New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

belt grinder

Posts

belt grinder

#1

belt grinder

john sayles

Let me make clear that I don't want to open Pandora's box of sharpening methods. I have settled on a belt grinder for establishing bevels and need some advice. I am a hand tool only guy (the only electrons in my shop power the lights). I've been looking at belt grinders/sanders and have a few questions: How wide/narrow of a belt do I want/need? Figure the widest thing I'm likely to grind a bevel on is a 2 5/8" No 8 jointer iron.

Also, anything I need to know regarding platens, horsepower, etc. ??

btw - I'm pretty much sold on the Dayton line -- anyone have any experiences they'd like to share.

Re: belt grinder

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: belt grinder

#3

Re: Cheap thrills with a 1"x42" belt grinder

david weaver

Big big fan of the kalamzoo grinder. It's cheap (all of them are), but capable. I have a viel grinder in pieces in my closet because I burnt out a motor on it. The belt speed on the kalamazoo is more suitable for grinding, it's got a stronger motor and lower belt speed and doesn't get bogged as easily. The tool rest isn't quite as good as the viel. The whole assembly around the rest and platen is stamped steel, though, so you can relocate holes and so on until the rest is where you want it in reference to the platen and how you want it.

Any one of those with a trizact belt makes a fantastic way to sharpen coarse/cambered plane irons.

Re: belt grinder

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: belt grinder

#5

Re: The Kalamazoo has the best motor

john sayles

Wow - I certainly asked my question in the right forum!

Mr. Barnett: incredibly informative, and well-written; thanks for taking the time to write all of that!

Mr. Weaver: Thank you, too, for your "second" on both the Kalamazoo, Trizact belts and info regarding the tool rest.

I guess there's only one other thing I'm unclear about: when grinding, does one actually press the belt down onto the platen, or is the belt unsupported from behind when the iron (to be sharpened) contacts it?

Re: belt grinder

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: belt grinder

#7

Re: But wait! There's more! [appended safety note]

john sayles

Thanks, David -- great stuff!

Re: belt grinder

#8

Re: belt grinder

TomD

In my shop I use a 1x42 for most stuff I have the LV model, and use the belts they sell. One of my projects this year or next is probably going to be an upgrade to that. Not that it isn't very useful as it is. For precision grinding I mostly use a 1x8 1800 hard wheel. I use a 2x72 grinder for tool making, it can do anything, but it takes up a lot of floor space, and I got the 1x42 first.

Performance is the result of the abrasives qlity, the quality of the contact wheel, platen etc... variable speed, motor power, and general quality of grinder construction. 2x72 has the best variety of available belts, but other than that a 1x42 would do a lot of what a 2x72 can do, except you rarely see the same power or quality in their construction.

My 1x42 runs upwards and my 2x72 runs downward. For the most part when you make tools you are not running against a sharp edge, it is only the last step that the edge is sharpened. When sharpening it is easier to run the belt so you can see the edge, yet not catch it.

Re: belt grinder

#9

Re: MRIs

TomD

If you get a lot of imaging you may want to discuss grinders with your doc. They tend to want to give you a lot of x-rays in places you don't want them if you add a grinder to your shop. Eyeball grit can be sneaky and wearing eye protection is not the total fix. So it might be worth discussing if you need this kind of imaging.

Re: belt grinder

#10

Re: In case I didn't say it, too..

david weaver

..if you purchase when enco has free shipping, the entire thing to your door costs about what a decent baldor motor like that lists for.

Baldor being my favorite, too, despite the multitude of chinese and taiwanese motors that are sometimes goo.

When I got my kalamazoo, it was about $215 delivered to my door, and I remember taking it out of the box and wondering how they could make it, sell it and ship it for that (I don't know if it's drop shipped directly from the manufacturer, but it's not a small box).

Re: belt grinder

#11

Re: In case I didn't say it, too..

TomD

Wait till you pay 1500 and feel the same way. :)

Re: belt grinder

#12

Re: MRIs

john sayles

Tom -- that MRI business is interesting.

A question raised by your post just before this one (where you wrote about belt direction)

when sharpening, do I want the belt running into the edge I'm trying to grind (in other words if the belt is running downward or toward the tool rest, and my blade is angled upward)?

Re: belt grinder

#13

Re: MRIs

TomD

It probably doesn't mater which way the belt runs if you are jigged. Freehand, I prefer to have it running away from the the edge, since it can dig or catch. One can also go across the edge at times. One of the belts I have is cork and one fills it with polishing compound that would rip a knife or chisel out of your hand if it was snagged. One can sharpen with the edge down, it is just a little more difficult to see the edge. Some motors have reverse switches. Not sure if that works with variables. Also the ability to drop the speed to near zero means one can reduce the risk of a catch.

Another thing about belts is if you want to set scrapers for turning the belts cut so efficiently a lot of steel is wasted making a burr, if you get one at all.

Re: belt grinder

#14

Re: MRIs

TomD

On the MRIs, I'm no doctor, I just know what happens to me when I need one. I have only had one or two, so it was not a big deal.

Re: belt grinder

#15

Re: Thanks for the help

john sayles

David, David & Tom

Just wanted to thank you all for your help.

I just ordered the Kalamazoo 1SM from Enco.

BTW - a discount code I found online (google: enco promo code 2013) turned out to be a better deal than their current "Free Shipping on orders over $99" deal.

Re: belt grinder

#16

FYI 1"x42" Rikon on sale

Bob Entwisle in NJ

FYI anyone who's been considering one of these.

I got a Woodcraft flyer in the mail today. Starting Jan 26, they have the Rikon 50-142, 1 x 42 w/8" disk sander on sale for 189.99, about 10 bucks less than the Grizzly.

Looks to be exactly the same as the Grizzly but Grizzly Warranty is 1 year and Rikon is 5 years.

For me woodcraft is 40 mi driving distance, and Grizzly would be + shipping costs, (or a really long drive, which would cost more than the machine).

Bob in NJ