We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O
Scott in Douglassville
Hi, all -
I picked up a new saw for dovetailing last week - a Richardson Bros. 8" backsaw:
The saw is in nice shape, though the teeth need work:
Not sure what's going on there. Parts are 16 PPI, parts 14 PPI, teeth sharpened all cattywompus.
Anyway, I'm thinking of retoothing this to 16 PPI. I think I've narrowed down the field to three places: http://www.tgiag.com/ (Dom Greco), http://www.badaxetoolworks.com/ (Bad Axe), and http://home.grics.net/~weir/Old_SAWS_Restored.html (Daryl Weir). I'm not trying to start any flame wars, but I'm wondering if any of you have experience with any/all of these three sources (or any I'm missing), and what your opinions are? The last saw I had sharpened was by Tom Law, so I'm a bit out of the game.
Thanks for any input.
Scott
Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O
Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail sa
Ron in Sterling, CT
Hi Scott,
Nice Saw. I have two just like that one, although mine are Disstons.
I am not sure where you are located, but I have my saws sharpened by Marv Werner up in Northern California (no affiliation, just a happy customer), and he does a super job. In fact I have 5 saws up there being sharpened right now. I can supply you with contact info if you like.
You can't go wrong with D. Weir from what I have read and heard, although I have not had any saws sharpened by him.
Also there is Matt C?? up in Rhode Island who recently started a saw sharpening business. I have heard some good comments about his work also. Again, I can get contact info if you want. Good luck.
Ron
Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O
It sure makes a difference when a tool is worked on by someone who truly knows what he's doing. Good for you! That must be a joy to use. I have a miter saw that needs work, and while I've tried, the results haven't been totally successful. Time to send it out to someone who really knows how to fix it.
Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O
Scott I'm sure he did a fantastic job and did what you asked him to do, but resetting it in the spine appears to have turned it into a tenon saw - ruined the hang for sawing half lap dovetails. Was this really the intent?
Re: Sharpening options for a new-to-me dovetail saw? O
Obviously my intent isn't/wasn't to ruin the saw's capabilities. Really?
I am not a saw expert. I defer to Bob's advice and judgment on this issue (well documented on his blog). Again, I'm not an expert, but I thought tenon saws had plates larger than 8", but I could be wrong.