New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

Posts

Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#1

Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

Scott in Douglassville

Hi, all -

I picked up a new saw for dovetailing last week - a Richardson Bros. 8" backsaw:


The saw is in nice shape, though the teeth need work:


Not sure what's going on there. Parts are 16 PPI, parts 14 PPI, teeth sharpened all cattywompus.

Anyway, I'm thinking of retoothing this to 16 PPI. I think I've narrowed down the field to three places: http://www.tgiag.com/ (Dom Greco), http://www.badaxetoolworks.com/ (Bad Axe), and http://home.grics.net/~weir/Old_SAWS_Restored.html (Daryl Weir). I'm not trying to start any flame wars, but I'm wondering if any of you have experience with any/all of these three sources (or any I'm missing), and what your opinions are? The last saw I had sharpened was by Tom Law, so I'm a bit out of the game.

Thanks for any input.

Scott

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#2

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail sa

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Scott,

Nice Saw. I have two just like that one, although mine are Disstons.

I am not sure where you are located, but I have my saws sharpened by Marv Werner up in Northern California (no affiliation, just a happy customer), and he does a super job. In fact I have 5 saws up there being sharpened right now. I can supply you with contact info if you like.

You can't go wrong with D. Weir from what I have read and heard, although I have not had any saws sharpened by him.

Also there is Matt C?? up in Rhode Island who recently started a saw sharpening business. I have heard some good comments about his work also. Again, I can get contact info if you want. Good luck.

Ron

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#3

Bob Rozaieski

Ron Harper

Sharpened a backsaw for me recently. Fair price. Saw cuts like a dream

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#4

Bob Rozaieski

Ron Harper

Sharpened a backsaw for me recently. Fair price. Saw cuts like a dream

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#5

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail sa

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Marv does a great job. He did my LN DT saw a few months age. Cuts better than when it was new. He hangs out at the sawmill.

Cheers, and Merry Christmas!

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#6

Re: Bob Rozaieski

Scott in Douglassville

Thanks, Ron. Sent Bob an inquiry. He's fairly close, which would minimize shipping.

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#7

Results!

Scott in Douglassville

Saw came back from Bob Rozaieski today. He reset the back, retoothed and sharpened it to 18 PPI rip. Cuts like a dream now.



Again, in case you've forgotten how this started out:


Now to plane some wood and get busy!

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#8

Re: Results!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It sure makes a difference when a tool is worked on by someone who truly knows what he's doing. Good for you! That must be a joy to use. I have a miter saw that needs work, and while I've tried, the results haven't been totally successful. Time to send it out to someone who really knows how to fix it.

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#9

Re: Results!

CStanford

Scott I'm sure he did a fantastic job and did what you asked him to do, but resetting it in the spine appears to have turned it into a tenon saw - ruined the hang for sawing half lap dovetails. Was this really the intent?

Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O

#10

Re: Results!

Scott in Douglassville

Obviously my intent isn't/wasn't to ruin the saw's capabilities. Really?

I am not a saw expert. I defer to Bob's advice and judgment on this issue (well documented on his blog). Again, I'm not an expert, but I thought tenon saws had plates larger than 8", but I could be wrong. :b