New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

brush on lacquer

Posts

brush on lacquer

#1

brush on lacquer

eliot d

I brushed on about four coats of it on some nice cherry and used fine sandpaper and 0000 steel wool between coats. The finish is fine. But the fumes were just terrible! Smelled up the whole house(shop in basement.) It's too cold in Maryland now to paint outside. The last time I finished this wood, I used wipe-on poly, which worked beautifully with no particular fume problem. Is there some inherent advantage to lacquer? If not, I'm going back to the poly nest time. What's the answer here?

Re: brush on lacquer

#2

flammability hazard?

Bill Tindall

I don't know about the brush lacquer but the spray stuff has a low flash point which makes it dangerous to use in a confined space. Personally I would not risk it unless the brush stuff is substantially higher flash point.

Re: brush on lacquer

#3

Re: flammability hazard?

Bruce McCrory

Water-type is supposed to be clear-clear--unnatural look. Thinners-type has an amber tint. Professionals seem to prefer getting high. I think the thinners is better--I have Deft finished furniture that is 25 years old and still polishes with steel wool and dust cloth.

Yah, I'd look for something less volatile in your type of closed spaces.

Re: brush on lacquer

#4

Re: brush on lacquer

TomD

I have used the milky stuff that is water based and dries a little ugly/blue. I added a tiny amount of amber tint to it, and that took care of it. It isn't my most fabulous finish on a white wood, but it sprays and is not too bad.

On cherry I prefer to use an oil, or a Malloof, and buff it.

One thing to do with the wipe on is add shellac as a base coat. Use the dark shellac, it will bring out the colour, and it allows you to refinish the wood should that be necessary. Not all plastics overcoat well, and if you need to refinish down the road, or worse still, get some work back to refinish, you will wish you had a barrier coat. This is one good thing about lacquer, new stuff will burn right in. Lacquer is possibly the best protection for the wood for the least weight, which maters with musical instruments. It is also possibly the most beautiful high gloss finish there is, short of something like master level french polish. I don't like high gloss finish, but it sells stuff.

Re: brush on lacquer

#5

Re: brush on lacquer

William Duffield

There are only minor differences between spray-on lacquer and brush-on lacquer. Both are dangerous. You should only use it in a well-ventilated room, preferably with an explosion proof exhaust fan. Wear a well-fitting respirator, one rated for VOCs, and check the expiration date on the filters. (A dust mask is NOT appropriate.) When using lacquer, I always put the respirator on before opening the can. If at any time in the finishing process I can smell the lacquer thinner, I stop, get out and fix the respirator before continuing.

Re: brush on lacquer

#6

Re: brush on lacquer

eliot d

Thanks to all; I think I'll stick to some less volatile stuff for anything fairly large. I think I can get away with small amounts for work at the lathe.

But here are two more more questions:(1) is it ok to put, say, wipe -on poly over the lacquer? (2) can you use lacquer and thinner like shellac and alcohol to do a french polish?

Re: brush on lacquer

#7

Re: (1)???

William Duffield

Why would you want to? Polyurinate just cancels out all the advantages of the lacquer, and you still have all the disadvantages.

I never heard of anyone trying #2, but I wouldn't be surprised if there were some adverse reaction between the mineral oil (an essential ingredient you missed mentioning in your french polish list) and the lacquer and its solvents.

Re: brush on lacquer

#8

Re: (1)???

eliot d

Would you be willing to expand on your comments? What are the advantages of lacquer over poly, and what are the disadvantages of poly? Th only reason I thought about it is that I find the fumes from the lacquer very objectionable. As for the oil in the "french polish", one uses only a small drop or two to lubricate when doing a true french polish. I doubt that it would be a problem.

Re: brush on lacquer

#9

Re: (1)???

William Duffield

It doesn't make sense to put poly over lacquer, because the volatile solvents in the lacquer must all vaporize before the lacquer can cure. After it has cured, sealing the nitrocellulose with poly won't reduce the odors one iota.

Further, I don't know if there would be problems with the poly binding to the lacquer. FWIW, that would require some testing. If you want to do it, go ahead, but I'm not convinced it will give you any generally useful information.

As far as the advantages and disadvantages of poly vs. lacquer (beyond the toxicity and flammability of lacquer's solvents) those have been well documented many times and in many places. The main points are: hardness vs. toughness; repairability (lacquer is easy, while poly is not); refractive index (poly is much higher, which is why furniture covered with it looks like it came from Mattel instead of a tree :D ); colorants (metal complex dyes, TransTint, for example, can be readily added to lacquer [or shellac], but are very difficult to add to poly or any oil-based finish).

It's not the quantity of the oil in the French polish that is the issue. The oil has interactions with the wax in the shellac, as well as the resin (bug spit) and the carrier (ethanol, mostly) to effect the polish's qualities. These interactions are totally changed if you are dealing with different resins and different solvents. As I understand it, the mineral oil does not mix (is not miscible with) the ethanol or any of its denaturants, but I have no idea how it reacts with the mixture of solvents that you might find in lacquer thinner. Some of these interactions may have a deleterioous effect on the lubricating properties of the oil. The mineral oil, being a petroleum distillate, will mix in any proportion with the wax in shellac. I suspect this property is very important to the French polish process. As with any other finishing schedule you may be contemplating, you would be well advised to test it out on some scrap, and take detailed notes. If it works, please let us know.

I am not very good at French polishing, and have had mixed results, and I am definitely not an expert on the process, so please take anything I have suggested here with a grain of salt.

Re: brush on lacquer

#10

Refractive indices and semantics

John in NM

I've argued this before, I know, but it is a vast over simplification to simply chalk up the difference in appearance to the refractive index. The difference between the materials is only RI 0.1 - 0.2, and just in terms of RI that is hardly even noticeable to most casual viewers.

More important than RI is poly's tendancy to have an amber color and form a thicker film than lacquer.

From most users point of view though, this is all a moot point. The two materials do tend to look very different, most people don't really care much about why they do.