New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Milling for Maximum Thickness

Posts

Milling for Maximum Thickness

#1

Milling for Maximum Thickness

Steve Elliott

This is the best tip I can give for getting the most out of a piece of lumber and it's sure to start an argument. I'm posting this in a new thread but it was kicked off by Bill Tindall's comment, "If removing cup, start with the convex side up [when using a power jointer]."

To get a straight board of maximum thickness and width, start by removing stock from the middle of the convex side of the board, or the middle of the convex edge. Most wood leaves the kiln in a case-hardened condition, which means that the outside of the wood is in compression and the inside is in tension. When stock is removed from the hump in the middle of the board, the balance of tension and compression is disturbed and the board bends a little and becomes straighter. When the first side or edge is straight, the board is thicker or wider at the ends. When the second side or edge is worked to produce a parallel surface, very little wood needs to be removed from the middle of the board so its overall shape doesn't change much.

Of course not every board is case-hardened so this technique doesn't always help, but it works about 2/3 of the time in my experience. When I'm done milling a pile of boards it's the case-hardened ones that are the straightest.

I spent today milling oak and maple for drawer parts. Of the stock I used I'd say 85% was case-hardened. I'm always a little disappointed if stock has had all the internal tension released in drying, which can be done by an additional step at the end of the kiln drying process.

Usually I try to stay out of arguments and don't like to start them, but this is one of the things I've learned over the years that I think other woodworkers would appreciate knowing about if they realized how helpful it is.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#2

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

david charlesworth

I can confirm that this technique has got me out of tricky situations, many times in the past.

So often there is one board which looks like it will not make the desired thickness.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#3

If you are from Missouri....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

(the show me state) what do you see that indicates the success of this approach? (read on, the question is not as dumb as it may initially sound, well it may be)

The mechanics of what you describe are sound so I have no question that what you describe will work.....to some extent. Enough to be seen by an observant worker without careful measurement?

When we ran a hardwood lumber business we mostly sold finished planed lumber and as a result I have run tens of thousands of feet of lumber through a planer and don't recall observing a response to material removed. Admittedly, I wasn't looking for it and one goes brain dead after a few minutes of this mindless activity and looses any ability to observe subtle effects. (The more obvious reason to plane convex up is better registration against the planer bed.) So, you saw some response on 85% of the lumber you were running. What did you see that I have missed?

I guess a way of phrasing the question for me would be- if I wanted to confirm this observation what scale of effect would I be looking for and how would I look- eye, ruler, micrometer?

A person running an in-line rip saw at a factory would be in the best position to see this effect. While I have watched this equally mindless activity I never ran one. If the effect is significant it would be standard practice to always rip the convex edge off first. No idea if this is standard practice or not. I'll ask next time I am with a plant manager or foreman.

An additional observation that does not confirm your observation results from lumber planed on a double headed planer. The way this machine is set up will simultaneously remove more from the convex side than the concave side. At times we bought skip planed lumber from such a machine. Your observation would result in this lumber being cupped after it exited the machine and that was not the case. I don't like other aspects of double headed machine planing but flatness was not an obvious problem.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#4

No need for a micrometer here

Steve Elliott

I guess a way of phrasing the question for me would be- if I wanted to confirm this observation what scale of effect would I be looking for and how would I look- eye, ruler, micrometer?

The amount of movement due to released tension can easily be seen by sighting down the board. If I need to reduce the thickness of a board after it has been straightened I use multiple passes through the planer. After the first pass the board will be concave in length on the upper side, so the for the second pass I flip it over to straighten it out again.

As for ripping, think of how many times you've ripped a board down the middle and it has pinched the tablesaw blade. The two resulting narrower boards usually look like a pair of parentheses because of the tension released.

Again, some boards react in the opposite way and spread apart but most tend to pinch the blade.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#5

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

hennebury

I always dress lumber convex side up when cupped or bowed. find it more stable to seat on the jointer concave face down.

Usually dress it twice; once to rough size and let it move & settle ; try to remove an equal amount of each side. then second time dress to finish size. If you can, leave it days, weeks before final dress to size.

Acclimatizing to the shop is important to relieve stress.

I am never sure on where or how the lumber has been prior to arriving at my place, so sticker it and let it be for as long as possible. I doesn't only matter what happened at the kiln it also matters how and in what conditions it has been stored since leaving the kiln.

I have had lumber turn in and out from the blade or cup in or cup out when ripped or resawn, so I find it best to be patient and dress twice.

It is not a bad idea to resaw a piece from your newly delivered lumber to observe what it does and let you know what to expect and how to treat it.I never used a moisture meter and found the resawing and seeing what happens is usually a good way to understand whats going on with your lumber.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#6

Re: Milling for ... final surface?

Bruce McCrory

Steve’s information has valuable implications for the final user, the craftsman. A mill would be less bothered by micro managing their lumber dimensions.

So I can picture this better … Steve, you are machine jointing? Or, Hand plane flattening the convex surface? The lumber is initially unsurfaced (rough)? Mill planed previously? When the surface compression is relieved, “straightened”, you are referring to cup, *not* a bowed board as “end” would imply.

I don’t own a machine jointer. But, I would tend to agree with Bill’s method for initial flattening, facing, however. If Steve can efficiently joint (machine) a convex surface—let’s just say face; it’s the one we usually are most concerned about—initially, Steve must have a simple jig or technique to be successful in producing a uniformly level face.

When accounting for case hardening, is a mill surfaced face going to respond favorably (with all the caveats) to final flattening? I don’t have a mental image for typical depth of case hardening. And, perhaps another Bill ran the concave face under the planer at the mill, thus aggravating the “cup”.

Finally, I admit my last question is niggling. However, I can visualize a board losing its bow after case hardening is relieved.

I will go to Hoadley for a couple other questions that surfaced during this soliloquy.

BTW, I have deep respect for Steve's comments.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#7

sampling

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most lumber manufactured now days comes from huge operations that have the skill and equipment to dry properly (certainly not the case from boutique drying operations). As time went on we found it ever less likely to get a bundle of anything less that perfectly dried lumber. What can happen though is that a rouge piece creeps into the operation. It can be a few pieces or ends of pieces that were situated in some part of the kiln that got better or worse air circulation. Or it can be a board or two that were much wetter, for a variety of reasons, than the average of the stacks going into the kiln. Or it may just be some outlier a tree produced. Work enough lumber and a cranky piece will eventually show up to be dealt with.

PS I never used a moisture meter either. I can tell how dry lumber is as soon as shavings are generated from the planer, if not before by feel.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#8

A more complete description

Steve Elliott

Bruce,

I do all my milling using power equipment but the behavior of the wood due to tension would be the same with hand tools. I use this technique whether the stock is rough or surfaced when it reaches the shop.

I’m not referring to cup but to curvature along the length of the board. To produce a flat face I start by placing the highest part of the convex hump on the outer end of the jointer’s infeed table and lowering the front edge down onto the outfeed table. As I advance the board I keep pressure on the outfeed table. This means the trailing end of the board will be lifted off the infeed table. If the first pass doesn’t remove the entire hump (usually it doesn’t) I repeat the procedure until the entire surface is flat. If I need to maintain some minimum dimension I watch the middle of the board to make sure I don't make it too thin.

The resulting surface has a little bump at the front end that will be removed during subsequent work with the planer. It’s the overall straight shape that I want to achieve at this stage.

My procedure is to choose the boards and rough mill them oversize, then sticker them for a few days if possible or at least overnight. This allows the moisture to equalize a little and there may be some movement due to the change in balance between tension and compression. Usually the straight shape produced in the first milling is plenty good enough for the work to be done. At this stage the boards may not be of uniform thickness. When reducing them to the desired dimension I check the straightness of each board as I put it into the planer (by just sighting down the edge) and remove stock from the convex side. Most boards get flipped a few times as they bow back and forth.

As for the depth of case hardening I believe it affects the entire thickness of the stock in one way or another. If you think of a wide board just ripped in half on a tablesaw, each resulting half has just moved until the tension and compression forces are back in balance. This means the newly cut surface has been pushed into compression as the piece distorts. So the original condition of the outer surfaces in compression and the inside in tension has been recreated in each narrower piece. Any further milling can be done using the same technique.

Now a word on cupping. This is where movement due to moisture changes plays a major role, and in flatsawn lumber even after a surface has been made flat it will become cupped in one direction or the other as the moisture content of the wood changes with the seasons. The straightness in length is affected very little if at all by moisture changes.

Once you’ve seen this technique work a few times it seems much simpler than it sounds.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#9

Now I get it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are straightening bow(or is it crook?), not removing cup. Never tried what you are describing but will at the next opportunity.

BTW, drying stress goes to the core.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#10

Drying Stress

Steve Elliott

. . . drying stress goes to the core . . .

It does and I'm glad of it. How the stress gets there as a result of the drying process is another story for another time.

To me understanding stress in wood is a bigger deal than getting a cap iron to work. I wasn't taught how to deal with it during my vocational training and realized it after about seven years of work in cabinet shops. My reaction was, "Why didn't I think of this sooner?"

My guess is that most of my co-workers don't know about this. I've been asked why I sight down boards as I mill them and I don't think my explanation got through. Over the years I have heard comments about my milled stock being unusually straight, though. I’ve worked under two cabinetmakers who had completed traditional apprenticeships (in Norway and Germany) and neither seemed to be aware of this. I’ve posted about it before and probably will again. I wish there was a dramatic video like the Kato/Kawai one to help get this across.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#11

Re: Ahhhh ... Now ...

Bruce McCrory

... "I see," says the blind man.

I will follow technique ... In spite of tear out. :D I never learned to "wheelie"--front wheel hand brake action--hand planes at the end of a pass; it's more like a golf swing. This will be training.

[An astoundingly graphic video, too. How is LV's new steel blade? (The reason for my earlier confusion.)]

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#12

Re: A more complete description

hennebury

I dress bowed lumber a little different;

I stand at the outfeed side of the jointer to start.

I dont use a blade guard as i find that it interferes.

I hold the wood concave side down.

I start by holding about 9/10ths of the wood over the outfeed table and 1/10th over the infeed side of the cutterhead.

I lower the wood down to the infeed table then lower the wood down over the cutterhead to the outfeed table drawing it toward me, so just nipping a skim from the end. I then flip the board around and take a skim of the other end.

Then repeat several times taking a longer pass of each end, so working the dressed face closer to meeting in the middle of the board.

Then i move down to the infeed side of the jointer to make the final full length skim passes. All the time being mindful of not pressing and distorting the board.

For the finish passes the hand pressure is almost all on the outfeed table.

Most of the time the boards are also twisted as well as bowed. so i lay the board on the jointer and rock it to see how much of a twist i have to deal with, i try to hold the board so that the twist gap is equal on each end, trying to remove the same amount of material from each end.

Boards are then thicknessplaned oversize and stickered to settle for a day or two, or longer if i can manage.

I usually dress close to finish size, but oversize enough to re-joint and thickness to finish size.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#13

comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With minor variation the approach you take is what I have always done only because it seemed intuitively easier. If I understand Steve correctly (finding the accurate word for this kind of lumber defect would be helpful, is it crook, bow??) he is saying that if we proceed first on the other side of the board that it will at least partially self straighten. It begs trying.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#14

Steve....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The wonderful drawings you use to describe sharpening and dulling would be most beneficial in this discussion.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#15

Re: comment

hennebury

I will give it a try.

Re: Milling for Maximum Thickness

#16

Drawings someday

Steve Elliott

I hope before too long to put together both drawings and photos to illustrate this. Then again there are a lot of projects I hope to do . . . .