We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have some Fullers like that I bought in the 70's. They don't hold an edge at all. Also I don't think they're tempered as far up the steel as you've cut them back. How well are they holding an edge for you? I always thought the Fullers were very comfortable in the hand.
I have been following ( as best I can) the discussions on the virtues and vices of various chisels. most of the talk has been very technical and way above my pay scale.
So I have gone to the root in an attempt to make sense of the discussion;
The root, to me is what i am trying to achieve.
An analogy:
You may have $20,000 car or a $200,000
Both will get you to town.
The town will look the same no matter which car you drove to get there.
One car will get you there a bit faster and be a lot more enjoyable to drive.
If I had the money of course, i would have a$200,000 car, just because.
But ultimately if I just want to get to town either will do.
The chisels in the photo are cheap crap of course, but even they can cut nice dovetails.
I bought them as disposables at the time, but still have many years later.
I am not afraid to grind them to suit a task, and I have lots experience sharpening them and experimenting with them.
They have served me well and done many nice jobs.
I do have a few nicer chisels, they don't make any noticeable difference to the work that I do, but they are nice to own.
I don't have any problem with fine tools, but lets keep some perspective;
Given an equal skill-set:
You can do fine work with humble tools.
Fine tools are nice to own, enjoyable to work with and a little more efficient to use.
But with all of the discussions on the difference between chisel steels and manufacturing processes, the actual, practical, difference that they make to the final result is imperceivable.
They are old ( probably from the 70's) and i thought that i would have thrown them out years ago , but cant seem to part with them. They of course require a lot of sharpening, but they still come in handy every once in a while.
But this is a forum with a wide range of interests, and reasons for owning tools. The spectrum varies from totally interested in the finished woodworking project. The tools are the way I get there. To Totally interested in the tools. The alleged woodworking project is the way I justify owning them. Both of those are extremely valid positions. They will have different perspectives that come with them.
I feel that way about a couple of Ginsu knife sets I bought as disposables at the start of what looked like a long move that indeed turned into 6 months. This was 14 years ago, and we're still using them.
And that is exactly my point; my reason was to add some practical perspective.
Woodworking is a blend of both art and craft, woodworkers, part logical, practical and part fanatical extremists.
Having been afflicted in early childhood, I understand and can tell the difference, but for many that read the forums trying to understand, a little perspective from time to time may help.
I have some nice stuff, just because it is nice to work with nice stuff: doesn't necessarily make my work any better: I still end up in the same town, but the drive is a lot more enjoyable.
You can buy a small try square of brass and rosewood for over a hundred dollars.
The line that you scribe across a board will not be any more square to the edge than if you had used a square available on ebay for 10 bucks.
If one has the resources, and he is not spending the baby food money, there is absolutely nothing wrong with buying a hundred dollar square as long as you understand that it is not about doing good work
"The town will look the same no matter which car you drove to get there.
One car will get you there a bit faster and be a lot more enjoyable to drive.
If I had the money of course, i would have a$200,000 car, just because.
But ultimately if I just want to get to town either will do."
"The chisels in the photo are cheap crap of course, but even they can cut nice dovetails. I bought them as disposables at the time, but still have many years later. I am not afraid to grind them to suit a task, and I have lots experience sharpening them and experimenting with them."
These chisels cost about the same as your Fullers. Patience in finding cheap and unhandled Stanley 750, time to regrind all the shoulders to zero lands, one reground from 1/4" to 1/8" and another from 1/2" to 3/8". Handles turned from West Australian She-Oak.
"The alleged woodworking project is the way I justify owning them."
I never feel that owning tools has to be justified. Woodworking is a hobby, and there are many facets to this hobby. Generally I build two large projects a year and perhaps a dozen or so small projects. I enjoy the tools as much as I enjoy the build process and as much as I enjoy what I have built. Often the tools inspire me along the way.
"You can buy a small try square of brass and rosewood for over a hundred dollars. The line that you scribe across a board will not be any more square to the edge than if you had used a square available on ebay for 10 bucks."
I've made them in brass and I've made them dovetailed and infilled ..
These cost nothing but my time. A sliding bevel could do as well, or I could cut dovetails without a marker. Why did I bother?
I could go on and on. It is apparent to all of us that there are many pleasures to be had in woodworking, and that we can be divided into camps in this way. Let's not do that here, please.
Regards from Ottawa (heading for the (Grand Canyon)
Take that hundred dollar bill you would have spent on a fancy square and place it in a jar. While you`re adding bills to that jar and waiting for them to add up cruise another area of the internet, the one where you can find and sign up for skill building classes. Look for a class that will allow you to make the tools you`d like to own. Once you have the skills you can take as much or as little time on that phase of things and make you tools as ugly or as pretty as you see fit. If your tools are still the thing that is holding you back after you have your toolmaking skills in place then you have nobody to blame but yourself.
Plan B- Join both a WWing AND a blacksmithing/metalworking club or guild near you. Plan B may take a little longer to attain the same results but I`m willing to bet it`ll be more fun, last longer and require a far smaller cash investment.
But it is very useful to understand that there are a lot of different interests on this board.. I really do not care if you want to build trophy cases for your tools and walk by them an stare every few hours. That is a wonderful hobby. But is s different from the guy who is primarily a woodworker whose shop is for making projects.. Yes you can get the ultimate chisel. But the ends of the pins will not any more flush than when trimmed with those interesting artifacts of Mark's.
That's a really fun outfit. While I'm not a member, I've attended some of their meetings. They just like to make stuff out of metal. Ask a question and sit back for as much information as you can handle.
From their website, ABANA is "The Artist Blacksmith's Association of North America is the preeminent blacksmith organization in the world."
you cant fool us, there ain't no Grand Canyon in Ottawa. "
There is a fairly impressive drop behind the house of parliament, and most days there are people on the front lawn who are more or less willing to push.
Pat, did Jim Cummings use Fuller butt chisels in his video where he is seen re-heat treating them to a higher performance level. They make these things soft on purpose, normally so they can be sharpened with a file at the jobsite. But the steel is capable of more.