New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Sawhorses

Posts

Sawhorses

#1

Ellis Walentine

Sawhorses

Ellis Walentine

Good morning, folks. I'd like to gauge your interest in a sawhorse contest. I've been thinking about this for quite a while, as I reminisce about my visits to Jim Krenov's shop and all the nifty sawhorse designs I saw there. Seeing Bill Tindall's post below just reminded me of the contest idea.

I'm imagining the designs could be all over the map in terms of size, specific intention, but judged on the relative merits of function, aesthetics and joinery. We could do this with big prizes, like we usually do with our contests, and recruit well-known judges, or we could do it on a shoestring with volunteer judges.

What say? Could I interest you in designing and building sawhorses for a competition?

Ellis

Re: Sawhorses

#2

Re: Sawhorses

Bruce McCrory

This could be fun. I still have most of 30 years in failures and successful subjects moldering somewhere. But none solve my Rube Goldberg needs. Most importantly, I could meet the special skills needed for doing this subject.

One vote in...

Re: Sawhorses

#3

Re: Sawhorses

Patrick Gibbons

The ones I use are traditional saw benches. I always think contests are fun. It would be interesting to see what others have done.

Re: Sawhorses

#4

Selfish Thoughts.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would like to begin by considering what the main objective of this contest will be. I would like to consider teaching as the main objective.

I have no interest in building a saw horse for a contest, BUT, I would like to see what others find useful for I might benefit from these designs. I still recall my visit to David Finck's shop where I first saw the Krenov horses in use and came to appreciate their numerous functional attributes-easy to move, easy to store, easy to build and very sturdy. I am not one to spend time on shop furniture, but I suspended furniture building until I had two sets of these wonderful horses. To that end, a contest with rules and prizes that encourages many, and a diversity of, entries would be most desirable to me.

The problem with this kind of contest is that it could be ruled and judged such that an ordinary design that everyone may have employed in their shop, executed from Brazilian rosewood with dovetailed joinery, would be the winner and nothing would be learned from the exercise. I recall the shop contest. I found no practical knowledge from the "show" shops that were the winners. It could have been a bonanza of shop ideas, but wasn't.

A thought- ask the masses what kinds of horse categories might be considered for prizes. For example, a horse from a 2 x 4. Strongest horse. Easiest to store. Horses for the shop. Horses for the job site. Easiest to make. Horses costing less than $5 to make. Horses entirely built with hand tools. Fancy joinery or most handsome, if you must.

So long as the judges are people that routinely use horses in the shop or on the job site I don't care how famous they are. And, if I was willing to make a horse just for the purpose of this contest a modest prize would be the same motivation to enter as a large one, for the main motivation to enter would be to teach others about a useful design. $10, 25 and $50 gift certificates to a WC supporting business would be a dandy prize for each of several categories of horse designs.

Re: Sawhorses

#5

Re: Selfish Thoughts.....

William Duffield

Excellent points, Bill. I've been considering building a pair of trestles similar in design to the ones you built and use. I am amazed that yours are strong enough to hold up that bench, not to mention the plant stands and the platform of 2x lumber at the same time. I'm still using two pairs of StoreHorses, one of which I collapsed when I was building a bench several years ago, so I'm still leery of overloading them.

Saw horses or saw trestles are meant to do work, not look pretty. A separate category, or a forgotten category, that would reward turnings or inlay banding, stringing and bell flowers would be necessary for me to enter, so I wouldn't have to deal with that category at all.

I also have designed and built, but as far as I can remember never published, a horse for sawing logs for bowl blanks. It also works for firewood. I've noticed that some contests are limited to new designs or new work. Excluding this horse on those grounds would do a disservice to the educational value of the contest. I would propose that you offer token prizes if you think they would encourage more people to enter the contest, but I personally wouldn't need that incentive.

As far as joinery, wedged through tenons are great for demonstrating the strength and construction of the joints, but Dominos can be as effective, much quicker to execute, but are not an obvious teaching tool. Also, admittedly, a Festool DF500 or DF700 is extremely expensive compared to a mallet, mortise chisel, a pair of back saws and layout tools.

A requirement to provide joinery dimensions and materials would make the entries much more useful to the WC readership.

How about a "load to failure" test? That would make it a fun contest. :D

Re: Sawhorses

#6

Re: Selfless Tho'ts.....

Bruce McCrory

I bought a metal contraption years ago that is incredibly durable. However it does not perform as a sawhorse "system". I have a couple 'Burrows' from HD I paid $40 for that do the basic job, and no more. Similar I made were burned for wasting space.

I joked about a Rube Goldberg ... But not really. Some of us are pretty limited in space. For some, a horse fills the closet they have to store it in.

I am jacked about a contest. Even a demonstration! (Nice demo, Bill T.)

Re: Sawhorses

#7

Re: Selfish Thoughts.....

TomD

I agree with Bill that it should not be a decorating contest, probably. But aesthetics should be part of it. I remember seeing this show on performing Shakespeare, and the actors and directors were discussing when to pause. The director made the strong point that "pauses should be earned". Meaning they should not just be inserted all over the place, they should be inevitable based on the rest of the work.

Beautiful objects, are more likely to get people excited about using them, and more likely to make them, but the beauty should probably be mostly in terms of function. I think I have had my Krenov horses a lot longer than Bill has had his, probably about 30 years in my case. Mine are only slightly nicer finished than his, if that. I recently showed them here as part of my bridge crane, and one of the reasons they adapted so well to that is that they are pretty blocky, and this allow stuff to be clamped to them, and for them to be clamped to each other, where more stability is required. But they also can be painful to bump into, and when I see examples that look nicer to my eye, more refined, they probably take up less space and cause less pain, and weigh less. So the aesthetics not only add something to their appearance, but they might be more functional.

Re: Sawhorses

#8

Ellis Walentine

Excellent suggestions -- keep them coming!

Ellis Walentine

Bill and I are thinking along the same lines on this one. Multiple categories won't fit our regular contest judging paradigm, but that's okay. We could just make a list of judging categories and solicit entries. This would mean that entrants would have to pick one category for their submission. (It could be in the purview of the judges to move an entry to a more appropriate category at their discretion.)

Sawhorses are shop fixtures, first and foremost. Fancy filigree and/or exotic materials don't make a lot of practical sense, and, certainly, if someone wants to gild the lily personally, they can go ahead and do it. But, I don't think decoration should have much, if any, weight in the judging.

The Krenovian sawhorses I've seen -- and the many pairs we had in my shop before the fire -- were all about engineering and construction. So, I'd be looking for aspects like size, material selection, rigidity/stability and height and duty rating per purpose. (With the understanding that some sawhorses are larger, for heavier-duty applications.)

I even have a design I'd like to submit myself, for a specialty sawhorse that I can't discuss here or else you'd all steal the idea. :)

Keep the ideas coming. I sense a contest on the horizon.

Ellis

Re: Sawhorses

#9

Re: Some inspiration

TomD

http://americanwoodworker.com/blogs/randyjohnson/archive/2009/03/02/simple-sturdy-sawhorses.aspx

Saw horses are one of those small easy to make, seemingly space saving items, that can end up taking over the shop. A pair of krenov style horses standing around, takes up the same space as a bench. I'm still not convinced making them demountable is the solution, since in my case once made a useful thing is rarely stored in parts... But:

http://americanwoodworker.com/blogs/resources/archive/2011/08/08/american-woodworker-156-october-november-2011-preview-knockdown-trestle-sawhorses.aspx

http://books.google.ca/books?id=cvsDAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA48&lpg=PA48&dq=american+woodworker+saw+horses&source=bl&ots=aDoNUmU0bg&sig=M1l4IphIZIkfpOYjrk3Nk7M67fc&hl=en&sa=X&ei=YW3fUJaKL-Lu0gHBsIDAAg&ved=0CD4Q6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=american%20woodworker%20saw%20horses&f=false

My favourite article on sawhorses:

http://books.google.ca/books?id=DPYDAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA48&dq=saw+horses&hl=en&sa=X&ei=I2_fUJPrLMXm0QHmwIDgDQ&ved=0CFoQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=saw%20horses&f=false

Re: Sawhorses

#10

Re: Some inspiration

William Duffield

Here are two more, from Chesapeake Light Craft, specifically enhanced for supporting kayaks and canoes:

http://www.clcboats.com/shoptips/stitch_glue/sawhorses_slings.html

The second one is particularly ingenious, but is made from PVC, not wood.

Re: Sawhorses

#11

Re: Some inspiration

TomD

In the land of over reach:

http://www.woodsongcanoes.com/display_options.htm

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_MlvfQTkG04Q/R-G89NxTQ9I/AAAAAAAAAFw/h7CbJlfd_0s/s400/woodsong.jpg

Re: Sawhorses

#12

Re: Excellent suggestions -- keep them coming!

Bruce McCrory

Quote: "I even have a design I'd like to submit myself, for a specialty sawhorse that I can't discuss here or else you'd all steal the idea." End quote

Well!!! Now you say it ... *after* I divulge my concepts! :\

Re: Sawhorses

#13

Categories, and criteria

James Watriss

I'm thinking 2 categories, and a score based on a list of criteria, plus final judgment.

-My thought on categories: No-nonsense, and specialization. Some horses need to be very expedient. Others are specialized shop fixtures. Grouping them all together makes no sense.

The no nonsense category is easy enough to understand. Budget, durability, store-ability, and possibly limited to home center lumber to boot.

The specialization category is more for horses that fit particular needs, or have been adapted in thoughtful and well implemented ways. Kayaks, job site, short trestles and beams for dry fitting a built in, etc... weird situational stuff, or just well thought out. Some horses need to be expedient, but not all.

Criteria thoughts... Budget, load capacity, expedience in build, thoughtfulness of design... More?

Re: Sawhorses

#14

Ellis Walentine

 


Re: Sawhorses

#15

Re: Categories, and criteria

Bruce McCrory

If we limit the fixture to a support function, I can't see anything more utilitarian than the ubiquitous real estate "Open House" A-board sitting beside the street.

I think we have different interpretations of what a "sawhorse" is. Also, one's intended function. The classic woodworker magazine tends to exhibit them as load burrows, temporary work benches, and; its namesake, the sawhorse.

I never owned a true workbench. What passed for one was usually an expanded storage shelf. As a youth, sawhorses and a convenient step were my working benches. They still are.

In this view, as a working fixture, a sawhorse encompasses a much broader spectrum of designs and purposes.

Re: Sawhorses

#16

another idea to encourage submissions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Submit horses you actually use, what ever they are including construction details. Winner(s) picked by random drawing.

Re: Sawhorses

#17

Just sawhorses, or also sawbenches?

Chuck Nickerson

I have no sawhorses, but use my sawbenches (3rd generation) as sawhorses from time to time.

Re: Sawhorses

#18

Saw benches are just specialized horses, IMO