New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

sanding and scraping

Posts

sanding and scraping

#1

sanding and scraping

eliot d

I think I messed up: I used a card scraper to get a fine surface on some nice cherry. Then, for some strange reason, I decided to sand it very fine. Then , for even stranger reasons, I went ahead and scraped it some more. So now the wood is really smooth; but I can see a kind of whitish haze in it. I'm figuring it's very fine sanding dust that got into the pores because of my ridiculous approach. When I wet it slightly, it looks perfectly all right. What do you think? Do I have to start over?

Re: sanding and scraping

#2

depends on the finish

Bill Tindall

I sand everything as does every furniture maker I know of. While it may be a source of some satisfaction to produce lustrous freshly planed or scraped surfaces, they don't look any different from an expertly sanded surface after a finish is applied that has any build to it. Minimalist finishes may respond different.

The best advice is to not do finish research on the furniture. Develop a surface preparation-finish schedule on an equivalent piece of wood and when you are satisfied with the materials and execution then apply what is learned to the furniture.

Every time I think I am too experienced to follow this advice I get screwed by my impatience.

Re: sanding and scraping

#3

PS

Bill Tindall

I didn't answer your question , at least directly. Apply finish and see if you are satisfied with the result.

Re: sanding and scraping

#4

Re: depends on the finish

eliot d

What a sensible response! I know you're right; but I'll probably keep screwing around each time. (This is especially true when I finish pieces on the lathe because it's so easy to just rag stuff on.)

Getting back to the flat cherry, I do know that wipe on poly does work beautifully on this particular wood because I have used it before-- and it's from the same piece of lumber. So to take your advice , I suppose I should use that. (Multiple coats with 0000 steel wood between the coats.) Thanks for your help.

Re: sanding and scraping

#5

Re: depends on the finish

TomD

I agree with Bill.

One mark of the professional, or competent, is no wasted steps. There is a tendency to repeat steps, or to not complete a whole step across the whole piece. Sometimes it does not mater, at other times it is critical to keeping forward progress.

In general sanding follows scraping if the scraping leaves a poor surface or an uneven on. Of course, one does not always need to sand.

In your particular case I do not see anything wrong with the outcome, other than wasted time, and potentially an incomplete process. Many woods benefit from a filling of the surface with sanding dust. Cherry does not normally require it. I'm surprised that scraping would leave any dust in the project pores from sanding.

Re: sanding and scraping

#6

Re: depends on the finish

Ron Harper

I have seen a couple of demonstrations on some woods that would argue with you. I could see a distinct difference. Now, I will agree that 98. 672 percent of folks would not. You have to be looking for it. On red oak and cherry and kiln dried walnut, it woul not matter. On some woods with interesting figure, it does

Re: sanding and scraping

#7

Use a tack cloth and clean off the dust