New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Posts

Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#1

Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Charles Jackson III

I have a set of 1/4, 1/2, 3/4 and 1 inch Footprint Beech Handle chisel they have rust and pitting spots on them that I like to remove. I am wondering whats the best method to flatten a chisel back and would a 1000/8000 combo waterstone sharpen the bevel. I also need to find a bench grinder.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#2

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Bruce Mack

I haven't the wisdom of many others on this board, so will address only the coarse sharpening aspect. I am wary of grinders and the possibility of a major screw up, burning the edge or roughening it beyond my ability to repair. Having tried coarse waterstones I find them to be too slow for even slight rebeveling. An aluminum oxide (India) stone was fast but quickly became uneven. I bought a reasonably flat 1/4 steel plate from the metal bin at Menards and have used this as a base for both aluminum oxide and silicon carbide powder and oil. It's fast and I can flatten a bevel by hand before my arm muscles give up. From this I can proceed to the Veritas steel plates and diamond slurry which for now have replaced my waterstones. Others on this forum will have helpful advice. I have learned from my questions and lurking.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Charles,

You need something flat. I use a granite piece I got from Woodcraft. Glass works,preferably thick glass. A tablesaw top also will work. I do the rough work with sandpaper ,gradually going to smoother grits. Removing pitting from chisel backs takes a little patience because you want to keep it flat. Once you remove the pitting you can use your stones to finish.

I am no expert and a lazy sharpener. With the exception of drawknives I usually end up sharpening a bunch of stuff at once after everything I touch is dull,but this works for me. Others may have better methods. Have fun with it. ---Jack

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#4

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Patrick Gibbons

Keep in mind that the initial flattening is the longest operation you'll perform on your chisels short of a regrind to remove a chip. The other comments are dead on. Use a flat surface like a granite plate or plate glass and a course medium. Finish on your regular stones.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#5

Robert Tutsky

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

Robert Tutsky

In the past I used 1/4" plate glass as a base for wet/dry automotive sandpaper which worked well. After selling all that stuff and moving on I found a tile place that sold polished 12" x 12" granite 1/2" thick which I mount the sandpaper to. It works great and has some weight to the base. For pitted chisel backs I start with 80 grit to remove pits then move on to 180, 320, 600, 800, 1500 and finally 2500 grits to flatten the backs. Next I would regrind the bevels by hand on a grinder. Takes some practice but if you have a steady hand and work with a light pressure it can be done. Once when the bevels are correct I move to the sandpaper to finish the bevels. Start with 180 grit and move on up to the 2500 grit, ultimately polishing with a green compound charged leather strop.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#6

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

eliot d

You may want to ignore what I say here, but what I do when the back is really badly pitted, is to make a simple jig to keep the chisel flat against a belt sander. It takes just a few seconds on the belt sander. The chisel will look like new, but it won't be flat enough( new ones usually aren't flat anyway); so THEN you can go ahead with the other methods recommended to get it really flat. My point is that getting all those pits out without the belt sander takes forever.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#7

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

cstanford

True. Pitted steel is virtually useless, tiny pits will erode during use and during honing leaving a jagged edge that results in inexplicable (to the neophyte) plane tracks and other ugliness.

You have to be able to grind all the way to good steel either by grinding back, and thus shortening the tool, or by flat grinding on a belt sander or stationery sander, making the unit thinner. The latter is the best solution unless all of the pitting is at the edge and not much length will be lost by grinding to fresh, clean, unpitted steel. Other tricks like back bevels only delay the inevitable.

Micropitting, not to mention visible pitting, on saw plate is as bad or worse leaving the user with a saw that never gets sharp and inexplicably dulls much faster than it should as the pits erode during use. Sometimes sharpening, to the extent metal is removed back to a new line of pitting, makes the blade cut even worse than it did before the sharpening.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#8

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

TomD

Back bevels have the advantage of maintaining the bit stiffness, and leaving the mass of work till later. With a back bevel you can try it and see if you like it, and you probably won't be much worse off if you decide some other approach is required.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#9

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

CStanford

No arguments from me other than to say with all the equippage currently being manufactured in several price ranges, and quality vintage stuff available, there really seems little reason to put oneself in the position of having to deal with pitted steel. Seems pointless to me and a total distraction.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#10

How about a quick fix?

Bob Hackett

Pitting along the edge of your chisel? Roll an extra heavy burr on the bevel toward the back of the chisel and then hone the burr off. The displaced metal will allow you to fill most moderately pitted surfaces without having to grind the pits away.

How`s that for a quick and relatively painless fix? :D

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#11

Re: How about a quick fix?

TomD

Interesting, I will have to try that when the time comes.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#12

Re: Oh, reason not the need 


Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#13

Re: How about a quick fix?

cstanford

Bob, I thankfully don't have any pitted tools in my shop nor do I plan on adding any to my arsenal any time soon.

It's a good tip though for those that have a need.

Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?

#14

Just jousting at my daily windmill