We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Blade drift with a jigsaw and getting the cut back to 90 degrees led me to question the use of a jigsaw. What is the hand saw alternative - a jab saw, a hole saw? And is it really an improvement? I was cutting gentle curves in 27" x 27" panels for the ends in a Stickley table, so a scroll saw (which I don't have) wouldn't work. Thanks.
Either one of which is good for sawing curves. For a gradual curve in thicker stock you're better off with a turning saw which is a small bowsaw with a narrow blade(the picture).Fret saws and coping saws are better for sharper curves in thin stock.---Jack
I find myself using a coping saw a lot for these kinds of cuts. I have a bow saw kit from Tools for Working Wood that I'm embarrassed to say I've yet to put together. That and a hole saw that needs sharpening. However, these two would be good alternatives. Obviously I can't give you personal experience on their effectiveness. Files, rasps and sandpaper are going to be necessary no matter what you start with.
For that application, assuming these are convex curves, even a small handsaw could do it, roughing it out. It would wind up as a series of more or less straight cuts tangent to the curve. If it's a very mild curve, a bench plane using the same approach of progressively shorter tangents to the curve might do it, but that's a lot of planing strokes for most curves. You would then finish with a block plane (even the powered tools usually require some smoothing after), and sandpaper.
For a long concave curve on end grain, a bowsaw or, lacking that, a keyhole saw to rough it out, followed by a spokeshave or sandpaper on a block to smooth it.
For a long concave curve on long grain, a bowsaw is the usual "proper" approach. I don't have one, so one approach I've taken is to lay out the curve, then do crosscuts periodically from the edge almost to the curve, Then, paying attention to grain direction so I don't go beyond the line, I split out the chunks, finishing up with a spokeshave. Like this:
For convex and concave curves, there are also compass planes (see picture below; image from Patrick Leach's "Blood and Gore" dissertation on Stanley planes, http://www.supertool.com/StanleyBG/stan3.htm#num20), but these are not cheap and, unless you're doing a lot of curves, may be hard to justify.
For inside cuts, depending on size, you might use a keyhole saw, compass saw (larger), coping saw, or fretsaw, complemented with holes drilled at spots where the curve is a portion of a circle of a diameter for which you have bits.
I'd check my technique with the jigsaw first. That should be a very easy cut to accomplish with even a less than the best jigsaw.
Put in a fresh blade, not too fine. Make sure the shoe is square to the blade. If it's an orbital jigsaw set it on the max orbital motion. Let the saw practically pull its way through the cut. Don't rush the cut. Live a tiny bit of "white space" between the cut line and pencil line for cleanup just to the layout lines.
Much will depend, here, on the quality of the electric jigsaw. In my experience, a consumer-grade saw has a hard time maintaining 90 degrees on anything much over 1/4" thick. Yes, the pro-grade ($150 and up) saws will do a good job if the cut's not pushed; but there are lots of consumer-grade saws out there.
I believe Frank Kelly was one of my grandmother's (on my father's side) brothers, although I'm not sure. The plaque was in the ancestral house in Seattle when several of us went up (from Oakland, that little city across the bay from San Francisco) to clear it out in 1964, when the last of the sisters still living in Seattle and in the house - my Granny's older sister Bella - became infirm and had to move into a care home.
There were lots of sisters and brothers, and the sisters were much more lively than the brothers, so I really don't know much of anything about my great-uncles on that side. But I'm presuming from the style that Frank Kelly was a great-uncle.
I just got around, this weekend, to taking its picture, and I put it up on my profile only just yesterday. I have another little item, from my grandfather on my mother's side, that I may rotate in at some point.
Oh Lord Bill that may very well be the case now. I wish I knew how many feet of material I cut with a very run of the mill Craftsman that always produced a square edge. Maybe it was a better saw that I (we) gave them credit for being. It finally crapped out but not until after a really fine run of work.