New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Posts

Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#1

Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Scott in Douglassville

Hi, all -

I'm looking for a new 1/8" chisel for chopping waste on small dovetails. I have several Ashley Iles bench chisels (the longer ones), and want to keep with them. They're offered as the longer, "London" pattern chisels, and shorter "American" pattern chisels. For dovetailing, is there an advantage to one over the other? The American pattern are more like bevel edged butt chisels. I've been using the longer style (1/4") with decent results; I'm not sure what, if any, advantage there would be with the shorter ones.

Thanks for any help.

Scott

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#2

a vote for short

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I, and I know of several others, prefer a short chisel for this kind of activity. To name names Will Neptune uses a short chisel as does Steve Hamilton in the Headley shop. I suppose we could add Klause if my video is any indication. Better balance and control and less hand cramps. The short Japanese chisels are ideal in this regard, but poor multitaskers in my hands.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#3

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

TomD

When I used to do dovetailing seminars one part of it was based on the Klausz video. Part of that was to show how to practice dovetails in easy wood, in a low stress way. And I would use cheaper, available tools. My choice of chisels for that was LV Butt chisels that I use in my framer's belt at other times. And other than the fact that when I bought them they were seemingly intentionally heat treated at the soft end of the range, they were pretty ideal for the task of making dovetails. So yeah, I would go towards the short end. Particularly with narrow chisels they are bendy, and shorter can be better.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#4

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Scott in Douglassville

Good points, gents. Shorter, American pattern, it is. Thanks for the input.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#5

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm looking for a new 1/8" chisel for chopping waste on small dovetails. I have several Ashley Iles bench chisels (the longer ones), and want to keep with them. They're offered as the longer, "London" pattern chisels, and shorter "American" pattern chisels. For dovetailing, is there an advantage to one over the other? The American pattern are more like bevel edged butt chisels. I've been using the longer style (1/4") with decent results; I'm not sure what, if any, advantage there would be with the shorter ones.


Hi Scott

What do you consider to be long and what to be short?

For a 1/8" chisel with a triangular section (or close) and zero lands, I would be looking at something in the range of 3" -4" long in the steel. You have to keep in mind that the longer the blade the greater the degree of flex. Flex is not a good thing in a chisel that may be used to chop as well as pare end grain.

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#6

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Mark Hennebury

Hi Scott,

Its all a matter of perspective; Tools are a means to an end, match the tool to the work. Small work, small tools, lots of control.









Big work.... your going to need bigger chisels.

Don't be afraid of your tools... they work for you, and if they don't, modify them until they do.

You don't have to have super expensive ones like mine of course :)

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#7

wow that couch is cool!


Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

OT :more on that couch

Jack Guzman from Maine

Mark, could you talk abit about that couch? Is it as heavy as it looks?---Jack

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#9

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Will Neptune uses the same kind of chisel for wasting out dovetails. For those that don't know, Will taught at North Bennett and now has own shop and does Period reproductions and teaches some. Don't miss a class with will should you get a chance. He is a master of making difficult joinery easier by clever approaches.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#10

Scott, I have the Ashley Illes chisel

Patrick Gibbons

My bench chisels are mostly AI in the longer size. I bought the 1/8" chisel in the shorter size because it would primarily be used for dovetailing. Of course that did not turn out to be the case. I use the 1/8" chisel a lot for many things. The shorter size has proven to be a good choice. As Derek pointed out, stiffer is better and the shorter size is a stiff little chisel.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#11

Re: OT :more on that couch

Mark Hennebury

Hi jack,

Yeah, its pretty heavy, solid Oak 3" sides and front and a 10" wide shelf at the back for a top rail. I did that about 30 years ago. It has 2" rubber webbing for cushioning on the seat and back.

I liked it because it was a very simple design, comfortable and practical, I liked the shelf on the back most. The webbing has metal clips on the ends and just presses in a saw Kerf, the cushions ( i made those too) can come off for washing. So its quite practical and easy to replace anything when it wears out.

There is a lower brace from right to left which the webbing clips in and a brace from front to back.

I will look to see if I can find any more photos.

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: OT :more on that couch

Jack Guzman from Maine

It's impressive. I love those huge dovetails.---Jack

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#13

Re: Some News About Will Neptune at this   *LINK*


2013 SAPFM Cartouche Award Winner

Re: Chisel style for chopping dovetail waste?

#14

Re: Some News About Will Neptune at this

CStanford

He's the man.