New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Posts

OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#1

OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A week or so ago, I put down mouse/rat poison in our crawl space (and attic), after hearing definite rodent noises in the crawl space.

I spent part of this afternoon on hands and knees questing for corpses around the 1500-square-foot crawl space, in response to a plaint from LOML (whose nose is more sensitive than mine, most of the time) that the bedroom stank of dead mouse. I found one rat, definitely past its most attractive years, and cleared out a mouse nest*.

I know I've got some holes in the foundation perimeter that I need to plug next summer, when the crawl space is dry. That should help. But what other rodent control methods have people found useful? I'd prefer not to have to crawl under the house every few days to check a trap (although I could do that: the crawl space is four feet high at the front, where the access is, and I could put traps down where I'd have to crawl in just a few feet); and the one time we tried mothballs as a deterrent, the bedroom smelled like Aunt Harriet's back closet for a week. Are there other methods less likely to lead to l'aroma de rodent or other unpleasant scents?

*And, yes, I was wearing a respirator and nitrile gloves for the cleanup, corpse and nest.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Jack Guzman from Maine

Bill, Google "water bucket mouse trap". It really works. ---Jack

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#3

Thanks.  Looks like a good idea


Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#4

For plugging holes and an effective repellent

Bob Hackett

Use either copper or stainless steel scrub pads stuffed into the holes. Anything else will either be chewed through or rust away.

Fabric softener soaked rags will smell much better than moth balls and keep the rodents away just as effectively.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#5

those dryer sheets really work

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have a backyard shed with a roll-up overhead door. The voles figured out they could squeeze through the gaps between the door rollers and the door track. A couple years ago I filled those with dryer sheets and they worked spectacularly well. That is, until the little buggers chewed a hole in the vinyl gasket on the bottom of the door. Stopped that with a bent-up piece of flashing, filled everything with dryer sheets and the voles are stymied once again. We'll see what they figure out next. But they really don't like those dryer sheets.

BTW, I also filled the tail pipes on my motorcycle with steel wool because the rumor is that mice like to live in there, too.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#6

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Bruce McCrory

There is a wood working solution, that gets this OT onto On Topic. But first, from the experts, and me, after several hundred dollars to the experts:

We have both Norwegian and native roof(?) rats in western Washington. The roof rats are smaller, but much uglier varmints. Those nasty tails are longer than the body. Rats move in during cold weather. They used the hose bib opening that was without a scutcheon plate to get to our basement plumbing wall, then up into the ceiling-first floor cavity. I couldn't put my thumb through the gap. Roof rats can run along the eaves or wall trim and bob under exposed truss tails. Vegetation needs to be clear of the house by about 4 to 5 feet.

The best way to stop rats is stop all openings as small as a quarter. Use metal scutcheons, sheet metal, or heavy wire webbing, like for rabbit cages or sifting dirt. They will try to chew through wood at a familiar access; and aren't bothered by copper wool. A nursing mother will tackle even wire. Rats are smarter than children, definitely smarter than teenagers, and will learn to avoid hazards. How ... Smell? Who knows?

If they are in the house, don't plug the outside accesses until you have removed them, by luring them out. As noted, poison is not a good solution in the home. You probably won't be able to get to rotting carcasses. [Bill, you were really lucky!] Poison should only be used where pets can't get to it. Poison is one of those things they learn to avoid, too. They can also get at an open spring trap after raccoon, cats, and dogs mess with them.

But they love peanut butter. And, here is how you get them every time:

You know the Victor Brand Spring traps? Use them. Victor has a plastic base version, also. Nothing else works. Period!!

Now you build the "safe and cosy" trap mansion.

It is a three chambered box (four walls). I made the chambers the same size, lined up side by side. The trap resides in the middle chamber. This "room" is wide enough for the trap to slip into, long enough for its length and, maybe, two to three free inches for the visitor at the doorway. Make him/her squeeze and keep things very snug.

The box is fully enclosed, bottom, top, sides; and the two interior chamber walls are full height. Height is based on the length of wire swing. All holes were about 1" to 1-1/4" size; I knocked them out on the bandsaw. I didn't want to deal with squirrels, so kept size smaller than my brain thought was needed. Trust the spec's.

Keep in mind that the trap will jump, so nail it down. Rats are fast! And, a trap hung up for even a micro-second will miss the guy. All of my guests had snouts only a tiny fraction of an inch too long.

The top lifts off for access. Also, mockups help because it's awkward setting the traps. I set rat killers in place. You can't drop them in or slide them like mouse traps. Some bricks on the lid will keep most casual interest from pulling off the lid for the peanut butter.

The two abutting chambers are for the rat to hide in while it investigates the sumptuous presentation through the inner door. I lined up the doors, but placing the exterior access openings at the opposite sides of the inner openings will get the victims bending in a "U" to reach the peanut butter. Anything to slow them down.

Place the trap mansion near the access hole, or in a secluded hidey spot next to the foundation. They won't feel so exposed this way. Two traps per house are recommended by the pro's.

Go get em'!!!

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#7

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Dale Stansbery

If no pets can possibly get access to the crawl space, you can try a shallow dish of antifreeze. I saw that approach in an Amish corn crib one time. Seems like it would be effective.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#8

You just can't beat a snap trap...

John in NM

We use them all the time up here at work. Weather gets cold and the mice move right in to the building.

I much prefer the traps with the metal trigger over the plastic. Plastic is either too slippery or not slippery enough to set off the trap reliably compared to the metal on metal triggers.

We bait with peanut butter and a paper twist tie that come with garbage bags. The paper soaks up the peanut oil and keeps smelling like the bait they love so much. Don't use too much peanut butter, then if you get one that is gentle enough to lick off the PB without springing the trap, it will still have an appetite and start gnawing on that twist tie. That will get them every time.

Snap traps are quick, often killing instantly, and you know where they are so you don't have to search for the little stinking corpses. Personally, I don't think much of some of those other suggestions - although I eat meat and kill animals when necessary, I see no point in lingering deaths like drowning or anti-freeze poisoning for any living thing. Others are entitled to their own opinions of course, they need not do as I do.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#9

Re: You just can't beat a snap trap...

Kevin French

My money is on my Mouser.

I came down stairs yesterday to her playing with a mouse. I'm thinking that the mouse didn't consider it 'Play', but the whole time I was dressing she was playing "Catch & Release". I almost felt sorry for the little guy but, then I also use the snap traps on them.

Good luck Bill and remember the ONLY way to keep unwanted animals out of something is-

You have to be more persistent then they are, lacking that people use an easier nuclear option.

Home Depot has a 'No Pests Foam' made by the same people that make the expanding foam to fill the small gaps. I have not tried it.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#10

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Old Baleine

Bruce McCrory is clearly an experienced, successful rat wrangler. I have had great success with a very similar approach. A tight, enclosed space that directs them into the trap in the correct orientation is the first step to success.

The only thing I would add is this: take a wine cork (a natural cork one), and slice off a disk about 1/4" thick. Jab the cork disk onto the prong of the bait holder, then apply a dab of peanut butter. If you buy one of the "natural" PB brands that are packed without an emulsifier, you can just dribble a little of the oil onto the cork. It's the smell of the oil that the buggers go for. The cork is hard for them to get off without triggering the trap, and it is soft enough that they will readily chew into it.

I agree with some of the other posters vis-a-vis the spring trap: it is nearly instantaneous, and far more humane than the gruesome glue traps or poisons. Done correctly, there is nothing as devastating, except my black cat. A feral or semi-feral cat will rid a homestead of rats and mice in pretty short order, but she will also have a toll on songbirds and reptiles. My cat ate a whole rabbit last week, leaving behind one hind foot, the little cottontail puff, and the carefully excised intestines, still full of chewed vegetation and little bunny pellets. All of the fur, and even the skull and bones...down the hatch!

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#11

The final swirly.......

Edward in Vancouver

Having worked in kitchens for over 30 years now, I "have my ways" dealing with furry critters.

I don't like poison for the following reasons:

-Most cases it's illegal in kitchens, and "ye olde health inspector" doesn't like to see it.

-Any over-the-counter stuff is useless and turns you into a pet owner--you're just feeding them. To use the "good stuff" you need a permit and that is a p.i.t.a.

-But the biggest reason I don't like it is because once poisoned, the critters go and find the smallest, most in-accessible spot to die, and then stink. Most of the time you never recover the bodies.

I'm a big fan of "catch and release" traps for the following reasons:

-Once in there, they can't get out. Many a critter have outsmarted a snap trap or have chewed off a leg or tail to get out.

-They're still alive and don't stink when you get to them. For some employers that I've worked for, "checking the trap lines" was part of my cooking duties, I dunno maybe they were above this job. If I knew I couldn't check the traps every day, I'd stuff the trap with enough food to last a few days so the critters wouldn't die and stink, or eat their buddies, or themselves. I would dispose of the live ones by first flushing the toilet, then immediately opening the trap and shaking them into the swirling waters--the final swirly.

Some bosses didn't like this method, but I never gave them another option--other than for me to take the boss's car and boss's time to chauffer the critters to a park 20 minutes away. No one ever took me up on this option....

It is important that you plug all entrances immediately. The "trail blazers"--the first ones who got into your crawl space have left behind a scent trail that others will follow. Not only are their snouts sensitive to odours, but to temperature differences too, if it's warmer they will go there, little heat-seeking devices with whiskers is what they are.

The biggest bone in their bodies is their skull. If you've ever watched a cat or rabbit go through small openings you know how they can weasel into tight holes. Kitchens have no shortage of used up s/s pot scrubbies or wads of aluminum foil to stuff into cracks. However the critters can pull this out or weave holes into it. I foam this stuff into place with that foam-in-a-can stuff so they can't pull it out. Metal covers are best for pipe openings, etc., but for "emergencies" foam and s/s scrubbies work pretty good.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#12

I had a cat just like that....

John in NM

Big black cat, half Maine coon cat. He would eat whole bunnies, less a foot or two and the guts. He always left the guts at the bottom of the stairs for my dad to find with a bare foot first thing in the morning. Funny part is that dad never learned, fell for that over and over :D

That cat also caught a bat once, but didn't seem to care for the flavor, so left it under the dining room table (dad found that one too :D )

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#13

Another guru ...

Bruce McCrory

OB, I can smell a good ratter, too. :D My methods aren't as elaborate, however. My corks are plastic, or screw lids.

I wish my earlier article had been edited better. Sorry to all, for the disjoints. On that note, some other thoughts:

Rats are the culprits, the enemy in my book. If I have a mouse problem, then I have discouraged or eradicated the natural mouser.

I haven't done it, but poison can be stuffed into PVC pipe and fixed solid at perimeters of urban properties, away from normal play areas. The intent is to prevent casual access to a dangerous substance. Professional poison boxes are pretty expensive, as are the Trap Mansions (my name).

Rats will use roof gutters and downspouts for freeways. Foundation drains are their tunnels. And sewers. The rat you flush down a toilet will be crawling out in a while, or shock a user on another toilet. The only water is in a few inches of drain trap. Wood piles, piles of any nature by a foundation are cover and habitat for pests. They even frequent BBQ grills.

Food processing facilities (not cafes) are notoriously clean and barren. All you will see near a foundation is a poison trap every couple hundred feet, and paving. And, roof downspouts are fully sealed. Maintenance is key to control.

My experience in other fields has convinced me that easy, off the shelf poisons and pesticides (herbicides, too) will do little more than harm everyone and everything in the long term.

No one is free of pests. Rats and mice have followed humans from the cave house. They will never be eradicated. In the same vein, we are responsible to protect the bystanders, responsible more so to them than the subject of our efforts. (Then, the preacher growled...)

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#14

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

Brian from Monument

I have had some experience with mice in the garage.

I would not use poison as the mice will eat it and then go somewhere you cannot retrieve their rotting carcases.

2nd don't use poison if you have small pets that might get into it.

Mouse traps work best. Already mentioned peanut butter is excellent bait.

Get many mouse traps, there are always several takers. Not just one or two.

I even had one trap that got two mice with one hit.

If you do choose to use the cat approach, keep the cat hungry and confined so it must hunt where you have the problem. But did the cats mother teach it to hunt. Some are good hunters some are a victim of legend. and are allegedly good hunters.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#15

Re: I had a cat just like that....

TomD

I had a big black cat at one point who unlike my other cats, was mostly useless at catching. Once he caught a bat, and liked it I guess, because even when we plugged up the siding just above the foundation, he stood there for a few summers, expectantly. He may have been mostly useless in the field, but he would hang out with a boatbuilder no matter how loud the grinder, just sleeping a few feet off to one side. Best cat ever. Hal.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#16

A well-fed cat hunts just as well

Patrick Gibbons

It's my understanding that being hungry does not make a cat a better hunter. As others have stated, the cat is either a natural or it's not. I live by the bayou and have a problem with rodents in the garage (shop) and rabbits in the compost heap. Besides hawks, there's also a rather large owl that likes my backyard as a hunting spot. It even almost got my cat once. The neighbor has used traps and poison. I think the poison was not so good, because of the smell of dead rats. When he started his regimen against the rodents, it seemed to drive them into my garage. That's when he switched to traps only and achieved better success. I never got around to doing anything. I've noticed my problem has greatly decreased. The owl? The drought? Not sure what's caused the decrease. I'm sure the neighbor's efforts contributed a lot.

Re: OT - mouse/rat control in crawl space

#17

The old school way

CJ

I can only imagine how much fun the boys had.

http://boingboing.net/2013/01/07/rats-and-rat-riddance.html