Some scientific testing of hide glues
Bill Tindall
The University of Delaware in conjunction with Winterthur has what is likely the best furniture conservation program in the US. They are equipped to do good research and have done so and published the results on comparing the strength and stability of Franklin Liquid Hide Glue and hot hide glue with the variables of temperature and humidity. Using MS snip I copied the conclusions from this study which can be downloaded in its entirety from
http://cool.conservation-us.org/coolaic/sg/wag/1990/WAG_90_buck.pdf

To summarize the Franklin liquid hide glue was stronger than hot hide at 50% relative humidity and substantially weaker at 80 %RH. Metrics at 50%RH were:
Liquid hide bond strength 4000 psi 60% wood failure
Hot hide 3600 psi (failed to not wood failure but it was similar)
Don't use either liquid hide if you live in a high humidity environment and hot hide is not a lot better.



