New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Why good glue is tough and flexible

Posts

Why good glue is tough and flexible

#1

Why good glue is tough and flexible

Bill Tindall

A short discussion of polymer chemistry as it relates to glue and cooking-

To introduce the topic consider two experiments. First, leave a sheet of polyethyene out in the sun. After some time, more in MN and less in FL, it will become brittle and easily broken. Why is it so incredibly tough when new and frail when exposed to the sun?

Crack a fresh egg and "pour" some of the white over the edge of the shell (for cooks, separate the white from the yoke). At first a long string of egg white will hang over the lip of the shell. When this hanging part gets large, and therefore heavy enough, it will fall and pull the rest of the white out of the shell. The white behaves like it is sticking together, and it is. Compare this behavior to water.

Now consider a plate full of spaghetti and a second plate full of rice. Now using your hands divide what is on each plate into two portions without breaking apart either the rice grains or the spaghetti strands. It is easy for the rice. It is hard to impossible for the spaghetti....because.....the long spaghetti strands are ENTANGLED with one another.

Tip each plate to slowly pour off its contents. The rice acts like water. You can start and stop the flow at will. But the spaghetti acts like the egg white. First some of it hangs off the edge of the plate and then the whole mass is pulled off the plate, again, because the strands of spaghetti are entangled with one another, while the rice is not.

The lesson to be learned- Things that are long and skinny- hair, fishing line, garden hoses, spaghetti and polymer molecules- can get entangled and be hard to impossible to separate without breaking the strands.

If the food part of this discussion is understood there is only a bit of chemistry necessary to understand why bad glue is brittle, and good glue is tough and will make strings. First, everything is made up of molecules. The stuff we call a polymer, which in wood working includes glue and many finishes as well as wood, and plastic chisel handles, is different from other stuff because the molecules in a polymer are extremely long and thin like spaghetti except even 100 times longer compared to their diameter. Second, the force required to break a molecule apart is huge compare to the force required to simply separate two molecules touching. Small touching molecules are easily to separate. Entangled molecules must be broken to separate them and that takes great force.

Egg white is a protein just like hide glue. If one pulls on a portion of egg white “strings” of egg white can be pulled (or drizzled) because the long protein molecules are entangled with one another. Pulling on one molecule pulls on the whole mass, just like the plate of spaghetti.

Entanglement is not all or none. Things can be entangled more or less, leading to more or less tough. For example, “UHMW” polyethyene stands for “ultra high molecular weight”. Because its molecules are longer they tangle more thoroughly and this leads to a tougher stronger material.

A polymer is like the plate of spaghetti where each strand of spaghetti is a single polymer molecule and these spaghetti molecules are all tangled up with one another. Or, if you understand how felt is made, a polymer is like felted wool where the tangled wool fibers are analogous to the polymer molecules. To break a polymer apart involves breaking apart the polymer molecules and that takes great force. Hence the polymer is strong and tough, like polyethylene, felt and good glue. If something like sun light or bacteria breaks the polymer molecules into small pieces (chop up the spaghetti as some misguided parents do) these small pieces can no longer entangle and the molecules are easily separated. What once was a tough solid now becomes a brittle mass of small molecules.

“Bad Glue” is glue where the polymer molecules have been broken by sun or bacteria or some chemical process. The resulting parts can no longer tangle. As a result the mass is brittle, and it cannot pull a “string” like the egg white.

To sum up the concept. Paraffin wax and polyethylene are chemically identical. The wax molecules are small and short like rice. The polyethyene molecules are like extremely long spaghetti and hence entangled. The differences in properties between wax and the plastic polyethylene are due to entanglement of the longer molecules in polyethyene. (all plastics are polymers)

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#2

Robert Tutsky

Very interesting, thanks Bill.


Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#3

Well said

Curt Putnam

Thank you

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#4

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

TomD

I don't have a problem with that. I once submitted the same polymers project work for something like 3-6 grades.

What is not scientific is words like tough and brittle. The problem is, based on over 30 years of boat building with epoxy, and trips to the Gougeon headquarters, and several million tech post. :) One man's brittle, is another man's tough. And many people thing soft is tough and tough is brittle when dealing with actual glues. They also think there are situations where soft is "tougher" because there is something that moves. So you get all the statements about vinyl glues maybe holding up better in various wood movement scenarios. Or softer epoxies being better if on a flexy deck. You would get better overall results if every time you had a glue selection option you just went for the harder one. Pretty much something anyone can judge with their fingernail.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#5

You forgot impact resistance

Bob Hackett

And a few other factors such as UV (Bill touched on this one),moisture, solvent, stain and heat resistant.

A couple of other factors that come to mind and should be considered are compatibility with the intended finish and ease of repair or removal.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#6

Toughness is precisely defined

Bill Tindall

Materials science definition "In materials science and metallurgy, toughness is the ability of a material to absorb energy and plastically deform without fracturing. Material toughness is defined as the amount of energy per volume that a material can absorb before rupturing. It is also defined as the resistance to fracture of a material when stressed."

Toughness of any commercial plastic can be found tabulated in the materials specifications for said plastic. Toughness can be measured in various ways and the tabulation will include how it was measured, typically by one or more ASTM test.

Polymer molecules are present in a material as randomcoils, like what one would get by depositing a wad of rope on the floor. These coils act as "springs" to absorb impact which is why high molecular weight (meaning long and highly entangled) plastics are highly impact resistant(tough), and not brittle. If the polymer/plastic is degraded and the molecules become short there is less entanglement and the plastic becomes brittle(not tough).

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#7

Re: Toughness is precisely defined

TomD

I agree it is a defined term, which doesn't help at all. It just means for those who speak English there is an additional meaning to contend with. Do you correct every person who compliments the "grain" in one of your projects.

What I am saying is that to be understood, and to determine those glues that are preferable from others, structurally (there can be a lot of other reasons for choosing a glue), you will hardly ever go wrong selecting the harder glue in dried form.

Impact resistance is rarely the issue, unless you make hockey sticks. Well OK teenagers in the house... I would guess I make more high impact woodwork than most of you. I make bows, arrows, and boats, etc... You will not go wrong with any of those by selecting for hardness. But what you will find is a lot of people who think because bows bend, etc... the more flexible the glue the better. They may not be considering that the heavy lifting is being done by glass, in those products.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#8

Hardness in relation to what?

Bob Hackett

What standard, scale or baseline are we supposed to be comparing this "hardness" to?

It has been my experience that the word "hard" and it`s derivatives is not at all useful unless the standard of measure or reference point is given along with it.

It`s like saying you need to choose a glue that will give you a strong bond.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#9

need to pick a nit - brittle isn't weak

Chris Friesen

The term "brittle" means that a material will break without significant deformation. It does not mean "weak".

Thus, hide glue is more brittle than PVA, but it's essentially equivalent in strength.

You don't always want your glue to be flexible. For bent laminations you actually want a brittle (but strong) glue, since it will resist creep better. This is why people generally use urea formeldehyde or epoxy rather than PVA for this purpose.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#10

Re: need to pick a nit - brittle isn't weak

TomD

Bingo. The glue line is very fine, so brittle in that dimension is actually flexible, like a glass fiber.

Re: Why good glue is tough and flexible

#11

brittle isn't weak, but it could be

Bill Tindall

Brittle fracture is just that. There is no implication of how tough the material is. Indeed it is toughness that is important in an adhesive.

To be precise: When a polymer's molecular weight (molecule size) is too small either because it was made that way or it became that way through degradation it will loose toughness and break by brittle fracture.

When dealing with polymers their response to stress depends on the rate with which it applied. It has to do with the tangled up plate of spaghetti being able to untangle some without breaking the molecules if the force to separate it is applied slowly. A polymer may exhibit a brittle fracture as a result of a sharp whack but creep when the stress is applied slowly.