Re: Sharpening and Flatting hand chisels?
cstanford
True. Pitted steel is virtually useless, tiny pits will erode during use and during honing leaving a jagged edge that results in inexplicable (to the neophyte) plane tracks and other ugliness.
You have to be able to grind all the way to good steel either by grinding back, and thus shortening the tool, or by flat grinding on a belt sander or stationery sander, making the unit thinner. The latter is the best solution unless all of the pitting is at the edge and not much length will be lost by grinding to fresh, clean, unpitted steel. Other tricks like back bevels only delay the inevitable.
Micropitting, not to mention visible pitting, on saw plate is as bad or worse leaving the user with a saw that never gets sharp and inexplicably dulls much faster than it should as the pits erode during use. Sometimes sharpening, to the extent metal is removed back to a new line of pitting, makes the blade cut even worse than it did before the sharpening.