New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Experiments in wood drying.

Posts

Experiments in wood drying.

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Experiments in wood drying.

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have a new toy. I need to play with it.

I built a more efficient kiln for drying chair parts. I lined the underside of a wall mounted bench with insulation board including sides and doors and put in cleats for a removable rack. In the bottom under some screen are three standard ceramic light fixtures. I use 150 and 200watt bulbs(whichever is on the shelf at the local hardware).It also has a thermal switch that cuts off power at 125 degrees.I left an opening at the bottom of one side of the cabinet and have a computer fan in an opening at the top on the opposite side pulling air out using a 12v battery. This works great . I used it to accelerate the drying of a couple bent parts in their forms.

Friday morning,I bought a fresh cut maple log for leg stock. My grandson and I busted it up into leg blanks roughly 2" square by 24" and stored them in a shaded place outdoors. I decided to experiment a bit.

I put four pieces into my kiln ,planning to dry them a bit before turning. They are way too juicy as is. 12 hours in the kiln I took them out and had a shock. They had all checked. Cracks in all ends and some running the whole length of the blank. The wood opened up pretty wide in places.I learned that I can't do that . Gotta wait for gradual air drying, so I put the ruined blanks on a shelf for the time being. Went down and looked this morning and alot of the checking is gone.

This makes sense. The moisture trapped in the center has spread throughout the pieces stabilizing them. Now I'm wondering if the fractures are still separate but just unseen. Will these pieces be useable after all or will they come apart where they cracked.

I will turn one of these when it has had awhile to dry and I will report the answer to the above question.---Jack

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#2

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

Sgian Dubh

As you surmise, the checks are still there, but unseen-- for now. This is quite common in oak, well known for its refractory nature in drying. Surface checking caused by too aggressive drying forms and is visible. Later, as the rest of the wood nearer the core dries the surface checking closes up and isn't readily seen. The problem is when the wood goes into a piece of furniture, those checks may still be pretty much invisible, so the worker goes ahead all the way through to prepping and polishing. The surface checking almost always reveals itself when the finished furniture item goes into service. It may be just a few days, or it may be months, but at some point those checks will stand out, and rather spoil what may otherwise be a fine piece of furniture.

I wouldn't use your maple, which is known to have deep penetrating surface checks and the like for any kind of "money" part in your furniture. If you must use it, use it where it's not visible, eg, under upholstery or for internal hidden parts of a cabinet or something similar. Also, there may be strength considerations to take into account, as there is surely some loss of strength due to grain separation. Slainte.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

Jack Guzman from Maine

It will be a chair leg and it will be painted but I won't use it. I have plenty of undamaged wood to use. thanks ---Jack

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#4

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

TomD

In my experience, for a month or so, the deal is to expend effort into not letting it dry. Then it gets past some critical stage, and you can accelerate things. Also turning your chair leg wet, would have been easier, in some ways, and would make it dry faster. With normal beads coves and tapers, there is a lot more end grain exposed which will reduce the chance of checking. Of course, one either has to want the look one gets from drying turned parts, or one needs to do a secondary turning. Not to say all designs will accept this approach.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#5

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for posting this, Jack. I've been interested in making a similar set-up. I noted that in one of Curt Buchanan's videos he had a very similar outfit. It would be interesting to know how much heat he had going into his. I once made an oven for curing laminated longbow blanks. It had 6 -100 watt bulbs, but no thermal cut-out, but it was covered by 2" foam insulation. Those bulbs kept the "oven" at 200 degrees (in the unheated garage in the winter, which can be pretty cold in North Dakota), just right for the epoxy.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#6

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

TomD

Me too. But as you know that wood starts out dry as a bone, the heat is there to super cure the epoxy and take it through the glass transition phase, or something. Just for anyone here who may not have made a bow oven...

It is hard for me to come up with a set situation. I can end up with wood that is fairly dry, say a fallen tree that the leaves have pulled the water out of, or something that is wringing wet. With the last big batch of beech, it was really fragile for a while. I had some jointer blanks under a table, on a cement floor, out of direct sunlight. It is not sunny in my lower shop, and the windows have special glass to keep the heat down. But one day I moved the blanks out to get at something else, and they sat in the shady sunlight for a day, and a few of them cracked. They were end sealed, and everything. Not easy to predict.

I think this is why steam is so effective. It forces the water out, but does it in a way where there is not a huge differential, and the blanks don't tend to split. A big dry heat differential is death, or even a small one. A contributing factor in my case was the sun only hit one side of the blanks. I suspect if the blanks where on a rotating table it would have been a different mater. Though whether it would have been OK, or just split on four sides, hard to tell.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#7

beech is the second most miserable wood to dry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Black gum is first. Before I knew about its problems -interlocked grain and huge shrinkage- I bought 300 bdft and piled several hundred bdft of walnut on it. It lifted the walnut pile as it dried, demonstrating crook, bow, cup, twist, and other configurations NHLA hasn't found names for. Beech is nearly as bad which likely is why you don't see it in furniture unless it has been steamed as is done in Europe.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#8

Re: beech is the second most miserable wood to dry

TomD

I feel better Bill. Though one thing I found was that it dried out faster than any wood I had hitherto dried. On the C&W site they mention that it's particular structure makes it ideal for planes as it deals so well with environmental moisture issues that a plane experiences. Not the same thing as getting it dry in the first place.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#9

Tom, I have a question

Patrick Gibbons

I've always wondered why beech is steamed. Can you explain the process and its rationale?

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#10

Re: Tom, I have a question

TomD

I am not an expert on that question, but three reasons jump to mind. One is that steaming is common in many processes of kiln drying; Two is that the process, as with american walnut, produces a colour change that is considered desirable. The change is from white to pinky or browny shades; Three it is a wood that responds to steaming well for bent work, and numerous classic designs have taken advantage of this feature to allow industrial use of beech, a relative weed species. I am guessing that these are different stages of steaming. They could be done all at once or they could be separate processes. Wood that has been kiln dried may not respond well to steaming, while wood that is wet from the tree does respond well to steaming. So it would make sense that wood for bent furniture would be steamed wet.

Apparently beech is the most common hardwood in europe and western asian, and is available in large specimens.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

steamed?

Jack Guzman from Maine

In this context I don't know what you are talking about. Please explain?--Jack

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#12

craigd

Re: Tom, I have a question

craigd

Another reason I've read for steam drying is that the high humidity keeps the board ends from drying out faster than the interior and thus reduces checking.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#13

Re: Tom, I have a question

Sgian Dubh

"I've always wondered why beech is steamed. Can you explain the process and its rationale?"

Steaming beech makes the wood easier to work than unsteamed beech which is naturally a generally off-white brown, or at least this is the normal colour of European beech whereas the beech native to North America has somewhat different characteristics. I find the colour change has a tendency to make the wood more even in colour, so I think this colour consistency along with easier working properties are the main drivers for steaming the wood here in Europe-- I'm not sure about North America.

Steaming beech causes the wood to take on a pink hue in a similar chemical process to the way steaming walnut causes the sapwood to darken. Steaming (of walnut, beech, and other species such as pear) usually takes place in a dedicated steamer and it's a process undertaken after the wood has been dried in a kiln. Basically, the wood is close stacked, aka dead stacked, in the steamer, the doors closed, and hot wet steam is injected into the chamber. The wood needs to be raised to the temperature of boiling water (100ºC+) and held at that temperature for a couple of days for the colour change to occur.

Many people think erroneously that the colour change in walnut is caused by colour from the heartwood leaching into the sapwood. This doesn't happen and the sapwood colour change is caused a chemical reaction within the sapwood itself; the heartwood itself also changes colour, becoming darker. European beech doesn't have pink heartwood, and nor does pear, the other species I mentioned that is often steamed. The beech, for example is naturally an off-white, muddyish brown when dried ready for use, but steaming causes both the heartwood, and the sapwood to a greater or lesser extent to change to pink-- again this indicates a chemical reaction being the cause of the colour change.

Unrelated to your question is a process of high heat treatment of wood at temperatures between 150 and 250ºC (302- 482ºF), but this process is to impart characteristics such as durability in non-durable softwoods that are to be used in exterior locations. It is also used to improve stability and to cause colour changes in, for example, birch which becomes a dark chocolate colour, although this colour is somewhat fugitive. Slainte.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#14

correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

walnut sap changes color almost immediately when it reaches 100 C. I already lost this argument to the late Jon Arno. Being the skeptic that I am I tested his statement in a pressure cooker ( a handy way to steam small objects) and of course he was right. What takes two days is to heat the center of a 1000 bdft pack of walnut up to 100C.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#15

the answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

According to the representative of the German company importing steamed beech to the US that I quizzed at at a recent IWF show in Atlanta the beech is steamed prior to drying to make it behave better in drying, less warping.

I was told by the owner of a furniture factory that ran their own steamer that steamed walnut worked better in the factory. Apparently steaming alters the composition/structure of the wood. It may leach out some lignin. One can smell furfural around the steamer which implies some amount of cellulose degradation.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#16

another correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I lived a few miles from a walnut steaming operation and consulted on it from time to time (got to pick 500 bdft from a several thousand bdft inventory once as payment)


Walnut steaming is always done right off the saw (green lumber). After the lumber is sawed it is bundled into about 500 to 1000 bdft packs (dead packed), banded and sent to the steamer location for steaming. The color change is much less after the walnut has been even air dried. Water, lots of water, is essential to this color change.

The volatiles from steaming are wickedly corrosive. The steel bands are gone after 2 days. So is the building or autoclave if it is not done right. Pictured is the second facility built after the first dissolved. The doors are aluminum, the building block.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#17

Re: another correction

Sgian Dubh

"Walnut steaming is always done right off the saw (green lumber).

You're quite right Bill, and I realise now I had a brain fart in my earlier message where I inadvertantly said that steaming for colour takes place after kiln drying. I meant to say before drying, but for some unknown reason the word 'after' slipped in there by mistake. Slainte.

Re: Experiments in wood drying.

#18

Re: another correction

TomD

I always think of steaming as being an earlier part of the drying process, as the bulk of water actually leaves at that time (?).