New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Do I need a grinder

Posts

Do I need a grinder

#1

Do I need a grinder

Tony Wilkins

Following on to my question about the burr in sharpening, I'm wondering about a grinder. I watched the Chris Schwarz sharpening video on sharpening on the Popular Woodworking site.

He talks about the three phases/types of media in the sharpening process as being grinding, honing, and polishing - all related to the size of particles (in microns) of the media. I have an adequate water stone for honing (Hida 1,000 grit) and for polishing (King S3 6,000 grit). I don't have anything for grinding yet.

It seems like the most used is a grinding wheel (powered by electricity or hand crank) though there are grinding water stones and diamond stones.

So I haven't gotten a lot of information about grinding along the way. Can anybody help me be better informed? BTW, call me silly but the spinning wheel makes me somehow nervous.

TIA,

Tony

Re: Do I need a grinder

#2

Will find no consensus on this one


Re: Do I need a grinder

#3

Re: Do I need a grinder

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you maintain your edges diligently, and avoid running your chisels into nails and other things that will make big nicks, and are happy with the bevels on them as delivered, you may find that you will not often need a grinder.

And some determined folks do with very coarse stones what others do with a grinder.

That said, I have two: a regular bench grinder for rough shaping of bevels (I have a lot of "vintage," meaning "yard sale," chisels, some of which have been abused) and a wet grinder similar to the Tormek for fine grinding. I have tried, but have never mastered the art of fine grinding on a bench grinder without burning the bevel.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#4

you will know if you need one

BillTindall

It is a fast way to remove metal. If some alternative is too slow to suit you that is the time to buy it. See my article in the Articles section for wheel selection. The wheel is the difference between success and bruned edges.

If I was to make a suggestion it would be to get on with making something. It is the only way to know what you need. I need a grinder because I don't typically sharpen a plane blade until the tip is visibly rounded and to remore this wear involves removing more metal that say an oil stone will remove in what I consider a reasonable amount of time. (And I use it for a multitue of tasks on the farm and to sharpen lathe tools) Before the grinder I found 100 grit zirconia paper glued to a piece of glass and a sharpening jig served me well for this step in sharpening, so long as I was dealing with the tools made from traditional steel. Others find a water stone of some grit serves them.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#5

Re: Do I need a grinder

joel moskowitz

I cannot imagine not having a grinder. it has saved me countless hours in the workshop and the only must have power tool I own.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

No, but

Jack Guzman from Maine

You will always find a use for one in a shop that uses metal tools. Not just for reshaping chisel edges. I use a blue norton stone mostly. See the Article Bill mentions for stone selection.---Jack

Re: Do I need a grinder

#7

Re: Do I need a grinder

TomD

I got my first grinder when I started wood turning. In wood turning the turning itself is very fast, and unlike other woodworking, every step can be done under power from wood harvesting to final finishing. This means that unless you also automate the sharpening, materials disposal, and rough out of the pieces (in those cases where it makes sense to saw them), then you will spend all your time doing these grinding tasks, while only a small amount of your time will be spent on the part you like.

So I got a regular two wheel unit, 8" wheels and 1750 RPM, that was probably 30 years ago. I would not be without it, though I rarely use it on hand tools. The format of small round wheels at 3600 rpm is really a machine shop thing. It is better for some of those tasks, but as an all around unit the 8" 1750 is the business.

I should point out that I bought Asian back then, and it has never let me down, so the whole thing is so cheap it is hard to justify not having one. But! It will not solve every problem in the shop and if you are a hand tool purist for whatever reason, you may find like me that 40 stationary power tools later you are still at it. The rule as I described it already is that whatever you don't automate is the one thing you spend all your time doing, slippery slope.

Using power tools is dangerous, and while grinders have few bad habits they can hurt you, so peruse the safety info online when you make a decision.

I think the best all around grinders are the belt ones. They cut fast and cool, and can cut all bevel types from convex to concave.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#8

Re: Do I need a grinder

CStanford

You don't need a grinder.

Watch the video:

http://www.closegrain.com/2010/04/grimsdale-method-part-2.html#video

Re: Do I need a grinder

#9

Works very well for me

Ron Harper

I have been a convert for about a month. This is not to suggest that anyone else should do this ever. But, it works for me.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#10

Re: Do I need a grinder

TomD

In The Joiner & Cabinet Maker, a book from 1839, there is an interesting passage where the apprentice is told that he should take a moment to look at the power grindstone in some shop he might visit. Sure old shops all had grindstones, but even almost 200 years ago, the advantages of a power set-up were recognized. So if any reluctance is based on some idea that it is cheating to use a power grindstone, it can be set aside because even in the golden age they also had them. And the same is true in Japanese shops.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#11

Re: Do I need a grinder

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

I cannot imagine woodworking without a way to grind a bevel on a blade. My preference is to create a hollow grind and freehand on that, but years ago I would use a belt sander to create a flat grind, and then use a honing guide to form a micro secondary bevel.

It is indeed possible to do without a grinder, for example, I sharpen my Japanese slicks the traditional way - flat, full bevel face. These are different, however, since the blades are laminated steel, and this acts a like a hollow grind in that the soft iron backing abrades easily, leaving only a small amount of hard steel to hone.

The common denominator here is that sharpening is easiest and fastest when there is least steel to remove, and that when there is a significant amount to grind away (such as correcting for a chip), then the method you use does not become another major task in itself.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Do I need a grinder

#12

Re: Do I need a grinder

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Charles, note that Steve in that video is not using the Sellers Method, but the Grimsdale Method. The difference is that Sellers starts the bevel at the highest angle and then drops away on the grind stroke. Grimsdale (or the video - perhaps Steve got it wrong) starts at a low angle away from the bevel and lifts the grind angle as he strokes towards the bevel. The Sellers method is safest as it keeps some check on the bevel angle.

For the record, Steve (who made that video 12 months ago) posts about his sharpening journey (I think he is a beginner), and now seems to prefer a hollow grind on diamond stones.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Do I need a grinder

#13

Re: Do I need a grinder

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Yes, you do. And a bandsaw. Minimum.

Wiley

Re: Do I need a grinder

#14

NO

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You certainly don't need a grinder. I have tools that I have maintained for more than 40 years without a grinder.

In general, the more skilled you are the less you need coarse sharpening media. Toshio Odate says that if 1200 grit is not adequate as a coarse stone, then you have waited too long to sharpen. I start with either an 800 stone or with a Washita stone, which is considerably finer. You may want something in the 600- 800 range for when you have gone too long without sharpening.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#15

Re: Do I need a grinder

Patrick Gibbons

You don't need it, in the sense that it won't bring your work to a crashing halt without it, but you can justify it. I didn't have one for years, mainly because I wanted to spend my money on other things first. I got along well without it. A friend gave me one about five years ago. I still haven't used it though I keep thinking I'm going to. Once I use it I'll probably wonder what took me so long. I also have need of a grinder for other uses in the future. For one, there are a lot of old tools I need to rehab that I've put off doing because of time involved. It's all a balance of time, money and skill.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#16

Re: Do I need a grinder

CStanford

The video is not posted to capture a particular woodworking personality (or his or her 'journey'), rather, simply illustrating a method of honing that does not require a grinder, which the video does well.

That particular fellow's having left the method for whatever reason isn't a commentary on honing convex bevels which was obviously used, a lot, in times past.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#17

Re: Do I need a grinder

CStanford

And if you've ever been in a room when a grinding wheel comes apart, much less standing at the wheel (I wasn't thankfully) the whole things becomes much less a philosophical argument.

Anybody reading this -- turn on the grinder and let it run for at least a minute or two before you put tool to wheel.

Inspect your wheel. Use a name brand wheel. Wear eye protection, full face shield is even better.

Be careful.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#18

Opening doors and expanding horizons

Bob Hackett

Each and every tool I make or buy is evaluated in relationship to how much further it will take me in my work and/or the new directions it will allow my work to move or expand into.

I see the context of your present question being; do I need a grinder to properly sharpen my tools? The answer to your question viewed in that context is simple. No, you don`t.

If you change the context a bit and tweak it to read ; "Will owning and using a grinder make it easier and faster to properly sharpen my tools, especially old and used tools"? The answer to that question is yes, you will see the benefit from owning and using a grinder.

A powered grinder (in it`s many forms) has no equal (except a cutting torch in very skilled hands) when it comes to quickly and efficiently removing metal once you have mastered the skills needed to properly control it. I think if you plan to rehab, modify or make your own tools in the future then you most assuredly will benefit from owning more than one grinder, they are cheap and plentiful as used tools and can be found for stupid cheap money at yard and garage sales, flea markets, etc.

I recommend both an 8 inch bench grinder with an appropriate stone on one end and a bonded Scotchbright (or equivalent) deburring wheel on the other as well as a high quality 4-6 inch right angle grinder with a 5/8-11 shaft, safety glasses AND a faceshield as a starter kit to open the gateway into grinding. Once you get your skill set and control down you`ll understand how incredibly useful these things are and the only regrets you`ll have is not investing the time and money sooner. They will open doors you never even knew existed in both wood and metal working.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#19

Re: Not Surprised..

david weaver

....That he's gone to a hollow grind and a couple of stones.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#20

Re: You don't need one...

david weaver

... but I would much rather have one than not.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#21

Re: Not Surprised..

CStanford

Like I said in my reply to Derek, I was not offering up Mr. Branam's imprimatur, just his video which shows the technique. I don't recall, in fact, that he even says in the video that he uses (or used) the technique exclusively. And I really don't care. He made a nice video.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#22

Re: Not Surprised..

david weaver

Never hurts to have options. Some are in limited space and some do have a phobia to the possibility of loose grit being anywhere in their shop.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#23

Thanks

Tony Wilkins

Thanks for all the input. Digesting it. This next week we're moving into a house where I'll have my shop in the garage -- couldn't get down to the basement where everything was in my old house. Hopefully getting my hands back on tools and wood will help me understand the needs better. It's a tough wait to get back to learning the craft.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#24

deburring wheel question

BillTindall

I see these things in the tool catalogs and have always wondered what they might be good for(other than deburring, DUH) How do you use them. I have never seen one inperson to know what they are like.

Re: Do I need a grinder

#25

Re: deburring wheel question

Bob Hackett

For me they are a much safer alternative to things like wire and buffing wheels, far less likely to snatch things out of your hands and/or toss them.

There are numerous uses for them that David so kindly outlined in his answer to you Bill. The two most useful aspects of them for me personally are; 1- making tools more user friendly by way of very slightly easing edges that my hands and especially fingers come in contact with and 2- maintaining the polish needed to keep rust and corrosion at bay and keeping my tools appearing neat and professional, even if the operator of said tools is less so. :D