New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Ok. A question

Posts

Ok. A question

#1

Ok. A question

Ron Harper

In the thread below about planing, my sanity was questioned because I size my tabletops very close to thickness before glue- up. Is this so weird? With a flat gluing bench and proper preparation this has become pretty routine for me. I would really have trouble if I tried to glue up complex assemblies the way Bill does in a post below. My hat is off to him. I'd love to stop by his shop someday and learn how he does it.

Re: Ok. A question

#2

Lots of roads up the mountain

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If it works for you, it's a good approach. What works for Bill Tindall works for him.

Re: Ok. A question

#3

Agree wholeheartedly...

John in NM

A lot of people on the internet are very attached to their own way of doing things, but if your methods produce the result you desire, then stick with them. Eventually your methods may need to evolve to meet changing goals, but in the mean time don't sweat it.

Re: Ok. A question

#4

Re: Ok. A question

TomD

I don't recall the thread, but sizing the table parts prior to glue-up sounds to me like standard practice, assuming one does not have machines large enough to take the parts, or reach long enough to do it by hand. Even then, the best yield of stable parts comes from finishing the sub-assemblies first. Same principle as best yield in sawing comes from breaking the board out first.

Re: Ok. A question

#5

Re: Ok. A question

cstanford

I think the day will inevitably come when you'll wish you had the extra thickness to solve some sort of problem that presents itself post glue-up.

If it doesn't then you must be living right, and me, not so well.

Re: Ok. A question

#6

Ron, my experience

Patrick Gibbons

Most panels I've glued up from wood that I bought S3S and had minimal planing to do after the glue up. On the occasions where I have used rough, unsurfaced lumber, I would plane any cup, warp or other problem from the individual boards but wait until after glue up to do my major surfacing. This was to bring the panel to a consistent thickness. I read the thread below but not thoroughly. I suspect some are leaving out some detail on their procedure. If the boards I'm starting out with are flat and smooth then my panel will need very little work. Essentially just cleaning up the glue lines. There's usually no surprises about how much work my panels are going to need because I can tell going into the process what's going to be needed. If I rush a glue up before I perfect the butt joints, I always have more work to do on the panels. Maybe you and I are both blissfully ignorant.

Re: Ok. A question

#7

We agree

Ron Harper

I can get a surprise, but it does not happen often. I do agree with Roger that if much thickness needs to be removed, it needs to be done over a few days to allow for movement in the wood.

Re: Ok. A question

#8

Re: We agree

TomD

Why would the wood move if you had already let the wood move. If it moves every time you do something, then there isn't any end to it. My wood is done by the time I start.

Re: Ok. A question

#9

two reasons

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. There is a moisture gradient in the lumber.

2. There is residual stress in the lumber.

2.5 It is a common practice in furniture shops because they have experienced the results of 1 and 2.

Re: Ok. A question

#10

Re: Ok. A question

cstanford

Don't know about roads up mountains and all of that half-existential stuff. In Planecraft, broad surfaces are planed after panel glueup, not before. Ditto Joyce, Frid, Hayward, Ernest Jones, and on and on.

An internet connection is generally a poor substitute for a woodworking library, though here is a little ditty from Jeff Gorman's website - the section on making a panel joint:

"It is really desirable to work with material that is thicker than the intended finished dimension. The entire surface can then be planed after the job has been glued."

Re: Ok. A question

#11

Ok

Ron Harper

Yes I plane after glue up but hopefully with my smoothers. Not to thickness stock. I really am not comfortable suggesting what you should o.

Re: Ok. A question

#12

Re: Ok

cstanford

Ron, it's easier to process panel as a whole than it is individual boards almost to completion. Try it once or twice. You owe it to yourself.

Re: Ok. A question

#13

I sure will


Re: Ok. A question

#14

True edge?

Ron Harper

How do you get this with no reference surface?

Re: Ok. A question

#15

Re: True edge?

cstanford

Use a combo square like you always do and then tweak to get the boards generally vertical - I test it with boards in the vice usually. Register the combo square on the concave side of the board, not the convex side (everything has a little cup).

It sounds impossible. I swear before God it's not. If you want to, you can clamp boards back to back and plane the edges at the same time - boards DO NOT have to be flattened first for this to work.

Re: Ok. A question

#16

Gonna try next time I use rough stock


Re: Ok. A question

#17

Re: Ok. A question

jack curtis

My working approach is that all panels will go out of flat when glued and clamped, so I try to get the downside as flat as possible, planning to just have to do some touchups there. For the other side, I plan to take out all the non-flat possible. That's it.