of the stock no longer may meet that standard on gentleman's terms.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#4

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors hel

Gary Hodgin

David,

I'm not sure if this explains it but this comes directly from TFWW's website under Norton oilstones.

"Note: After about a century of operations, Norton finally decided to change the name of their top quality stones from "Hard" Arkansas to "Hard-translucent" Arkansas. This was purely a marketing label change with no bearing on the attributes of the stones. These honing stones are made from the same top quality stone as their older style stones. "

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#5

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors hel

david weaver

That definitely helps. I guess it just amounts to I got a dud this time around. I know there is often discussion about how there is no slippage in the quality of stones versus vintage stones, but I have not seen a vintage finsher close to as coarse as this stone. There might not be a shortage of material in general, but I have trouble believing that it isn't harder to get good translucent material in the bigger stones.

Nobody in those days would've marketed the stone I got as a fine hard stone.

And I might be a bit of a cynic, but I don't think norton would've removed the word translucent from their finish stones for no reason and combined the two categories like they're saying. I only have one data point for evidence, but it's telling me otherwise, and the direction it worked out was a way that had me spend translucent money for a marginal stone. That's too bad. I'd love to say I'd recommend people toward Dan's, but dan's retail prices can approach lunar.

Dan's finish stones are excellent, though, but their softer stones do not cut like you would expect a soft arkansas to cut.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#6

Re: Never mind..

david weaver

..I see that commentary was that norton changed from HARD to Hard translucent, and this is actually a change in the other direction unless there's some chance the stone I got is really old stock.

I guess there's a chance of that. Who knows.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#7

Re: Never mind..

Gary Hodgin

The names confused me when I got my stones a few weeks ago. I've used Norton water stones since I got into hand tool woodworking about 10 yrs ago. This winter I decided to add either oil or ceramic (spyderco) to the mix. My hands could no longer take the cold water in my unheated garage shop. I went with oil stones because I wanted something 3 in wide rather than 2 in. I messed my index finger on my left hand up a little over a year ago and find it very difficult to free hand sharpen now so I like the larger stones for my honing jig.

I got a med india and hard translucent from TFWW along with a soft, hard , and hard black from Natural Whetstone. Probably could have gotten along without the soft Arkansas and I really can't tell much difference between my hard black from NW and my hard translucent from TFWW. I've been extremely happy with the setup.

I'd planned to go back to the Norton's when the weather warms but not sure now. The oilstones are real convenient and I just have to turn around from my bench and I'm ready to sharpen. I keep them on my table saw's extension table and they're ready to go with no mess and fuss.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#8

Re: Never mind..

david weaver

You probably have an 8x3 then that's got blue lettering on it and says "Hard translucent"

I had one of those at one point, and was happy with it. I was hoping this would be a longer version of the same thing.

I think maybe I was just unlucky this time.

Picture a stone that looks like this one:

http://shopping.yahoo.com/39012999-norton-115-x-25-x-05-in-hard-translucent-arkansas-replacement-stone/

But with black lettering only and the word "translucent" missing.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#9

Re: Never mind..

Gary Hodgin

That looks like it. Mine is 8x3x0.5. $80 (TFWW) isn't bad in this world of high price stones.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#10

Re: Never mind..

david weaver

$80 is great for a good quality stone.

the 11.5*2.5*0.5 stone that fits in the im 313 is about $160, thus the whole question about the reason for the corseness and the different label.

Anyway, I've paid more than $80 for vintage stones that are about 8 x 1 7/8.

A good oilstone finisher is like magic. A not so good one just isn't that fine.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#11

Re: Never mind..

TomD

My feeling is that if it isn't even in the right country, it should go back to someone... Possibly a lack of experienced users protesting crap is part of the difference today.

My other thought is that even at these prices and at the level of uncertainty, it still sounds cheap compared to machinery, or Japanese stones. Not that you were complaining.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#12

Re: Never mind..

david weaver

Yeah, goodness, I'd pay $160 for a good translucent of that size any day of the week.

My best natural japanese stones are some of the less expensive stones I've seen and used, but all but one were more than $160. none were over $450 though.

There is some of the same with the japanese stones, a constant commentary about how there's no decrease in the quality of the stones, but when I compare my older stones to my newer ones, I don't think any experienced users would believe that.

Even if the newer stones are coming from stock that was mined 75 years ago but never cut, .... there's probably a reason it wasn't cut back then when the quality of the stone counted more than it does now because there weren't amatuers buying stones.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#13

Re: Never mind..

TomD

Yeah, and that can't have been the only stone they sold that was from that piece.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#14

Re: Nothing from norton..

david weaver

3 days and no response from norton. I guess they either don't pay attention to their customer service email from the stone side of the site, or maybe they're not that interested in questions from people who have already bought stones. A couple of years ago, I sent requests to cooper tools (about whether or not they were still supplying some places with higher quality files), too, and never got a response on any of them. That's the price of being a fanatic, I guess.

I'm sure the stone will settle into an OK fineness, I guess, but it'll be a booger to use if a slurry is raised on it because it gets out of flat. It's too coarse, and at more money than Dan's asks for their black stone (which is a very good quality very fine stone compared to all of the other new black stones I've seen), I'd not buy it again.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#15

Re: Nothing from norton..

joel moskowitz

I think I can answer your question.

According to their website all the Arkansas Stones they sell are listed as hard-translucent. (and they are marked that way on the stone)

On their REPLACEMENT stones for the multistone - the one you got is listed as a hard arkansas only. Remember of course that your multi-stone isn't a Norton product- it was assembled from Norton parts by your dealer. (norton discontinued the high end multistone a few years ago)

my own Norton 11 1/2 stone is also marked just hard arksansas not hard translucent. I would bet the stone we have in our multistone in the office is marked the same. The stone in the office started out a little coarse and has mellowed to wonderfully fine. (I haven't used my stone - but it looks amazingly smooth)

it's clearly marked on their website here:

http://www.nortonstones.com/replacmentstones.aspx

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#16

Re: Nothing from norton..

david weaver

Thanks Joel. It's mellowing, I've used it quite a bit. the oil bath does interfere somewhat in how you'd use a translucent, you'd never do it with a big splosh of oil covering the surface, but it is nice that it doesn't get ambient dirt.

Anyway, what's confusing is that the part number doesn't match that one shown there from norton and when you click on the HM11 stone, the norton site goes to some default page. I have never seen a norton stone marked in black, at least not a recent one.

It'll be fine over time as it gets totally broken in, it (a 11 1/2 hard arkansas) can't be much of their share even of the stones division. It's bizarre that they'd have two different part numbers for hard white arkansas stones of the same size (HM11 and BR 115).

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#17

Re: An Update - No Update.

David Weaver

However many days later it is here, no response from Norton. Glad to see they put up an inquiry form and value their customers enough to answer their questions. Not.

Normally when I see someone else say that, I'd say "pick up the phone and call them". I'm sure I could find a phone number, but it's going to lead to nowhere, anyway. It is clear, however, that on their contact page they don't want to field any calls because they intentionally don't give you a phone number, email address, etc. Just a form to fill in online with no other information (as I'm sure people like me would skip the web form and go to the phone or email instead, but if you're them, why deal with people after they've already paid, right?).

Not a big fan! That'll be my last Norton purchase.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#18

What is going on at Norton , "we" are to blame

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

12 years ago I called Norton, using a readily found phone number, asked to speak to tech service and had a wonderful conversation about abrading high hardness tool steels. In fact, if you realized it could be done, you could call any company, ask to speak with tech staff and engage in a technical discussion about any product- tooling, tools, finishes, etc.

During this time the consolidation of retailing was occurring. Instead of a thousand hardware stores for customers Norton, and everyone else, now depended on a handful of large retailers, or distributors, that accounted for the bulk of their business. These retailers competed on price, and it became a fact that retail customers shopped where they could find the lowest price, even if it was a penny less. In turn these retailers wrung, and are wringing, every cent of cost out of the products they buy from manufacturers. To stay in business manufacturers cut costs every place they could find to keep the business of the large retailers as the large retailers played one manufacturer against the others. This process continues. Customer service and tech service became a cost to be eliminated. These functions were shifted to distributors in some cases, or eliminated altogether.

The purchasing agent buying grinding wheels to make widgets for Walmart is going to buy wheels the cheapest place he/she can find because his/her job depends on lowering manufacturing cost to keep Walmart as a customer. As long as the customers make buying decisions based on price non-essential manufacturing functions continue to be eliminated or made more cost "efficient". Don't look for this situation to change as long as Walmart/Target, Lowes, etc parking lots are full of customers looking for the lowest price. The fact that Norton survives is evidence that they so far have been successful in eliminating costs that the majority of their important accounts can do without.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#19

Re: I don't think they'd survive...

David Weaver

.. if their company had to stone products for the consumer market. I'm not saying that because I haven't gotten contact from them, but more along the lines of really, how big is the market? There are very few stone pigs like me, and as far as I know around here, most restaurants' knives are taken care of by sharpening service. There are some fishmongers here and processing places close to the old food terminals in the city where you see very highly skilled folks doing all of the butchering and fish preparation in public, and those guys use japanese knives here and sharpen their own. But the rest? I can't think that most of those folks have any interest in sharpening a knife when the restaurant will send the knives out to be sharpened for $2 each on the swipe of a machine. The chefs have enough to do otherwise.

I would imagine (and I'm only speculating, as they haven't called or responded) that they (norton) feel it's the retailer's job to deal with the customer, which I think is fair.

But I haven't got much to ask the retailer, they specified a model number of stone and the model number didn't change. What norton writes on the stone changed and the stone seems very marginal as a translucent stone (the text now missing on the stone), but there's little the retailer could do about that.

I'd be a lot less inclined to complain if the buried cost (in the price of the im 313 set) of the hard stone was $80 instead of $160. It's just one of those things where you buy something, and afterward you don't feel like you'd get it again if you knew what it was going to be, but I can't in good conscience send it back TBT since it's already been oiled (how else would you find out how good it is?).

I'm sure earlier in this thread, I went through all of the possible reasons the stone could be on the coarse side. At least the medium crystolon and fine india are surprisingly good.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#20

I believe Bill is correct. Sad


Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#21

Re: What is going on at Norton , "we" are to blame

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, this is a sea-change that has occurred across the whole economy. One of the first things companies have changed is the reduction and/or elimination of sales forces. This has greatly impacted my sales career. One of my jobs as a salesman was the education of retail customers and their staffs. That's not a necessary function anymore. Those products that require explanation are the ones that still require a sales force. Also those that require a more involved merchandising function. Outsourcing to Asia and consolidation of manufacturers have all been involved as well. Norton is owned by a European conglomerate, I believe. I was reading about Curtis Mathis TV's the other day on the Internet. In the 1970's their TV cost as much as $1500 a set. Many, many of those same sets are still running. The consumer mindset today does not want to buy once and keep. We also want everything now. That's not bad or good. But all this contributes to the way things are.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#22

Re: What is going on at Norton , "we" are to blame

David Weaver

Not just Curtis Mathes, how about Zenith? With their TV designs, chassis designs and pretty much high quality sales, service, design manufacture, all the way through.

I personally like the sales model if the product price will support it. The trouble these days is that if you're selling something with sales support in it for 10% more, people will enjoy the service if they get it. But they won't choose it up front because they're hung up on 10%.

Once you're no longer peddling good products, though, it's demoralizing to a sales and service force, anyway, and ultimately the honest ones of the bunch will leak comments in conversation about the slipping product.

I'd imagine there is someone at norton I could talk shop with. If the answer is that I got a dud but anything with even the very slightest translucence with a very high power light is fair game, then it is what it is. Not being able to talk to someone who actually knows the score by design of the company's customer service is not cool, though.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#23

need to hang out at trade shows

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

There will be technical people in the booth the first couple of days at a trade show. It is why I go to IWF.....with a list of questions and I come home with a list of contacts for future reference.

Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#24

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: A change in Nortons Hard Arkansas? Vendors help?

#25

Re: Tradeshow booth duty

Patrick Gibbons

When I did trade shows they were only open to the trade and always very busy. I always hated them because they were hard work with long hours. At the same time, I liked them because of new introductions, getting to see other sales people and meeting with new customers. It was just part of the job.