glue drying times vs glue strength
eliot feldman
For a given type of glue, e.g epoxy, is it the case that a version of that glue with a longer drying time, e.g overnight vs several hours, will as a rule provide a stronger bond?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
glue drying times vs glue strength
eliot feldman
For a given type of glue, e.g epoxy, is it the case that a version of that glue with a longer drying time, e.g overnight vs several hours, will as a rule provide a stronger bond?
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
TomD
I think at some considerable level of generality, longer cure times are associated with more complete crosslinking, and better strength. Heat is related to the rate of cure. Epoxies that are heat cured can cure quickly and have very high strength. So there seem to be a lot of things that can be formulated for. But in the range of products available commercially for room temp cure there does seem to be some relationship between cure time and strength. Of course long open times can be a benefit of themselves. Some of these products can be mixed, so the WEST 5 minute can be mixed with the 105 resins and a bled of strength and speed can be adjusted for. Check out 3:30
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mx0Rw_RqXCo
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
eliot d
Thanks. but 3:30 wasn't there -- mostly sailing stuff.
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
Bruce McCrory
My experience and understanding is that Epoxy strength benefits from longer cure time in its formulation. Hence, various cure times--impatience, so-so, and Rip Van Winkle.
Of course, one ideally picks the type of glue for the particular application. My projects have crappy mating surfaces so epoxy is more appealing. But I would slobber all over a released joint on a cello, to reseal the bond. I am not a hide fan, but know that repairs are obligatory with wood instruments.
Epoxy is usually the last resort for adhesive when other types can be used. I think it also requires a looser fit of bonding parts.
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
TomD
3:30 is where they discuss blending materials of different cure time. I guess on has to know what to look for, but I was surprised any blend with 5 minute in it would be up to that repair.
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
TomD
It does not require a looser fit, but fits up to 1/4" are fine. Also, with certain viscosities, one may be hard put to get the joint tight since at a certain point it can be too difficult to get the film out of the joint with normal clamping pressures. As you say, if there were many other options, why would one bother with epoxy, but the glues exist to make invisible joints.
For a given type of glue
Warren in Lancaster, PA
For hot hide glue just the opposite of what you suggest is true: the stronger the glue the faster the set up time.
Re: For a given type of glue
eliot feldmqn
Now that's interesting. I was, kind of, sort of, thinking about no free lunch; i.e. you can have more strength, but you'll have to wait longer. Or, you can finish up sooner, but you'll lose some strength. If what you say is true, and I have reason to doubt it at all, then hot hide glue is a win-win! (Unless you want the longer set-up time.)
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
James Watriss
There are a lot of different factors involved.
With hot hide glue, sizing is important. Adding glue to the surface, and letting it sink into the fibers, followed by 'reactivation' with more glue, and then putting the two pieces together, gives a joint where the glue has deep roots in the piece of wood. I've seen end grain to face grain butt joints that will tear out face grain, when properly sized.
PVA works in a vaguely similar fashion, in that it will seep into the fibers over the course of a few minutes, and then get tacky. At this point, the glue has seeped in, and the bond will be solid. Slathering and then quickly putting things together isn't as effective. If there's a lot of gluing up involved, the 5 minutes isn't such a problem.
AND, once you've used yellow glue, because of its tendency to soak in, if you try to reglue with hide glue, it won't work as well, because it can't soak in as well. PVA is less forgiving of gaps compared to hide glue.
Epoxy's a bit of a dark art to me. I've been told that slower cures mean more cross-linking, but that heat is a big factor: if the work is too cold, or the epoxy is spread too thin, it can prevent the epoxy from fully curing.
I'll have to check out that youtube video on mixing in 5 minute...
Re: glue drying times vs glue strength
TomD
"Epoxy's a bit of a dark art to me. I've been told that slower cures mean more cross-linking, but that heat is a big factor: if the work is too cold, or the epoxy is spread too thin, it can prevent the epoxy from fully curing. "
Not that everything is always happy in epoxy land... It will normally cure eventually it just takes longer, when cold.
Spreading it thin will slow the rate of cure due to heat build up, but that is not ever going to stop it from curing, it is just a technique when using glue at the upper end of it's heat range. I have worked with fast cure epoxy on summer days, when one can just keep ahead of the cure. If I mixed a batch and did not immediately spread it out, it might start jelling almost before it was mixed, but with clever technique, I can just keep ahead of the cure, and really push a job on.
Increase the heat 10 C double the rate at which is cures. Some resins will not cure at room temp.
Most resins commonly out there will cure harder if post cured with heat, but one can do that at any later date. Post cure is not required for normal applications with normal glues, it is just something that is nice to do. Something like a bow limb might need it. But where it becomes critical is with composites where the glue is holding the whole thing together. Say you have a wooden post holding up your roof, and it was laminated with epoxy. That joint is probably not that critically loaded. The wood by itself is nearly sufficient. But say you made the post out of carbon and epoxy. It is basically sitting on the epoxy. The harder the better, so getting max properties out of the glue would be important.